Making Your Money Last

Is 4% Withdrawal Rate Still a Good Retirement Rule of Thumb?

We put the popular theory to the test using 30 years of real-world stock market returns. Here's what we found.

The general guideline of withdrawing no more than 4% of your portfolio each year during retirement has come under fire as of late. This guideline was the result of a study conducted almost 30-years ago by William Bengen, at a time when it was believed that 5% was a safe withdrawal rate. In the study William determined that 5% was too risky, and proposed the change to 4%.

But is 4% still a good rule of thumb, as Bengen concluded? I believe the answer is “probably.” The reality in retirement is a little more complex, however, so it takes a little more planning than just using a rule of thumb to help ensure your peace of mind during retirement. Not getting the withdrawal rate correct means running out of money, and we can’t afford that.

The Basics of the 4% Rule

Here’s how the 4% rule works. If you take your investment portfolio at retirement and multiply it by 4%, that is how much you can safely withdraw each year without running out of money. The rule also assumes that you’ll give yourself a 3% raise each year by slowly increasing your withdrawals to cover inflation.

Let’s test the rule by assuming you retired 30 years ago, on Jan. 1, 1989:

You may remember 1989. Michael Jordan scored his 10,000th point; the San Francisco 49ers won their third Super Bowl; Dustin Hoffman won the Oscar for his role in the movie Rainman; George H.W. Bush became the president; there were pro-democracy protests in China’s Tiananmen Square; and Exxon’s Valdez tanker spilled over 11 million gallons of oil off of Alaska’s shoreline.

Let’s say that you followed the 4% rule and happened to be fortunate enough to have a million-dollar investment portfolio in 1989 (which would be equivalent to $2.4 million today). While $1 million would have been a lot in 1989, we are not testing the dollar amount but rather the percentage. $1 million is just an easy round number to work with. We can apply the percentage to any dollar amount.

Analyzing the 4% Rule with Real-World Numbers

So here is our investment plan. We are going to take the $1 million and invest half into stocks and half into bonds using the Vanguard 500 Index Fund (VFINX) and the Dodge and Cox Income Fund (DODIX). We are going to rebalance the portfolio every six months. During year one we’ll assume that you withdraw and spend $40,000. In year two we’ll assume that due to rising prices you’ll need to withdraw 3% more, or $41,200. We’ll assume you’ll continue to withdraw 3% more each year.

So how did you do? Did you get good advice? The first chart shows that your $1 million ended up at $5.9 million even after spending $1.9 million over the 30 years from 1989-2018. During that period the portfolio would have averaged 8.95%. So, if we had a repeat of the past 30 years we’d conclude that you could actually spend much more (as much as $60,000, adjusted for 3% inflation).

In the chart below I carved up the past 30 years into three decades so we can test our portfolio using the results of starting with a good or a bad decade. For example, in the first test your portfolio takes advantage of the technology run-up in the first 10 years from 1989-1998, which really helps over the long-term. Note, however, that things change a little if we flip the order of each of the three decades and re-test. Here are the annualized returns of each decade:

  • 1989-1998: 14.09% per year
  • 1999-2008: 2.59% per year
  • 2009-2018: 9.45% per year

In each test the portfolio ends up with a large balance. You didn’t run out of money.

Getty Images

Click here to see full image.

Now let’s see what would have happened had you followed the conventional wisdom of 1989 and withdrew 5% each year, adjusted for the same 3% inflation? You’ll see in the next chart that you still would have been able to withdraw even more investing from 1989-2018. If we flip the decades, however, and your performance during the first decade looked like that of 1999-2008, you would have run out of money.

Getty Images

Click here to see full image.

Based on the past 30 years we could conclude that 4% was a safe withdrawal rate, and good advice at the time — and even 5% was mostly safe. Of course, “mostly safe” isn’t a good way to plan. The author of the original study has modified his conclusion now, and has increased his safe withdrawal rate to 4.5% when holding a more diversified portfolio. Note, however, that you may be comfortable with a withdrawal rate closer to 5% of your investment portfolio if you have a lot of equity in your home that you aren’t opposed to tapping into if your investments run out (by downsizing, taking a reverse mortgage, etc.).

The problem with this type of testing is that retirement spending doesn’t go exactly as outlined, spending exactly 3% more each and every year. Oftentimes there is a need for higher withdrawals in some years and lower ones in others for things like replacing a car or handling unexpected health care expenses. The 4% rule is a good place to start, but I believe that further planning is needed.

To Ease Your Mind, Test Your Plan in Many Ways

With so many variables, I suggest updating your financial plan every six months and exploring lots of “what if” scenarios. For example, what if you live longer, spend more or less for different periods of time, have higher or lower returns, spend time in a nursing home, buy a car, experience higher or lower inflation, etc.? By throwing lots of curve balls at your portfolio you can see what your range of withdrawals can be as you compare scenarios, as opposed to a fixed withdrawal percentage. In addition, using a Monte Carlo analysis with each curve ball you throw at your portfolio will give you more precise results. As you review your numbers you may decide to cut withdrawals in some years and increase them in others.

In the end, after reviewing many scenarios and comparing the results, you’ll be able to pinpoint a comfortable withdrawal amount for each year. Doing this will provide you with peace of mind, knowing that you won’t run out of money before you run out of life — the ultimate goal of retirement planning.

About the Author

Ray E. LeVitre, CFP®

Founder, Managing Partner, Net Worth Advisory Group

Ray LeVitre is an independent fee-only Certified Financial Adviser with over 20 years of financial services experience. In addition he is the founder of Net Worth Advisory Group and the author of "20 Retirement Decisions You Need to Make Right Now."

Most Popular

Your Guide to Roth Conversions
Special Report
Tax Breaks

Your Guide to Roth Conversions

A Kiplinger Special Report
February 25, 2021
11 Best Healthcare Stocks for the Rest of 2021
healthcare stocks

11 Best Healthcare Stocks for the Rest of 2021

The 2020s could be the decade of healthcare stocks. Here are 10 companies and one ETF to watch not just for the remainder of this year, but well beyon…
July 13, 2021
What Is the Social Security COLA?
retirement

What Is the Social Security COLA?

For the average recipient, the 2021 monthly increase doesn't even cover a fill-up at the gas station — but it beats nothing.
July 14, 2021

Recommended

33 States with No Estate Taxes or Inheritance Taxes
retirement

33 States with No Estate Taxes or Inheritance Taxes

Even with the federal exemption from death taxes raised, retirees should pay more attention to estate taxes and inheritance taxes levied by states.
July 26, 2021
10 Least Tax-Friendly States for Retirees
retirement

10 Least Tax-Friendly States for Retirees

When it comes to state and local taxes, retirees in these states are likely to pay more than retirees in other states.
July 26, 2021
10 Most Tax-Friendly States for Retirees
retirement

10 Most Tax-Friendly States for Retirees

If you want your retirement savings to last longer, consider moving to one of these states that impose the lowest taxes on retirees.
July 26, 2021
Taxes in Retirement: How All 50 States Tax Retirees
Tax Breaks

Taxes in Retirement: How All 50 States Tax Retirees

We rated every state, plus Washington, D.C., on how retirees are taxed. We considered taxes on Social Security and other retirement income, tax exempt…
July 26, 2021