Business Costs & Regulation

Financial Crisis Probe Misses Mark

Politicians and others are stuck in the blame game, rather than working to fix fix root causes

Almost typical of Washington hearings when financial titans are called to task to publicly answer for a mess, last week’s Financial Crisis Inquiry Commission hearings quickly devolved into political theater with almost predictable video clips of Mr. Chairman vs. the Multimillionaire.

The commission would have done little good anyway. At least part of the reason behind its creation was to look tough and make witnesses at least squirm a bit for the cameras.

By the time it even comes out with its report Dec. 15, Congress will have already made up its mind on financial reform, rushing to meet the election calendar. The report won’t be as widely read as the 9/11 Commission Report or effect the same level of change as the Depression’s Pecora Commission.

The bungled timing is emblematic of how, in the two years since Bear Stearns went under, thoughtful analysis has been sacrificed to a flurry of slapped together regulatory fixes and rushed out financial crisis best sellers. So it is especially disappointing that the commission is squandering the opportunity to provide a nonpartisan, clear-eyed assessment of what went wrong.

Witnesses at the hearing, which centered on the housing problems that led to bank failures, spent more time finger pointing than soul searching. Former Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan blamed mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Executives at those firms blamed the administration’s aggressive homeownership goals. Citibank executives offered sheepish mea culpas before turning their aim on regulators. The credit rating agencies were pretty much universally maligned.

Those tired explanations and half-truths simply rehash entrenched positions staked out by different sides early in the crisis. In reality, Fannie’s and Freddie’s shares of subprime mortgage originations actually started falling in 2003 as private lenders picked up the slack. The Community Reinvestment Act catches some blame, too, for easing credit too much in urban areas, but that doesn’t explain why there are so many foreclosures in the sprawling suburbs of Las Vegas and Phoenix.

Even more pernicious is the fact that all of last week’s well rehearsed testimony misses larger structural problems in the mortgage market. Tax policies encouraged not only homeownership, but also home equity lines of credit. Low interest rates fueled loose lending and adjustable rate mortgages, which George Mason University’s Todd Zywicki points to as the source of the first wave of foreclosures. Overly sweet incentives throughout the system meant that when home prices dropped from the stratosphere, homeowners with little equity to begin with and too pricey mortgages simply stopped paying the bills.

Sure, credit rating agencies, regulators and banks were foolish to rely on models that assumed home prices would forever go up. If last week’s hearings could have done any good, they would have reminded us that the stability of our financial system should not entirely rely on fallible human judgment. But the lessons will fall on deaf ears. Financial regulatory reform now making its way through Congress does little to address the structure of finance and instead simply hands error prone humans even more discretion.

Because the reform bill doesn’t get around the fact that bubbles are hard to spot and even harder to pop, it will not be very helpful in heading off the next crisis. At last week’s testimony, even Greenspan admitted he got things wrong 30% of the time. You’d get better odds at the Kentucky Derby. As housing economist Thomas Lawler reminded me, in 2005, when subprime mortgage originations peaked at $625 billion, “There were a lot of people who were not complete idiots, saying there wasn’t a bubble.”

Most Popular

Your Guide to Roth Conversions
Special Report
Tax Breaks

Your Guide to Roth Conversions

A Kiplinger Special Report
February 25, 2021
11 Best Healthcare Stocks for the Rest of 2021
healthcare stocks

11 Best Healthcare Stocks for the Rest of 2021

The 2020s could be the decade of healthcare stocks. Here are 10 companies and one ETF to watch not just for the remainder of this year, but well beyon…
July 13, 2021
What Is the Social Security COLA?
retirement

What Is the Social Security COLA?

For the average recipient, the 2021 monthly increase doesn't even cover a fill-up at the gas station — but it beats nothing.
July 14, 2021

Recommended

The Most Expensive Natural Disasters in U.S. History
Economic Forecasts

The Most Expensive Natural Disasters in U.S. History

Wind, water, fire and drought have all wreaked havoc on the United States. What’s been the worst?
July 1, 2021
Tough Times for a Family Business
Business Costs & Regulation

Tough Times for a Family Business

His dry-cleaning operation was rocked by the pandemic, but he is staying optimistic.
June 24, 2021
IRS Gives Truckers a Tax Break in Response to the Colonial Pipeline Shutdown
Tax Breaks

IRS Gives Truckers a Tax Break in Response to the Colonial Pipeline Shutdown

The tax penalty for using dyed diesel fuel for highway use is temporarily suspended.
May 13, 2021
Our "K-Shaped," Uneven Economic Recovery
Economic Forecasts

Our "K-Shaped," Uneven Economic Recovery

Confidence is key to the recovery, but the sentiment depends on consumers’ financial circumstances.
April 29, 2021