Retirement investors often face a frustrating trade-off: Chase high dividend yields for more income today, or prioritize dividend growth for a better chance at keeping up with inflation over the long haul.
The trouble is that both options pose risks. A retirement portfolio built entirely around high-yield stocks might generate attractive income today, but it can also expose retirees to dividend cuts and slower growth over time. Meanwhile, focusing only on dividend growth stocks might help preserve long-term purchasing power, but it could leave retirees with less income in the near term.
A dividend "barbell" strategy attempts to bridge that gap by combining both approaches inside the same portfolio. The idea is to balance income needs now without sacrificing future portfolio growth.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
"The dividend growers are your primary engine of capital appreciation, while the high-yield side provides current income," says John Menser, a certified financial planner and senior vice president with Novare Capital Management.
For retirees trying to engineer a more predictable income stream, the strategy can provide a framework for balancing current cash flow with long-term growth potential.
"If your concern in retirement is ensuring a monthly income of say $10,000, and you know Social Security will cover $4,000 of that, you can engineer the remaining $6,000," Menser says.
How a dividend barbell strategy works
A dividend barbell strategy is a spin on the traditional stock and bond barbell for managing risk. It divides the income portion of a portfolio into two distinct buckets.
On one side of the barbell are higher-yield investments designed to provide current cash flow. On the other are dividend growth stocks that might yield less initially but have a history of steadily increasing payouts over time.
"The high-dividend yield side of the portfolio would focus on companies with above-average income generation, serving as an income anchor and often providing a more defensive tilt given their exposure to sectors like energy, consumer staples and other value-oriented sectors," says Jay Jacobs, U.S. head of equity ETFs for BlackRock.
The dividend growth side focuses on companies with a track record of consistently increasing their payouts over time. While these stocks might start with lower yields, they can provide stronger dividend growth, better inflation protection and more long-term appreciation potential.
"The balance between the dividend growth and high dividend yield should be tailored to the investor's income needs, risk tolerance and time horizon, rather than fixed at a specific split," Jacobs says.
That said, Menser says retirees in their mid-to-late 60s might consider starting with roughly 70% in dividend growth stocks and 30% in higher-yield holdings.
"As you age and begin collecting Social Security, you'll typically want to reduce the dividend growth allocation and increase the high-yield side of the portfolio," Menser says.
"The balance between the dividend growth and high dividend yield should be tailored to the investor's income needs, risk tolerance and time horizon, rather than fixed at a specific split." — Jay Jacobs
You also don't necessarily need to build this strategy stock by stock. Dividend-focused ETFs can provide broad diversification while targeting the exact type of dividend income you need for each side of your barbell.
For example, Jacobs points to the iShares Core Dividend Growth ETF (DGRO) for dividend growth exposure and the iShares Core High Dividend ETF (HDV) for higher-yield exposure.
DGRO focuses on companies with a track record of consistently increasing dividends. Meanwhile, HDV includes dividend-paying stocks with relatively high yields.
"Used together, these types of ETFs allow investors to balance income today with income growth over time, without having to select and monitor individual stocks themselves," Jacobs says.
How retirees can avoid dividend traps
One of the biggest risks in dividend investing is chasing yield without paying enough attention to the underlying business.
"When the yield looks so attractive, you have to ask yourself why," Menser says. "Generally, we're talking about a high dividend yield because the stock price has dropped significantly and not because the core business has improved."
In some cases, unusually high yields can signal financial stress rather than opportunity. If earnings weaken or cash flow deteriorates, companies might eventually reduce or eliminate their dividends.
"The simplest metric to quickly analyze the situation is probably the payout ratio," Menser says. "If a company is paying out 80% or more of its earnings as dividends, you can see the problem pretty quickly."
Don't get blinded by headline yields. Instead, pay close attention to dividend sustainability and overall company quality.
"Some companies may offer elevated yields because their fundamentals are deteriorating," Jacobs says. "A high yield today does not guarantee a high yield tomorrow."
