Give a Gift

Health Care

Score Big Savings on Health Coverage

Don't wait for health-care reform. Use these strategies to cut your premiums now.

By Kimberly Lankford, Contributing Editor

From Kiplinger's Personal Finance magazine, August 2009
Text Size T T
  • Comments
  • Print This Article
  • Order a Reprint
  • Advertisement

Washington is buzzing about pending changes in the health-care system, and a bill could pass before the end of the year. In the meantime, if you're facing a layoff, graduating from college and losing benefits, or struggling to pay rising premiums, you can still find affordable coverage.

Related Links


Several recent developments could help you save thousands of dollars on health-insurance premiums. For one thing, this year's economic-stimulus legislation included a health-insurance subsidy for laid-off workers. In many states, new laws allow children to be covered by their parents' policies until they reach their mid twenties. And early retirees can now purchase insurance that will cover them until they qualify for Medicare.

You've been laid off

When you lose your job, you may be able to get coverage from your spouse's employer, continue your own coverage through COBRA -- the federal law that lets former employees continue group coverage for up to 18 months -- or search for an individual policy. Compare all three options: Many employers no longer subsidize coverage for family members, so adding on to your spouse's plan could be expensive.

COBRA is available to employees of companies with 20 or more workers, and you can't be rejected or charged a higher rate because of your health. But you'll have to pay the full cost yourself, which averages $12,600 per year for family coverage and $4,700 per year for individuals, according to the Kaiser Family Foundation.

Under the stimulus legislation, Uncle Sam will pay 65% of COBRA premiums for up to nine months for people who lose their job between September 1, 2008, and December 31, 2009. But if you're healthy, you might still get a better deal on your own. Melissa Harrison, 32, lost her job as a horticulturalist at a nursery in Summerville, S.C., in early February, just weeks before Congress passed the stimulus. She could have stayed on her old policy through COBRA, but her premiums would have jumped from $200 per month to $480. She went to eHealthInsurance.com, used a tool that lists the insurance networks that included her doctor, and found a policy issued by Celtic for $190 per month. The policy carries a $1,500 deductible, doesn't charge for annual exams and screenings, and offers maximum coverage of $7 million.

Harrison qualified for the 65% COBRA subsidy a few weeks later, but she turned it down. She would have saved only about $20 a month with the subsidy, and the price would have jumped back up to $480 after nine months. Plus, she liked the Celtic policy better -- especially because she had been paying out-of-network charges to visit her doctor under her employer's plan.

Harrison concedes that it's tough to focus on shopping for health insurance when you're worrying about finding work. "But my mother drilled into me that you have to have insurance," she says. "If you have a little time, you can get a better deal than COBRA and find a policy that fits you better, too."

You have health issues

Premiums will be pricier if you're older or have medical conditions. Laura and Shaun Best of Stevenson Ranch, Cal., own a locksmith business specializing in bank security. The couple also have three kids between the ages of 13 and 20. The Bests have had their own health insurance for a long time, but the premiums kept creeping up. When they reached $929 per month, Laura, 47, started looking for alternatives and found a policy through Anthem Blue Cross for $305 per month. "I wasn't surprised that I could find less-expensive insurance, although I was not expecting to save as much as we are," she says.

One reason the Bests' health insurance was so expensive was that Shaun, 52, has high blood pressure. But each insurer looks at health conditions differently. "One insurer may charge a lot for a particular condition, while another might offer the same person the lowest possible rate," says Scott Leavitt, a health-insurance agent in Boise, Idaho, who generally gathers medical records and gets prices from at least three insurers for clients with medical conditions (find a local agent at www.nahu.org).

The Bests also saved money by making some trade-offs. They wanted insurance their doctor accepted, but they didn't mind a $2,500 deductible because they plan to use HealthyCheck centers, which charge just $25 for basic visits and screenings. They opted not to pay for prescription coverage because Shaun's medications are currently available at many pharmacies for $3 and $5. And they gave the insurer extra medical records showing that Shaun's high blood pressure has been well controlled for 30 years with a very low dosage of medication. The search paid off, saving them more than $7,000 per year in health-insurance premiums.


Introductory Offer: Get Kiplinger's Personal Finance magazine for $12. Save 75%!

DISCUSS

Permission to post your comment is assumed when you submit it. The name you provide will be used to identify your post, and NOT your e-mail address. We reserve the right to excerpt or edit any posted comments for clarity, appropriateness, civility, and relevance to the topic.
View our full privacy policy

Reader Comments (12)

Posted by: Jim Anderson at 07/10/2009 12:01:35 PM

Great story. I am an insurance agent and spend my life trying to help people find the best deals, networks, plan adjustments etc. There's really not that big of a problem in our country regarding health insurance. Most of the "uninsured" are people who won't buy it, not can't get it!

Posted by: John Walker at 07/10/2009 08:50:40 PM

Well Jim I beg to differ. I am a Hospital Social Worker and over a 35 year career, consulting with thousands of patients I could not disagree with you more. One of the primary reasons my service is consulted is because of payment issues. Most of th un or underinsured patients aren't fully covered because they CAN'T afford health insurance NOT because they don't want to. The median

Posted by: John Walker at 07/10/2009 09:16:14 PM

My comment continues. The median middle class income cannot accomodate basic living expenses anymore, including housing, food, transportation and the outrageous healthcare insurance premiums. Medical costs are the Number 1 reason for bankruptcy in this country. And the primary reason there are inflated healthcare premiums are because of the sociopathic CEOs and Board memb ers of the insurance industry that award themselves millions of dollars annually rather than do the responsible and ethical thing by returning those profits to the consumers through lower premiums. Only then will there be "not really a healthcare crisis in this countr"y. The braintrust in this country knows this is a huge problem, they are struggling trying to repair it because of the resistance from the insurance and drug lobby that have make billions off the backs of patients and paid off ( in the form of campaign contributions) politicians on both sides of the isle.

