Why Your Home Insurance Might Not Protect You If Someone Else Lives There

If you own a second home, such as a vacation property, second home insurance can help protect both the home itself and your finances. But coverage becomes more complex when someone else lives in the property, making it essential to choose the right type of policy for your situation.

Several insurance options may apply to a second home, including homeowners, landlord and rental policies. Each is designed for different living arrangements, and the right choice depends largely on how the property is used and who occupies it.

That distinction matters more than many homeowners realize. In fact, insurers often focus less on who owns a property and more on who lives there — a difference that can determine whether a claim is covered or denied.

From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance

Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just ~~$107.88~~ $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues

CLICK FOR FREE ISSUE

https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/flexiimages/y99mlvgqmn1763972420.png

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.

Why who lives in your home matters to insurers

A recent case in Massachusetts demonstrates the issues that can arise when someone else lives in your home. According to Insurance Journal, the Massachusetts Appeals Court ruled that a property owner’s grandson was not a member of the household for insurance purposes; the court upheld the insurer’s right to deny a claim the property owner had filed involving the grandson.

In this case, occupancy mattered more than property ownership for insurance purposes.

Who lives in your home directly affects the level of risk insurers take on, which can change the type of coverage you need. If a property is your primary residence, owner-occupied homeowners insurance is typically appropriate. This type of policy covers the home’s structure, your personal belongings and personal liability.

If you own a property but do not live there, you’ll generally need a non-owner-occupied or landlord policy instead. These policies still protect the structure of the home, but they’re designed to account for tenant-related risks, including liability coverage for injuries that occur on the property.

It’s also important to clearly distinguish between long-term guests and tenants. In many cases, a guest staying temporarily in your home may be covered under your existing homeowners' insurance. However, once someone is considered a tenant, landlord insurance is typically required to ensure you’re properly protected.

Family relationships don’t automatically change that classification. If a family member lives long-term in a secondary home where you do not reside, insurers may still treat that person as a tenant. In many policies, a stay of 29 days or more can trigger a tenant classification, though the exact threshold varies. Because definitions differ by insurer, it’s best to confirm how your provider categorizes occupants and adjust your coverage accordingly.

Common situations where coverage can quietly change

Shifting living situations can cause your coverage to change, and you might not even be aware of it:

An adult child or grandchild living in your secondary home for more than 29 days is typically considered a tenant, which usually requires a landlord policy rather than standard second home insurance.
If you inherit a home during probate, you will need to take out a new policy once the home is transferred to your name. The type of policy will depend on factors like whether it will be a second home and who will be living there.
Second home insurance may be suitable for a vacation property used only seasonally by you. However, if you rent the home out — even part of the year — you’ll generally need a rental or landlord policy.
If you allow a family member to stay in your second home temporarily, they may initially qualify as a guest. Once their stay extends beyond 29 days, however, insurers may classify them as a tenant, triggering the need for landlord coverage.

What kind of insurance you may actually need

Below are some of the most common types of insurance that may apply.

Homeowners insurance is intended for your primary residence. It protects your home’s structure and your possessions, and it includes liability coverage for you and your family.
Landlord or dwelling policies are designed for properties you own but don’t live in. They generally cover the structure of the home and include liability protection if a tenant or visitor is injured on the property.
Umbrella liability policies provide additional liability protection once the limits of your primary insurance policies are reached. They can help cover bodily injury, property damage and certain personal injury lawsuits, and they often include legal costs such as attorney fees and settlements. Umbrella policies typically do not cover your own injuries, damage to your personal property or losses resulting from criminal or intentional acts.

Use the tool below, powered by Bankrate, to explore and compare some of today's top home insurance offers:

How liability claims can affect your finances beyond the property

Liability claims can have significant impacts on your finances, including:

Personal assets at risk: If a liability judgment or settlement exceeds your insurance policy’s limits, you are responsible for the remaining balance. Depending on state law, creditors may be able to place liens on personal assets — including home equity — to recover what is owed.
Future insurability: A large liability claim could prompt your insurance provider to cancel your policy. It may be harder to find insurance coverage because of the past claim, and you might need to purchase high-risk insurance, which has more expensive premiums and is more limited than standard home insurance policies.
Higher premiums and non-renewals: Your insurer might not renew your policy after a liability claim. If they do renew the policy, your claims history could drive up your premiums, even if you shop around for a new insurance policy.

What to check before — and after — someone moves in

Before and after someone moves into your property, make sure that you have the right insurance for the specific situation:

Notify your insurer: Contact your insurance provider before someone moves in and confirm the planned move-in date.
Confirm occupancy classification: During that conversation, verify how the insurer will classify the individual(s) living on the property. This is the time to confirm whether your current policy is appropriate or whether you need different coverage so the policy is in place before occupancy begins.
Review liability limits: Having someone live on your property can increase liability risk. Review your liability limits and consider whether increasing coverage or adding an umbrella policy makes sense.
Document how property is used: Keep records of how the property is used, including rental agreements if applicable and how often the home is occupied.

When keeping the property vacant may still carry risks

With all of the nuances that come with someone living in your home, it might seem like keeping the property vacant could be safer. Unfortunately, vacant properties are exposed to other risks, including:

Vacant home exclusions: Many homeowners' insurance policies limit or suspend certain coverages if a home is vacant for an extended period, often 30 to 60 days. After that point, claims may be reduced or denied unless you have a vacant home policy in place.
Maintenance and injury claims: Problems such as burst pipes or leaking water heaters can worsen in vacant homes because issues may go unnoticed for weeks. As a result, claims can be more severe, and insurers may require vacant home insurance to maintain coverage.
Vandalism risks: Vacant homes may be an increased target for vandalism, leading to potential damage.

How this fits into today’s housing and inheritance reality

Second home insurance is becoming more important as changing housing arrangements and inheritance trends leave more homeowners responsible for additional properties. Aging parents may move into an adult child’s second home, and multi-generational living has become a practical, cost-saving option in today’s economy. Estate settlements can also result in inherited homes that sit vacant for a period of time, while ongoing housing affordability challenges are pushing families to share properties more often.

When the people living in a property change — or when a home shifts between being occupied, rented or vacant — insurance needs can change as well. Making sure you have the right coverage helps protect not only the property itself, but your personal finances. A quick call to your insurance provider can help confirm that your policy matches how the home is actually used, so you’re protected if the unexpected happens.

Paige Cerulli is a freelance journalist and content writer with more than 15 years of experience. She specializes in personal finance, health, and commerce content. Paige majored in English and music performance at Westfield State University and has received numerous awards for her creative nonfiction. Her work has appeared in The U.S. News & World Report, USA Today, GOBankingRates, Top Ten Reviews, TIME Stamped Shopping and more. In her spare time, Paige enjoys horseback riding, photography and playing the flute. Connect with her on LinkedIn.