Don't get blinded by headline yields. Instead, pay close attention to dividend sustainability and overall company quality.
That's one reason many dividend-focused ETFs now incorporate quality screens designed to filter out potential "yield traps."
For example, DGRO tracks the Morningstar Dividend Growth Index, which excludes the top 10% of highest-yielding stocks while also screening for payout sustainability and positive earnings expectations. HDV's benchmark, the Morningstar Dividend Yield Focus Index, screens for economic moat and financial health before including companies.
Menser cautions retirees not to treat high-yield stocks as "safe" income sources.
"These are not Treasury bills," he says. When using a dividend barbell strategy, "be vigilant about screening these companies and their bottom lines."
Where to hold dividend investments for tax efficiency
Asset location can also play a major role in how effective a dividend barbell strategy ultimately becomes.
"Asset location can materially change your after-tax income, which matters most in the retirement years," Menser says.
In general, Menser says it often makes sense to hold higher-yield investments inside traditional IRAs when possible, while reserving Roth IRAs for dividend growth investments with stronger long-term appreciation potential.
The reasoning comes down to maximizing long-term tax efficiency. High-yield investments tend to generate more current income but often deliver slower growth over time. On the other hand, dividend growth stocks might benefit more from years of tax-free compounding inside a Roth account.
"Don't waste the fertile ground of a Roth IRA on high-yield stocks," Menser says.
Retirees might also have a window between retirement and required minimum distributions (RMDs) when taxable income temporarily declines, potentially creating an opportunity for Roth conversions, he says.
Ultimately, a dividend barbell strategy works best when you focus not just on maximizing yield, but on balancing income, growth, diversification and tax efficiency across the entire portfolio.
Related content
-
2 Sectors, 4 Stocks to Buy This NovemberBlack Friday. Cyber Monday. The midterm elections. We ignore them all when looking for the best stocks to buy this November.
-
My First $1 Million: Retired Banking VP, 70, Bexley, Ohio"I enjoyed the journey. The challenge of selecting and making good investments kinda fed on itself over the years."
-
What Happens When Social Security Thinks You're Dead?As many as 12,000 people a year are mistakenly declared dead by the SSA, stopping their Social Security and Medicare benefits cold. Here's what to do if it happens to you.
-
2 Sectors, 4 Stocks to Buy This November
Black Friday. Cyber Monday. The midterm elections. We ignore them all when looking for the best stocks to buy this November.
-
Is a Roth Conversion Worth It? Why Timing Is EverythingIf you're a high earner or have a large sum in pretax retirement accounts, learn how and when to use Roth conversions to minimize future taxes.
-
Is $2 Million Enough to Retire at 65? Maybe… But Here's What Really MattersCan you retire at 65 if you've saved $2 million? It all depends on the life you envision, and how much work your portfolio needs to do to support it.
-
Nasdaq Falls Another 747 Points as Intel Is Way Outside: Stock Market TodayEarnings reports from companies laying the foundation for the AI revolution continued to drive risk-off price action into the Halloween weekend.
-
5 ETFs to Buy for Rising Interest RatesInvestors spooked by the possibility of more Federal Reserve hawkishness may find refuge in these ETFs.
-
Buying Your Own Health Insurance? Bronze and Catastrophic Plans Now Open the Door to HSAsHSAs can be a useful tax-advantaged savings channel for business owners and the self-employed, and more people are eligible this year than ever.
-
Going Independent: 3 Common Pitfalls for Financial Advisers Starting Their Own RIA FirmIt's not easy to set up as an independent financial adviser. But it'll go more smoothly if you avoid these three common mistakes in the rush to get started.
-
How Gen Xers Are Rethinking Retirement (and How Advisers Can Help Them)Gen Xers don't want to stay in careers that no longer align with their goals or how they want to live. The Great Wealth Transfer gives them financial options.
