What to Put in a Safe Deposit Box

Social Security Card

Should your Social Security number fall into the hands of an identity thief,  start of years of headaches follow as you are forced to file disputes, freeze accounts and monitor credit reports for signs of financial fraud. It’s why we rank the Social Security card among the worst things to keep in your wallet (opens in new tab) in case it’s ever lost or stolen.

Stow your Social Security card in your safe deposit box. On the rare occasions when you actually might need to produce it, say, for a real estate closing, you can plan to retrieve the card. Then immediately return it to the bank vault. Meantime, memorize the number, if you haven’t already, for filling out routine paperwork.

Birth, Marriage, Divorce and Death Certificates

Vital records that are rarely needed but a hassle to replace are prime candidates for your safe deposit box. These include birth certificates, death certificates, marriage certificates and divorce certificates. Ditto for adoption-related documents; in particular, birth certificates from an overseas adoption are extremely difficult to replace if lost or destroyed.

Government agencies typically can issue certified copies of vital records, but it’ll cost you time, money and a lot of frustration. You’ll also need to provide proof that you are entitled to copies. Virginia, for example, charges $12 per certified record (versus $34 in California and $53 in New York), and it can take weeks to receive the document by mail. Expedited delivery through a third-party service called VitalChek (opens in new tab) is an option, but you'll pay a surcharge (it varies) per certified record, including service fee; add on the cost of what the state charges you as well as shipping fees. 

Paper Stock and Bond Certificates

Stock and bond ownership bookkeeping and transactions is handled electronically these days, but there was a time in the not-too-long-ago when actual paper certificates were issued to investors. The New York Stock Exchange eliminated its requirement for physical certificates in 2001, and paper savings bonds haven’t been available from banks since 2011. In a twist, however, you can use your federal tax refund to purchase paper Series I U.S. Savings Bonds (opens in new tab) directly from the U.S. Treasury in $50 increments. Include IRS Form 8888 (opens in new tab) with your tax return to request the paper savings bonds.

Some paper certificates, many of which are intricately engraved, and sometimes, works of art, are still floating around. If you have any of your own or receive any as an inheritance, secure them in your safe deposit box until you can determine the actual value. This is especially true if you don’t recognize the name of the corporation on the certificate. The security could be worth more than you think if the stock later split or the original corporation merged with a bigger company. The Securities and Exchange Commission recommends contacting the transfer agent listed on the certificate for information. You can also try your broker or the relevant state agency that handles incorporations. Finally, even if you discover that the certificate has no investment value, it might be worth something as a collectible. Check out Scripophily.com (opens in new tab).

Personal Papers

Sentimental value counts as well when deciding which personal papers to stash in your safe deposit box. Items like diaries from your youth, cherished letters from friends and family members, drawings by your young children or the unpublished memoir of a long-dead relative can benefit from the protection of a safe deposit box. Yes, these personal papers can (and should) be scanned as a backup, but there’s no replacing the connection that comes with holding in your own hands something meaningful from your past.

Experts recommend using a safe deposit box for difficult-to-replace or irreplaceable documents.

Family Photos

Probably most of your recent photos are snug in the cloud, so your latest selfie is safe even if you lose your smartphone. But what about those precious old photos of, say, childhood vacations or relatives long gone? Much like personal papers, you’d be wise to store family photos with sentimental value in your safe deposit box, along with any negatives you may possess.

Don’t stop there. Scan the photos (opens in new tab), copy the files onto a thumb drive, and store that drive in your safe deposit box, too. Another backup option: Upload the digital copies to the cloud-storage solution of your choice. One of the membership benefits of Amazon Prime, for instance, is unlimited digital photo storage. If you own an Apple device, you get 5 gigabytes of iCloud storage for free, with the option to purchase additional space.

Collectibles

How often do you really look at the rare coins you collected in high school or the that stamp collection your grandfather gave you as a child? Or how about your dad’s baseball cards (opens in new tab) including a signed Mickey Mantle? Probably infrequently.

