1100 13th Street, NW, Suite 750Washington, DC 20005202.887.6400Customer Service: 800.544.0155
All Contents © 2020The Kiplinger Washington Editors
By Charles Lewis Sizemore, CFA, Contributing Writer
| July 23, 2018Content has been updated to reflect data through Oct. 16, 2019.
Mount Rushmore features massive 60-foot-tall busts of celebrated presidents George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln and Theodore Roosevelt, each chosen for their respective roles in preserving or expanding the Republic.
But if you were to make a Mount Rushmore for presidents based on stock market performance, none of these men would make the cut. There really was no stock market to speak of during the Washington, Jefferson and Lincoln administrations, and Teddy Roosevelt ranks as one of the worst-performing presidents of the past 130 years – at least as far as Wall Street is concerned.
Just for grins, let’s consider what a “stock market Mount Rushmore” might look like. (Yes, a president’s actions aren’t the only thing that moves the stock market, but in many cases throughout history, the commander in chief’s decisions over time significantly contributed to how equities performed.) While we’re at it, we’ll rank every president that we can realistically include based on the available data – and that data includes a few caveats below.*
The following is a ranking of every president since Benjamin Harrison (who, sneak preview, did not do very well) by stock market performance, in order from worst to best.
* Returns data are price only (not including dividends), which tends to favor more recent presidents. Over the past half-century, dividends have become a smaller portion of total returns due to their unfavorable tax treatment. Data is not adjusted for inflation. This will tend to reward presidents of inflationary times (Richard Nixon, Jimmy Carter, Gerald Ford, etc.) and punish presidents of disinflationary or deflationary times (Franklin Delano Roosevelt, George W. Bush, Barack Obama, etc.) Presidents from Hoover to the present are ranked using the Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index, whereas earlier presidents were ranked using the Dow Jones Industrial Average due to data availability.
Courtesy Gage Skidmore via Wikimedia Commons
President: March 4, 1929-March 4, 1933
Market Performance: -30.8% per year
Someone has to be in last place, and that particular shame belongs to Herbert Hoover. President Hoover occupies the bottom rung with a truly abysmal 77.1% cumulative loss and 30.8% annualized compound loss.
In case you need a history refresher, Hoover took office just months before the 1929 crash that ushered in the worst bear market in U.S. history.
That’s rotten luck, but don’t feel too sorry for Hoover. He played his part in bringing about the whole mess. More than a thousand economists signed a letter warning him not to sign the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act into law … yet he did it anyway. This helped to turn what might have been a garden-variety recession into the Great Depression.
That’s on you, Hoover.
Courtesy Eric Draper via Wikimedia Commons
President: Jan. 20, 2001-Jan. 20, 2009
Market Performance: -5.6% per year
In second-to-last place is George W. Bush, with annualized losses of 5.6%. Poor Dubya had the misfortune of taking office just as the dot-com boom of the 1990s went bust and shortly before the Sept. 11, 2001, terror attacks helped to push the economy deeper into recession. If that weren’t bad enough, the 2008 mortgage and banking crisis happened at the tail end of his presidency.
Sandwiched between two of the worst bear markets in U.S. history, Dubya never had a chance.
There were some good market years, of course. Stocks rallied from 2003 to the peak in 2007, briefly surpassing their Clinton-era dot-com highs. These gains were attributable, at least in part, to Bush’s tax and regulatory reforms, which deserve credit.
Alas, Bush also will be remembered for an expensive and controversial war in Iraq and for throwing fiscal restraint out the window with some of the largest budget deficits in history.
Courtesy Library of Congresss Prints and Photographs division via Wikimedia Commons
President: March 4, 1893-March 4, 1897
Market Performance: -4.9% per year
For the bronze-medal loser, we have to go back to the late 1800s and the second presidency of Grover Cleveland.
Most of the poorer-performing presidents had their share of mistakes that helped contribute to the lousy market returns of their presidency. Cleveland, on the other hand, was just unlucky.
By any historical account, he was a responsible president who ran an honest and fiscally sound administration that believed in free trade and sound money. He was respected by voters and by his peers in Washington. But then the Panic of 1893 hit the banking system and led to a deep depression. The fallout was so bad it actually led to a grassroots revolt and a total realignment of the Democratic Party.
