Investor Psychology

Sell in May and Go Away? Here We Go Again ...

Every year, "sell in May and go away" is dragged out for show like Punxsutawney Phil. Should you follow this advice in 2021? As always, it depends.

Fretting over whether to "sell in May and go away" is one of Wall Street's most tiresome annual rituals. And over the next few days, investors and the financial media are sure to give this dubious old saw far more attention than it deserves.

Here's our contribution. 

Way Back in the Day

The "sell in May" proverb is said to have originated centuries ago in England when merchants, bankers and other interested parties in London's financial district noticed that investment returns generally did worse in the summer. 

If the most profitable months of the year usually occurred when market participants weren't off in their country manors trying to escape the heat … well, apparently, that was a good enough reason to adopt "sell in May" as an investment strategy. 

Incidentally, the original saying went "Sell in May and go away, and come on back on St. Leger's Day," a holiday held in mid-September. In America, it has essentially come to refer to the period between Memorial Day and Labor Day. 

Getting back to the modern era: There is evidence that the stock market, on average, tends to underperform in the six-month period between May and October. However, analysts, market timers and academics who have studied the phenomenon extensively can't settle the matter conclusively one way or the other. 

If they could, we wouldn't be having this discussion every year. 

What strategists do tend to agree on is the answer to the question of whether investors should sell in May and go away:

It depends.

Sell in May and Go Away? Here's What the Numbers Say

Sam Stovall, chief investment strategist at CFRA Research, sums up the "Should I sell in May?" conundrum facing investors in 2021 this way:

"Some say yes, in anticipation of a long overdue digestion of recent gains triggered by lofty valuations. Others say no, since valuations are justified by a projected second-half surge in gross domestic product and earnings per share growth, due to pent-up consumer demand, the expenditure of recent stimulus checks, and the anticipated passage of an infrastructure package."

Stovall adds that the "strongest six months of the year," as popularized in The Stock Trader's Almanac, tells us that the price return for the S&P 500 from November through April has recorded the highest average price change of any rolling six-month period.

"Conversely, the 'sell in May' adage reminds investors that average May-through-October price returns have historically been anemic," Stovall writes.

Historical average performance can tell us only so much, of course. Past performance, as we all know too well, is not indicative of future returns. 

For the record, thanks to Dr. Ed Yardeni of Yardeni Research, we do know unequivocally that the worst individual months for average stock market performance are not found exclusively in the post-May period. 

Indeed, per Yardeni, since 1928, average monthly price changes for the S&P 500 are actually pretty good during the dog days of summer.

Although May is tied with February for producing the S&P 500's second-worst average price change (-0.1%), July is actually the single best month for average price change (+1.6%). Interestingly, June and August – at +0.7% and +0.8%, respectively – both offer above-average gains. Have a look at the chart below:

Chart of market performance by month

Yardeni Research

Indeed, only one month really stands out on a historical basis as a good one to miss. Since 1928, the S&P 500 has delivered an average price change of -1.0% in September, per Yardeni Research.

Based on the historical record, investors who interpret "sell in May" as the period from Memorial Day to Labor Day are coming back a month too early.

Looking at It a Different Way

Another issue to consider before pulling the trigger on the "sell in May" strategy is that, as CFRA's Stovall reminds us, sector-level returns can diverge widely over the summer months.

For example, since 1990, the consumer staples and healthcare sectors of the S&P 500 recorded average price gains of 4.6% from May to October – a period when the overall market managed an advance of just 2.2%.

In addition to the issue of individual sectors delivering relative outperformance or underperformance over different multimonth periods of the year, there's the complicating factor that strong year-to-date gains are thought by some to negate the "sell in May" strategy in the first place.

Stovall notes that some data suggest that given the market's "jack-rabbit beginning" to 2021, investors might want to rotate into more defensive sectors as this year's "sell in May" strategy. 

"Should history repeat, and there's no guarantee it will, embracing a more defensive posture in the coming six months may prove to be a prudent strategy," the investment strategist says. "Rotate, don't retreat."

Most of Us Should Just Stay

The great bulk of retail investors are likely best served by simply leaving their allocations alone. 

The pros get judged on every basis point of return they can squeeze out of their holdings. But for us regular folks, portfolio churning – even in the age of commission-free trades – can still take its toll, be it in the form of opportunity cost or emotional stress. 

Like most Wall Street sayings that encourage clients to trade, long-term investors would do well to ignore the "sell in May" chatter. Leave the tactical moves to the tacticians and trust your plan. 

Something tells us Warren Buffett isn't sweating "sell in May" right now.

Most Popular

Your Guide to Roth Conversions
Special Report
Tax Breaks

Your Guide to Roth Conversions

A Kiplinger Special Report
February 25, 2021
How to Calculate the Break-Even Age for Taking Social Security
social security

How to Calculate the Break-Even Age for Taking Social Security

When it comes to maximizing your Social Security benefits, there are many elements to consider. One factor that can be especially enlightening is your…
August 30, 2021
Spend Without Worry in Retirement
Financial Planning

Spend Without Worry in Retirement

Fears of running out of money prevent many retirees from tapping the nest egg they’ve worked a lifetime to save. With these strategies, you can genera…
August 30, 2021

Recommended

Investment Strategies for the 4 Stages of the Economic Cycle
Markets

Investment Strategies for the 4 Stages of the Economic Cycle

The U.S. economy is cyclical in nature, surging ahead and pulling back in waves over time. Investors’ portfolios need to change with the rise and the …
September 19, 2021
Is a Target Date Fund Right for You?
investing

Is a Target Date Fund Right for You?

You're busy, and poring over investments is a pain. Wouldn't a target date fund be easier? Take a look at their pros and cons to see if incorporating …
September 14, 2021
Is the Stock Market Closed on Labor Day?
Markets

Is the Stock Market Closed on Labor Day?

Stock markets and bond markets alike will enjoy their annual three-day weekend as America observes Labor Day.
September 5, 2021
Stock Market Holidays in 2021
Markets

Stock Market Holidays in 2021

Is the stock market open today? Take a look at which days the NYSE, Nasdaq and bond markets take off in 2021.
September 2, 2021