Collectibles like these that are valuable and hard to replace are strong candidates for storage in a safe deposit box – but only if they’re insured. Remember: Neither your bank nor the FDIC insures your stored possessions, and the off-premises coverage provided by your homeowners insurance typically has very low limits for collectibles. One option? Contact your insurer to see if the coverage limits of your current policy can be raised.

Jewelry

One more time: Your bank and the FDIC still aren't insuring the contents of your safe deposit box. And as with collectibles, the standard coverage offered by your homeowners policy for jewelry stored in a safe deposit box will be modest at best. Insurance experts recommend adding a personal articles floater to your insurance portfolio. This supplemental policy provides added coverage for specified valuables. You’ll likely need to get written appraisals of the value of each piece of jewelry for insurance purposes.

Jewelry you wear regularly doesn’t belong in a safe deposit box, which can only be accessed during a bank’s normal business hours. Keep everyday jewelry in a secure place at home such as a safe. But the pricey heirloom jewelry that perhaps you inherited but rarely wear should stay in your safe deposit box until a special occasion arises and you can pick it up, wear it for the big event, and put it back safely.

Insurance Home Inventory

Speaking of insurance, it’s a smart move to keep an inventory of all the belongings in your home safely tucked away in your safe deposit box. Should disaster ever strike, the home inventory will be invaluable when it comes to filing insurance claims. And, of course, a home inventory kept at home won’t do you much good if the house burns down, floods or gets flattened by a tornado.

Another tip (and here's where a thumb drive comes in handy): Supplement your written inventory with visuals – the more detail the better. Include photos and videos. As the saying goes, “a picture is worth a thousand words.”

Property Records

Anyone who's purchased real estate is familiar with the piles of paperwork that accompany the transaction. In general, it’s a good idea to keep these documents as long as you own the property and even beyond when you sell, though in truth you might never need any of them. But in the event you ever do, having the peace of mind that many years later you can track down a needed document in your safe deposit box is worth it.

Settlement documents including the closing statement detail how much you paid for the property. Some of these costs are deductible on your tax return, and proof of the purchase price is essential when you sell and need to calculate taxes on your profit. The original property survey can come in handy if a dispute ever arises with a neighbor over property lines. The deed showing property ownership is typically recorded by your local government and made available as a public record. If you can’t find a needed document related to a home purchase, try contacting your agent or the title company that handled the closing.

Car Titles

A car or truck title is rarely needed and a pain to replace; in other words, it’s a document that’s perfectly suited to be stored in your safe deposit box. The only time you’re likely to retrieve it is when you’re ready to sell the vehicle and literally sign over the title to the buyer. The only other time is if you decide to take out a short-term title loan, though in our opinion there are better ways to get extra cash (opens in new tab) than putting your car up as collateral.

If you lose your car title you will have to visit your state’s department of motor vehicles (and that might require an appointment). There will be paperwork, a fee and perhaps a long wait time for your number to be called. If there are no liens and no changes to the title, you might be able to order a replacement copy online.

Records of Home Improvement Costs

If you’ve been a part of this great resettlement and bought a new home and moved during the pandemic, you want that value to hold on. And even if you bought a home 20 years ago, what it’s worth today could be extraordinary, and when you sell your home, you don’t want to pay capital gains taxes. To cover that spread of what you paid for your house and its value today, it’s important you factor in all the home improvements you made over the years – new kitchen, turning the garage into a home office, building out your basement, getting a new garage door, etc. – and store those records in your safe deposit box. That means receipts, designs, tile samples perhaps, and a breakdown of all costs.

An example: Exclusions from the capital gains tax for home sellers are $250,000 for a single owner and $500,000 for a couple. Say that house you bought in 2002 for $200,000 sells for $800,000 in 2023, giving you a profit of $600,000. Back out the $500,000 exclusion and you’re on the hook to pay capital gains tax on that $100,000. To get that profit number down, factor in the cost of all those major home improvements you made over the 20 years.

And the proof of the cost of those improvements? It’s sitting in your safe deposit box if you need to show tax authorities.