After Cleveland fell from grace, the mantle of leadership eventually shifted to Teddy Roosevelt, Woodrow Wilson and William Jennings Bryan, in what is known as the Progressive Era. That, among other things, gave us the Federal Reserve.
Courtesy U.S. National Archives and Records Administration via Wikimedia Commons
President: Jan. 20, 1969-Aug. 9, 1974
Market Performance: -3.9% per year
Stocks did not perform well during the presidency of Richard Nixon, losing 3.9% per year. And it’s worth reminding readers again that these losses were in nominal terms. If you consider the high inflation that was prevalent during his time in office, the real losses would look a lot worse.
“Tricky Dick” generally is considered to be one of the most intelligent men to ever occupy the White House. Alas, following the Watergate scandal, he also was widely considered to be one of the most paranoid and corrupt. Facing certain impeachment, Nixon was forced to resign early in his second term.
But while Nixon’s presidency is most associated with Watergate, the Vietnam War and sweating profusely while on stage, market historians would point out that the most significant event for stock investors was Nixon’s closing of the gold window, which ended the dollar’s convertibility to gold and essentially killed the Bretton Woods system. This helped to usher in the high inflation of the 1970s, which contributed to one of the worst bear markets in history in 1973-74, and for good measure, wrecked the bond market.
Courtesy United States Library of Congresss Prints and Photographs division via Wikimedia Commons
President: March 4, 1889-March 4, 1893
Market Performance: -1.4% per year
Most Americans know very little about President Benjamin Harrison, a one-term president that was sandwiched between Grover Cleveland’s two non-consecutive terms. History buffs might note that he was the grandson of President William Henry Harrison, making them the only grandfather-grandson pair to have held the White House.
Harrison, a protectionist, was a proponent of high tariffs and used the revenue to boost federal spending. He has the distinction – or perhaps shame? – of being the first president to preside over a federal budget of more than $1 billion. His administration also passed the Sherman Antitrust Act, which is the foundation of U.S. competitiveness regulation.
There was no defining recession or calamity in Harrison’s presidency, though the market losses of 1.4% per year under his watch are generally attributed to the effects of the unpopular McKinley Tariff, signed into law by President Harrison.
Courtesy George Grantham Bain via Wikimedia Commons
President: March 4, 1909-March 4, 1913
Market Performance: -0.1% per year
The market didn’t do much of anything under President William Howard Taft’s watch, losing 0.1% per year.
Taft has the distinction of being the only man to serve both as president and, later, as Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. Otherwise, there’s not much to say about him. He was a one-term president who sported a luxuriant mustache that made him look a little like a James Bond villain.
He also was the unfortunate victim of Teddy Roosevelt’s ego. Roosevelt split the Republican vote by running as a third-party candidate, thus paving the way for Woodrow Wilson’s win.
President: Sept. 14, 1901-March 4, 1909
Market Performance: 2.2% per year
Teddy Roosevelt was never supposed to be president. The Republican Party considered him a loose cannon and tried to neutralize him by making him vice president. Well, that was fine and good … until President McKinley was assassinated and the job fell to Roosevelt by default.
Roosevelt is one of America’s more colorful and controversial presidents. He’s fondly remembered as a rugged cowboy for his wartime exploits as a Rough Rider, and he’s the only president from the 1900s to grace Mount Rushmore. He was a walking, breathing symbol of America’s manifest destiny.
Alas, he also had a reputation for being something of a bully and had an ego that was proportionate to his bust on Mount Rushmore. He was best known for expanding the power of the government to aggressively break up industrial monopolies, which in part explains the rather lackluster market returns of 2.2% per year under his presidency.
President: March 4, 1913-March 4, 1921
Market Performance: 3.1% per year
President Woodrow Wilson is probably best-known for serving as president during World War I. But for economic historians, he will forever live in infamy as the president that reinstituted federal income taxes and created an income-tax division within the Bureau of Internal Revenue (which eventually became the Internal Revenue Service). He also introduced the Federal Reserve system, making him one of the most influential presidents in modern history.
Prior to the founding of the Fed and its emergence as a “lender of last resort” to banks suffering short-term liquidity crunches, America’s financial system was extremely susceptible to bank runs and financial crises. For all its perceived faults, the Fed has brought a degree of stability to our system that was previously and sorely absent.
While the world has continued to have its share of crisis in the decades following the Federal Reserve’s creation, it’s difficult to imagine what our system would look like today without a central bank.