Posted by: Common Sense at 07/13/2009 12:33:50 AM

To Jim Anderson.....as a Multiple Myeloma victim, I can refer you to several hundred people who can't get usable medical insurance. State "uninsurable pools" require a 25%+ co-payable which translates to $75,000 to $100,000 per year for cancer victims. 30 years of medical premiums with no illness, you get cancer and can't work, COBRA runs out and you are screwed by our wonderful "medical system". Wake up America, you could be next!!

Posted by: Steven Loop at 07/13/2009 12:01:37 PM

Jim, with all due respect your comment about the "uninsured" is way off base. I was just at a health care rally and most of the attendees' stories are my story. Either a small business owner who can't afford to cover their employees, laid off folks who can't find work, and people who have a pre-existing condition that has disqualified them or any meaningful coverage. Look at the numbers of people falling below the poverty line and people who are without insurance. Surely you can't be saying that these people are simply choosing not to be insured.

Posted by: Amazed at 07/16/2009 10:48:51 PM

Typically American - Those who have experienced hardships involving a lack of health insurance and/or having maxed out their policies understand the real issue with the US system. Those who live in their own daily world, with zero ability to see beyond their own world, and believe they will always be in the good health or secure job they have cannot see how they may just one major health crisis away from starving.

Posted by: Bradley at 07/24/2009 10:38:27 AM

This is absolutely amazing! Thanks so much for this podcast. I had downloaded it to my ipod before I went to exercise this morning. When I got half way through the cast, I had to sit down! All I have ever heard or seen on the news was that its a crisis of historical proportions!" I never saw any story telling anybody there was even an affordable market for personal policies!! So I went home and looked up the web site. I entered my information and compared a few policies from reputable companies. THEN...I called my congressman and asked him if he knew about the article or the web site? Well ofcourse he didn't have clue. Then I asked him how a congressman with a platoon of staff people can't find this stuff, but I can? Well the same dribble as before. Thankyou Kiplinger and Kim for this great story. You really must wonder why this information isn't front page news. Congress needs to put the ixnei on the whole healthcare stupidity. If the government run health system they have now is going broke, how can they claim to be the solution to the whole system....without cracking a grinn?

Posted by: wake UP at 07/28/2009 12:41:39 AM

Why is no one questioning how doctors and hospitals are making tons of money? Why should we "find" ways to pay these rich salaries? I challenge all readers to really look at the charges on your insurance statement even if you have good coverage. You will find tons of errors and overpayment.

Posted by: Kimberly Lankford at 07/28/2009 07:15:01 AM

Bradley, thanks for your kind words about my article and podcast. There are still plenty of problems with the health-care system that need fixing -- especially the ability for people with major medical conditions to find affordable policies in many states. But there are also a lot of other people who are relatively healthy and have no idea that affordable coverage may be available if they know how to search for it. I hope the article can show them the best strategies for finding a policy under the current system, which can save them money while they wait to see what Congress decides about health-care reform.

Posted by: patt at 08/28/2009 04:26:28 PM

I also used ehealthinsurance quote to help find personal coverage for my family, however, I was denied many time because my youngest child was born with a heart condition. Not one company would insure him, unless it was some wierd policy with a maximum of 1,000 in payments and a 1,000 deductible. we truly need a health care overhaul to include 'pre-existing' conditions. I don't mind paying the premium, but can't find an insurance company that will cover him. If anyone has heard of an insurance company that will cover 'pre-exisitng conditions' please (let me know)...thank you

Posted by: planetmango at 09/10/2009 04:43:21 AM

Ameriplan works well, and seems to offer a nice alternative, especially in this economy. At $40 a month a family or household of 20 or less receive 60% savings on dental (including orthodontist and cosmetic work)like porcelain crowns (for 60% less) and 40% of doctor visits, and approx 40% reduction on hosp bills more than $2500. plus lab fees for blood work reduced 85%. Pretty good deal especially if you have trouble getting qaulified for insurance. Because it is not insurance there are no age limits nd they accept preexisting conditions Plus it can be used with insurances especially those with high deductibles. There are something like 100,000 providers nationwide...

Posted by: Gordon Shedd at 02/23/2010 12:03:05 PM

From the article above, which seems to say that we don't need a better health insurance system as much as we need to look harder: "Laura and Shaun Best ...have had their own health insurance for a long time, but the premiums kept creeping up. When they reached $929 per month, Laura, 47, started looking for alternatives and found a policy through Anthem Blue Cross for $305 per month. "I wasn't surprised that I could find less-expensive insurance, although I was not expecting to save as much as we are," she says." A different view of reality comes from another Anthem HDHP policy-holder in an AARP discussion of health insurance plans: "We also looked for insurance when I was laid off at age 54, my husband was 56. COBRA was too expensive. We went online to compare rates...AARP was too expensive. We are both in good health and selected a high deductible policy. Unfortunately we chose Anthem BC/BS. In 3 years our rates have increased 87% (we're not in CA but in CO). In all those 3 years, our total medical bills were under $500! This past year our rate went up 37%. We did check out Humana several years ago but their rates were compatible ($50/mo difference). Anthem's new increase put our high deductible policy at $600 per month. Right now we are disillusioned and uninsured." Kimberly, since these people ended up where you were suggesting a few months back (Anthem HDHP), would you now advise them to stop complaining, or to look again?




Connect With Kiplinger

E-mail Updates: Select the Kiplinger columns and topics to be delivered to your inbox.

email-sign-up

Featured Videos From Kiplinger




facebook
twitter
RSS