credit & debt

Don't Sweat Small Changes in Your Credit Scores

Credit scores typically fluctuate a little from month to month, often because of changes in credit card balances. Here’s what to do when fluctuations in your scores are more dramatic.

Question: Recently my credit score dropped from “exceptional” to “very good.” I put a security freeze on all of my credit reports, and I closed out an auto loan around the same time. Did either of those actions cause my score to drop?

Answer: Neither of those actions is likely to have had an effect on your scores, says credit expert John Ulzheimer, formerly of credit-scoring company FICO and credit bureau Equifax. He advises people to stop worrying about minor changes in credit scores. “There’s a natural migration to your scores, normally 20 to 25 points month over month,” he says. “Your scores should stay within that range and, if so, it means your scores are moving in a normal, healthy manner.”

A credit freeze doesn’t hurt your credit scores, says Ulzheimer. “Security freezes simply restrict access to your credit reports to existing creditors” plus a handful of other parties such as government agencies and collection agencies, he says. “But the scoring systems are still able to see all of your information during the scoring process.” A freeze can help protect you from identity theft, but it can also make some things more complicated—such as applying for insurance or opening a bank account. (See the related article Pitfalls of Freezing Your Credit).

Also, paying off an auto loan doesn’t cause a score to drop, Ulzheimer says. But, he points out, it isn’t likely to help your scores, either, because installment debt has only a small impact on your scores.

Ulzheimer says that small score changes often stem from fluctuations in credit card balances, which cause your debt-to-credit ratios to rise and fall. Nearly 30% of your FICO score (the credit score most lenders use) is based on amounts you owe. Keep an eye on your credit utilization ratio, which is the percentage of available revolving-account credit you’re using. If the total credit limit for all of your credit cards together is $20,000 and you’ve charged $2,000, for example, your utilization ratio is 10%.

Even if you pay the full credit card balance by the payment due date, your utilization ratio won’t necessarily be zero because the ratio is based on the balance your lender reported to the credit bureau—which is usually the balance from your monthly statement. It helps to keep your utilization ratio particularly low for a month or two before you apply for a loan, either by charging very little or by making sure to pay off your balances before they’re reported to the credit bureau. For more information, see the Amounts Owed explanation at MyFico.com.

For more information about credit scores, see How Your Credit Score Is Calculated and MyFico’s credit basics page.

Most Popular

Are You Rich? The Answer May Surprise You
personal finance

Are You Rich? The Answer May Surprise You

Whether you are considered rich depends on how you measure it – and the bar for that is changing. Have a look at the numbers that define who's wealthy…
August 12, 2022
Your Guide to Roth Conversions
Special Report
Tax Breaks

Your Guide to Roth Conversions

A Kiplinger Special Report
February 25, 2021
Save More on Green Home Improvements Under the Inflation Reduction Act
Tax Breaks

Save More on Green Home Improvements Under the Inflation Reduction Act

Tax credits for energy-efficient home improvements are extended and expanded by the Inflation Reduction Act.
August 19, 2022

Recommended

When Will Student Loans Be Forgiven?
Paying for College

When Will Student Loans Be Forgiven?

Millions of Americans are waiting for the Biden Administration’s next hint, which could come later this summer, at how he’ll address the student loan …
July 7, 2022
Financial Advice from America’s Founding Fathers
credit & debt

Financial Advice from America’s Founding Fathers

What money-management guidance can we glean from the words — and experience — of Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, Alexander Hamilton and others?
June 30, 2022
Strategies to Pay Down Your Credit Card Debt
Making Your Money Last

Strategies to Pay Down Your Credit Card Debt

Consider these smart strategies to eliminate or reduce what you owe.
June 17, 2022
Should I Use Credit Card Portals to Book Travel?
credit cards

Should I Use Credit Card Portals to Book Travel?

Your credit card company wants to play travel agent, too. But there are some caveats to consider when booking through a credit card's travel portal.
May 26, 2022