That’s great and all. But it’s still hard not the curse Wilson every time April 15 comes around and tax returns are due to the IRS.
President: March 4, 1933-April 12, 1945
Market Performance: 6.2% per year
Franklin Delano Roosevelt was the longest-serving president in U.S. history, having been elected to four terms and serving for just more than 12 years before dying in office. He’s remembered as the president that stewarded the country through the Great Depression and stood up to Nazi Germany and Imperial Japan.
More controversially, he’s also remembered as the president that gave us the New Deal and the massively expanded role of the federal government that came with it.
In Roosevelt’s defense, the economy was already broken when he took office. Hoover’s poor management of the early years of the Great Depression had left a real mess to clean up. However, many economists would argue that Roosevelt’s heavy-handed approach to regulation slowed down the recovery and caused the effects of the Depression to linger far longer than they should have.
That’s open to debate, of course. But it might explain why stock returns were a relatively modest 6.2% per year despite having a low starting point following the 1929 crash and bear market.
President: Jan. 20, 1961-Nov. 22, 1963
Market Performance: 6.5% per year
John F. Kennedy was president for less than three years before he was tragically assassinated in office. But he is fondly remembered by most Americans as the president that inspired them to fly to the moon. He also was famous for his handling of the Cuban Missile Crisis and for presiding over a particularly frosty segment of the Cold War.
Market historians also would point out that Kennedy advocated lower personal and corporate income taxes and generally promoted pro-growth policies. Kennedy believed that lower tax rates would paradoxically lead to higher tax revenues due to higher overall economic activity. This sentiment would later be called the “Laffer Curve” after Art Laffer popularized the concept while serving in Ronald Reagan’s administration.
A bear market early in Kennedy’s term knocked down his average, but stocks still managed to return a respectable 6.5% per year during his time in office.
President: Jan. 20, 1977-Jan. 20, 1981
Market Performance: 6.9% per year
President Jimmy Carter gets blamed for a lot of things that probably weren’t his fault. His presidency was marked by economic “malaise,” in his words, characterized by low growth, high inflation and an economy that was highly susceptible to commodity price shocks. And sweaters …
Carter will always be remembered as the president that turned the heater down in the White House, setting an example for energy conservation.
By the time Carter took office, the U.S. economy was deindustrializing and the regulatory framework that had been in place since the Great Depression was really starting to look stale.
Carter made early attempts to deregulate and rethink the regulatory state, which is commendable, but he lacked the gravitas and the ideological zeal to pull off anything like the Reagan Revolution that would follow him.
Nevertheless, the stock market did manage to return 6.9% per year during his presidency. Not too shabby.
Courtesy Copyright by Moffett, Chicago. J241772 U.S. Copyright Office. via Wikimedia Commons
President: March 4, 1921-Aug. 2, 1923
Warren G. Harding is generally considered to be one of the worst presidents in U.S. history. His presidency was marked by scandal; prior to Watergate, the Teapot Dome bribery scandal was probably the biggest scandal in U.S. history. And Harding was also known to be a serial philanderer who preferred pursuing mistresses to governing the country.
That said, while Harding didn’t accomplish much as president, he was at least in the middle of the pack when it came to stock market performance. Stocks returned 6.9% annually during his presidency.
Harding died in office from a heart attack and was followed by Calvin Coolidge, who would go on to preside over one of the greatest economic expansions in U.S. history.
Courtesy Yoichi Robert Okamoto via Wikimedia Commons
President: Nov. 22, 1963-Jan. 20, 1969
Market Performance: 7.7% per year
Lyndon B. Johnson, better remembered as “LBJ,” took over the presidency following John F. Kennedy’s assassination. His time in office was a turbulent one, marked by an escalation of the Vietnam War and widespread social unrest.
LBJ was one of only four presidents who, while eligible to seek re-election, chose not to.
While his handling of the war cast his presidency in a negative light, Johnson also launched the Medicare and Medicaid programs, which decades later still provide basic health coverage to retired and to lower-income Americans.
Due in part to the cost of the Vietnam War, inflation started to trend higher during Johnson’s presidency, eventually accelerating into the punishing stagflation that plagued the presidencies of Nixon, Ford and Carter.
Under his watch, the market still returned a respectable 7.7% per year.
