U.S. & Global Economies

Double-Digit Unemployment
Through 2010

Everyone’s talking jobs these days — the government included. But only time can bring them back.

By Jerome Idaszak, Associate Editor, The Kiplinger Letter

November 20, 2009
Text Size T T

Advertisement

Jobs are on everyone’s mind these days as unemployment climbs despite economic growth. Elected officials of all stripes are feeling the heat from their constituents.

There’s not a lot Washington can do, and a Dec. 3 White House summit meeting with CEOs, union leaders, small business owners, economists and others is likely to yield few fresh ideas and fewer real results. On the table: Extending unemployment benefits again, giving businesses a tax credit for hiring new workers and additional federal spending on infrastructure, maybe in the form of new federal highway legislation. But both Congress and the White House will be inclined to avoid costly measures that would swell the budget deficit -- on course to top $1.5 trillion this fiscal year.

Related Links


Only time will cure the problem -- time for a gradual revival of credit markets and for a climate shift. In today’s risk-averse environment, few firms are willing to expand, betting on a better tomorrow. And for those that are willing, financing is tight -- either by government fiat (tougher lending standards) or because lenders have become supercautious. That’s especially true for small businesses, where most job creation takes place.

The fact is, unemployment will get worse before it gets better, rising to about 10.5% next spring, then hovering around 10% through the end of the year. Just to hold that rate steady, total employment needs to grow by about 125,000 jobs a month, absorbing young folks seeking their first job plus new immigrants. That’s a long way from the 190,000 jobs lost in October.

Indeed, it will be next spring before the long slide of job losses comes to an end, with businesses hiring more people than they fire. Total employment for 2010 will probably increase by only about 1 million.

One reason: There’s still plenty of room for businesses to increase production and handle new orders without putting new workers on the payroll. They can switch part-timers to full-time and lengthen the workweek, now at a 45-year low. According to economist Daniel Meckstroth of the Manufacturers Alliance/MAPI, manufacturers have enough slack to boost production 5% in 2010 without having to hire.

The best prospects for job growth are in health care, a field that has kept increasing despite the recession, adding 234,000 jobs so far this year. Passage of a major health care bill by Congress will only add to demand for nurses, pharmacists, home health care aides and technical assistants.

Another early winner: The energy industry, with increasing need for engineers in nuclear, wind and solar power. Expect more demand as well for human resources professionals to advise companies on new hiring and retaining existing workers. And lawyers, accountants and consultants should enjoy a stronger market for their services as the economy recovers. Even hard-hit manufacturing will see some gains, mostly in food processing, pharmaceuticals and medical equipment.

Trailing the pack will be construction, retailing and finance, although there are new jobs stemming from the effort to modify thousands of delinquent mortgages.

The bottom line: It will take years to return to prerecession employment totals, rehiring the nearly 8 million folks who have been laid off, plus the 1.5 million new workers who enter the labor market each year. And that doesn’t take into account the 9 million part-time workers who want to hold down a full-time job.

For weekly updates on topics to improve your business decisionmaking, click here

Discuss

Reader Comments (9)

Posted by: Nomen at 11/22/2009 11:23:47 AM

"Theres not a lot Washington can do". After 30 years of unfair trade agreements, easing regulations on business, rampant illegal immigration, outsourcing and betraying American workers. It looks like they have done enough already. Hopefully, just extending unemployment benefits and a few more infrastructure projects will keep the American workers docile.

Posted by: SaintLouis at 11/23/2009 09:32:22 AM

There is not a lot that our government will be willing to do. After decades in which the big labor unions have destroyed the work ethic and our capability to compete, it is not surprising that we have such high unemployment. The answer is to do what should have been done decades ago, and that is to break up the unions and let companies hire workers without fear of the big unions destroying the company. And the feds need to stop all the payments to big labor via bailouts.

Posted by: Blakely at 11/23/2009 11:30:49 AM

My sentiments coincide with Nomen. There is no political will to make any genuine efforts to resolve the underlying causes of high unemployment; and special interest groups relentlessly continue to ensure that our elected officials maintain the status quo.

Posted by: Eric at 11/23/2009 01:44:35 PM

The job creation for Heath Care is a farce! The type of health care legislation currently being proposed CUTS reimbursement rates and creates more eligible recipients. The amount paid by recipient per health care professional will greatly drop and in order to make up for the difference, case loads will double. Therefore, job creation will not occur and could possibly get worse. As far as pharmaceutical growth, this will too drop as the amounts paid will diminish dispensing fees and thus cause everyone to use mail-order facilities or mass distribution cites. Sad to say, your local pharmacy will be a story from the past. It was nice to live in a time that you had choices now that the government will take that away.

Posted by: marc at 11/25/2009 09:02:34 AM

Given that the Obama admin and the democratic agenda has caused this whole mess, I'd have to say that we have nothing to look forward to for at least 3 more years. I for one am fed up. Time to get out the pitchforks and torches before their agenda completes the destruction of the country.

Posted by: Maury H at 11/25/2009 09:16:47 PM

It would be nice if Kiplinger Editors would review the 2000 page Senate and the whatever page House legislation and ferret out the hidden ridiculous paragraphs that congress is trying to hide from the voters. Every one I have talked to recently is ready to throw the bums out. They are totally in denial and only trying to save the democratic party from a huge embarrassment - forgetting their home voters. Kiplinger Editors can you ferret out the nonsense and report it or is that against your editorial policy? Or do you not have the resources to report such? Thanks!

Posted by: Bruce Allen at 11/26/2009 01:38:10 PM

So unemployment will be with us for some time. I'm shocked! Let's review. The 1980's and 1990's lead to a great deal of excess and abuse. Idiotic spending in Washington. Employees accepting, without question, benefits packages that were as far from prudent as one could imagine. Promises, promises. The American worker thought he/she got a great deal when the 401k was added to their benefits package. Well, Enron and Worldcom and all of the other debacles have demonstrated the vulnerability of that benefit. I won't even go into the "back-dated" stock options issue. What we have now is the results of misplaced trust. We got what we paid for. We the people placed our faith in people and in institutions that, while not corrupt, required close scrutiny. When then President Reagan was in talks with Soviet Premier Gorbachev over strategic arms limitation, Reagan was asked by a reporter if he trusted the Soviets to live up to their end of the deal. President Reagan responded with, " Trust but verify ". How many of us followed that advice in regards to our benefits and our retirement funds? Not many. We got what we paid for. Now we have to move on and make the best of a bad situation.

Posted by: scott at 11/29/2009 02:24:39 AM

10/4 I have been on UI bennifits for 12 months need another year or so to make it Just extending unemployment benefits and a few more infrastructure projects will keep the American workers docile.

Posted by: Laidoff Healthcare at 12/01/2009 11:01:25 AM

Health care is gonna be hiring? Really? I got laid off from health care due to declining reimbursements and the new taxes imposed by the state (Ohio). I even tripled revenue in the departments I was responsible for in 3 years and increased reimbursement from 48% to 99% in 2 years. Yesterday, in my health care field, 1 job existed in the state of Ohio, and it was located 230 miles away paying 60% of what I was making. Yes I am glad the government is helping us out, afte rall, the government can't take care of itself.....

Today's Video More Videos >>

Save Money in February

E-mail Alerts: Select the Kiplinger columns and topics to be delivered to your inbox:

Advertisement