Courtesy The Library of Congress via Wikimedia Commons
President: April 12, 1945-Jan. 20, 1953
Market Performance: 8.1% per year
Harry Truman is perhaps most famous for being the president that ended World War II and as the only world leader to use nuclear weapons in war, dropping the atomic bomb on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
He also managed the earliest years of the Cold War and implemented the Marshall Plan, which poured billions of dollars into the rebuilding of Western Europe after World War II.
Truman had the good fortune to preside over the beginnings of the post-war surge in prosperity. The war and the rebuilding that followed it supercharged the U.S. economy and finally shook it out of the Great Depression. By the time Truman left office, the American economy was booming again.
Stocks averaged an 8.1% annual returns during Truman’s presidency.
President: Jan. 20, 1981-Jan. 20, 1989
Market Performance: 10.2% per year
Perhaps no person more embodies the decade of the 1980s than President Ronald Reagan. The final stages of the Cold War, the Decade of Greed, Gordon Gekko from the movie Wall Street … This was the Reagan Era.
Reagan took office at a time when America for ripe for change, and his “Reaganomics” consisted of tax cuts, deregulation and a general shift toward pro-business policies.
The Reagan years also coincided with the beginning of one of the greatest bull markets in history. Very early in Reagan’s presidency, Fed Chairman Paul Volker broke the back of inflation by running an exceptionally tight monetary policy. This lead to a nasty recession early in Reagan’s first term, but by the end of that term, the economy was firing on all cylinders and didn’t slow down again until George H.W. Bush’s term.
Tax cuts, deregulation and falling inflation all contributed to the impressive 10.2% annualized returns over the course of Reagan’s presidency.
Courtesy Shealah Craighead - White House via Wikimedia Commons
President: Jan. 20, 2017-present
Market Performance: 10.6% per year (data through Oct. 16, 2019)
President Donald Trump has reached the 1,000-day mark of his presidency. And the “Trump rally” places him in the top half of presidents, based on market performance, with annualized returns thus far of 10.6%.
Given the already lofty valuations in place when he took office, it’s questionable whether the market can continue to generate these kinds of returns for the rest of his term. That doubt festered in a very weak fourth quarter of 2018, though prices have rebounded somewhat in 2019. At time of writing, the cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ratio sits near 30, making this the second-most-expensive market in history after the 1990s tech bubble. For the market to continue generating these kinds of returns, valuations would have to surpass the old 1990s highs. That’s a tall order.
But if the bull does keep running, expect to hear about it on Twitter.
Courtesy David Hume Kennerly via Wikimedia Commons
President: Aug. 9, 1974-Jan. 20, 1977
Market Performance: 10.8% per year
Gerald Ford holds the distinction of being the only American president to have never been elected to the office of president or vice president. He took over as vice president for the resigning Spiro Agnew and later took over as vice president for the scandal-plagued Richard Nixon.
Poor Gerald Ford never got much respect as president. He inherited a nasty economy from Richard Nixon characterized by sluggish growth and high inflation, and he lacked the imagination or charisma to do much about it.
Yet Ford is an interesting case study in how timing is everything when it comes to investing. Ford took office just as the brutal 1973-74 bear market was nearing its end. That bear market saw the Dow and S&P 500 lose nearly half their respective values. Coming off of a low base like that, the market was in position to deliver solid returns even in a lousy economy, and that is exactly what happened. Over Ford’s tenure in office, the S&P 500 delivered very solid 10.8% annualized returns.
Courtesy Wikimedia Commons
President: Jan. 20, 1953-Jan. 20, 1961
Market Performance: 10.9% per year
Dwight D. Eisenhower had a certain prestige that few presidents before or after could ever hope to match. As the supreme commander of the Allies in World War II, he was a man who was certainly accustomed to being in charge.
He also happened to preside over an almost idyllic period in American history in the prosperous 1950s. The United States emerged from the war as the only major world power without significant damage to rebuild, yet that didn’t stop Eisenhower from embarking on one of the most ambitious infrastructure projects in American history in the Interstate Highway System.
America, in the 1950s, was the world’s economic, political and military superpower, so it is perhaps unsurprising that this decade was a strong one in the stock market. Under Eisenhower, the S&P 500 saw annual returns of 10.9%.
Courtesy Tom via Wikimedia Commons
President: Jan. 20, 1989-Jan. 20, 1993
Market Performance: 11.0% per year
The elder George Bush, who died in November at age 94, had a more difficult time at the ballot boxes than his son. George W. managed to secure two terms, whereas George H.W. lost his reelection bid to Bill Clinton.
Yet when it comes to stock market performance, the elder Bush utterly trounced the younger. Under George H.W. Bush, stocks returned an impressive 11% per year. Under Dubya, they lost nearly 6% per year.
George H.W. Bush inherited an economic boom and soaring political stature from his predecessor Ronald Reagan. The late Reagan years and early Bush years saw the collapse of the Berlin Wall and the fall of the Soviet Union. Bush also successfully repelled Saddam Hussein’s invasion of Kuwait in the Gulf War.
Unfortunately for Bush, the end of the Cold War brought with it a decline in defense spending that helped to create the worst recession in more than a decade in the early 1990s. This – and the emergence of a third-party candidate in Ross Perot – handed the 1992 election to Bill Clinton.
President: March 4, 1897-Sept. 14, 1901
Market Performance: 11.3% per year
William McKinley is an exception on many counts. To start, most of the presidents that saw the highest stock returns were more recent presidents, whereas McKinley’s first term started in the 1800s. Furthermore, most of the presidents from the late 1800s and early 1900s that favored protective tariffs tended to see lousy stock returns. McKinley was an exception on that count as well, as he was a strong advocate of tariffs and yet enjoyed the fourth-highest stock returns of all presidents in history.
This was partly due to timing. McKinley came to power just as the depression that had wrecked Grover Cleveland’s presidency was running its course.
McKinley’s second term was cut short by an assassin’s bullet, which led to Teddy Roosevelt assuming the presidency. But during his time in office, the Dow saw annualized returns of 11.3%.
Courtesy Official White House Photo by Pete Souza via Wikimedia Commons
President: Jan. 20, 2009-Jan. 20, 2017
Market Performance: 13.8% per year
President Barack Obama took office at a particularly difficult time in American history. The housing boom had recently gone bust, taking down the banking sector with it. Obama was left with the thankless task of managing the aftermath of the crisis and putting the rules in place to make sure it wouldn’t happen again.
Partly because of this, Obama was not known for being particularly business-friendly as president. Yet he can boast some of the most impressive stock market returns of any president in history with cumulative returns of 181.1% and annualized returns of 13.8%.
As was the case with Gerald Ford, it came down to timing. President Obama had the good fortune of taking office right as the worst bear market since the Great Depression was nearing its end. There was nowhere for the market to go but up. That’s fantastic timing.
All the same, 181% cumulative returns are pretty good and place Obama as the third-highest-returning president in history.
Courtesy Bob McNeely, The White House via Wikimedia Commons
President: Jan. 20, 1993-Jan. 20, 2001
Market Performance: 15.2% per year
The No. 2 spot goes to President Bill Clinton, who presided over one of the largest booms in American history in the 1990s: the “dot-com” boom.
This was lucky timing, of course. But to his credit, Clinton was considered one of the more business-friendly presidents by modern standards, particularly during the final six years of his presidency. Importantly, he was smart enough to embrace the technology revolution rather than stifle it.
The 1990s were an exciting time. With communism discredited after the fall of the USSR, the United States emerged as the world’s only economic and political superpower. The emergence of the internet and a new breed of technology companies created a surge in prosperity and fundamentally reshaped the economy.
The S&P 500 soared 210% during Clinton’s eight years, working out to annualized returns of 15.2%.
President: Aug. 2, 1923-March 4, 1929
Market Performance: 26.1% per year
At the very top of the list is Calvin Coolidge: the man who presided over the boom years of the Roaring Twenties. Coolidge – a hero among small-government conservatives for his modest, hands-off approach to government – famously said, “After all, the chief business of the American people is business. They are profoundly concerned with producing, buying, selling, investing and prospering in the world.”
It was true then, and it’s just as true today.
In Coolidge’s five-and-a-half years in office, the Dow soared an incredible 266%, translating to compound annualized gains of 26.1% per year.
Of course, the cynic might point out that Coolidge was also extraordinarily lucky to have taken office just as the 1920s were starting to roar … and to have retired just as the whole thing was starting to fall apart. His successor, Hoover, was left to deal with the consequences of the 1929 crash and the Great Depression that followed.