Buy Now, Pay Later: 5 BNPL Stocks to Buy

Block

• Market value: $85.2 billion
• Analysts' ratings: 26 Strong Buy, 10 Buy, 9 Hold, 1 Sell, 1 Strong Sell

In early February, Square parent Block (SQ, $146.84) jumped into the BNPL game in a big way by acquiring Australian-based Afterpay for $29 billion in stock. Block granted 0.375 SQ shares for every Afterpay share held.

The combination of Afterpay with Block's Seller and Square App platforms created a mobile payments giant with millions of customers and merchants around the world. In fiscal 2021, Afterpay processed $22.4 billion in transactions.

Argus Research discussed the Afterpay acquisition in a March 4 note to clients.

"We believe strong cross-selling opportunities exist between the companies, as Block integrates Afterpay into its Seller and Cash App platforms," says Argus Research analyst Stephen Biggar, who rates SQ stock at Buy. "Greater integration of these platforms has been a long-standing goal for the company. BNPL allows customers to receive products immediately and pay for their purchases over installments, free from interest and service fees for customers who pay on time."

In late February, Block introduced Afterpay Buy Now Pay Later to its U.S. and Australian online sellers. It intends to further integrate Afterpay's platform throughout 2022.

At the end of December, Afterpay had more than 122,000 annual active merchants, 64% higher than a year earlier. On the consumer side, it had more than 19 million annual active consumers, up 47%. Afterpay's gross merchandise volume (GMV) in fiscal 2021 was $19.7 billion, 74% higher than a year earlier.

As for Block itself, CFO Amrita Ahuja pointed out in its Q4 2021 conference call with analysts that its Square Seller business had six revenue streams in 2021 that generated more than $100 million or more in gross profit, while its Cash App business had four revenue streams of more than $200 million in gross profit.

Block is one of the best-rated BNPL stocks to buy, boasting 36 Strong Buy or Buy ratings versus just nine Holds, one Sell and one Strong Sell.

Affirm Holdings

• Market value: $13.7 billion
• Analysts' ratings: 5 Strong Buy, 3 Buy, 5 Hold, 0 Sell, 1 Strong Sell

Affirm Holdings (AFRM, $48.15), a San Francisco-based BNPL platform for digital and mobile-first commerce, went public at $49 per share in January 2021. It hit $100 on its first day of trading, and as recently as November, Affirm's share price traded at a 52-week high of $176.65.

The BNPL stock is down 76% in the roughly four months since.

You can chalk some of that up to the broader market cooling off. But speculative, high-growth companies unable to post profits have been specifically targeted, and AFRM fits that bill.

For instance, its fiscal second-quarter earnings report, out in February, revealed $4.5 billion in GMV that was 115% higher year-over-year (YoY). Active merchants increased by 8,000, to 168,000, while active consumers rocketed 150% YoY to 11.2 million (and 29% sequentially from Q1). Overall, revenues were 77% better YoY to $361.0 million.

But Affirm doesn't make money. It reported an adjusted operating loss of $7.9 million in the second quarter, and $53.0 million for the first half of 2022 – considerably higher than the $4.8 million loss it absorbed in the first half of 2021.

Analysts have widely had to temper their expectations, but Wall Street largely still counts Affirm among the best buy now, pay later stocks to buy.

Truist analyst Andrew Jeffrey, for instance, lowered his price target on AFRM in March, to $55 per share from $100, putting the stock at 9.5 times calendar 2023 revenue at the time. But he reiterated his Buy rating.

"While we recognize that the stock will likely face near-term pressure, and revenue multiples are inherently subjective, we see Affirm a long-term winner in the nascent BNPL market," Jeffrey says, recommending investors add to their positions on future weakness.

PayPal Holdings

• Market value: $141.2 billion
• Analysts' ratings: 25 Strong Buy, 12 Buy, 10 Hold, 0 Sell, 1 Strong Sell

PayPal Holdings (PYPL, $121.18) is the latest BNPL player to face a class action lawsuit. On March 1, a $5 million class action complaint was filed in a California federal court against the company. The suit claims that PayPal doesn't sufficiently inform users of its "Pay in 4" offer about potential insufficient fund fees and overdraft charges.

Buy now, pay later has become the latest revenue generator for the digital payments company. In December, CEO Dan Schulman said PayPal had more than 750,000 BNPL transactions on Black Friday, 400% higher than a year earlier.

PayPal said in its fourth-quarter conference call that buy now, pay later is available in eight markets, including the U.S. In the fourth quarter, BNPL accounted for $3.2 billion in total payment volume (TPV), 325% higher than a year earlier. Approximately 13 million consumers and 1.2 million merchants have used its BNPL services.

Like with Affirm and other BNPL stocks, PayPal has suffered several price-target reductions in recent months, even though the Street is still widely bullish on shares.

"We assume PayPal can achieve its 15-20 million 2022 NNA [net new active accounts] growth target, and beyond 2022 will return to the midpoint of its historical 30-40 million annual NNA growth through international expansion, share gains from BNPL and acquisitions," UBS analyst Rayna Kumar wrote in February. While she lowered her price target to $158 from $218, she maintained a Buy rating on the stock.

The current median price target for PYPL is $190, implying that Wall Street on average sees 57% upside from here.

Apple

• Market value: $2.9 trillion
• Analysts' ratings: 27 Strong Buy, 7 Buy, 7 Hold, 1 Sell, 1 Strong Sell

Bloomberg reported in July 2021 that Apple (AAPL, $178.96) was working with Goldman Sachs (GS) to launch a buy now, pay later offering not tied to the Apple Card. (Apple has partnered with Goldman on its Apple Card since 2019.)

The BNPL service is tentatively to be called Apple Pay Later. Consumers buying a product or service using Apple Pay would be able to pay in four biweekly interest-free payments. Alternatively, they could opt to pay over several months with interest.

Apple currently offers monthly installments when you use your Apple Card at Apple, whether in person or online. Apple Pay Later would extend this beyond Apple products and services.

Fast-forward to late March, and the company announced it would buy U.K.-based fintech Credit Kudos for $150 million. Credit Kudos has developed software that enables third-party companies to gain a more up-to-date credit profile for loan candidates using consumer financial data accessed through secure application programming interfaces (APIs).

Apple is thought to have acquired the company to further its ambitions regarding Apple Pay and BNPL. According to data from Pymnts.com, only 6% of U.S. consumers who have Apple Pay on their phones have actually used it to make an in-store purchase. BNPL would likely increase the take rate for Apple Pay.

In addition to Apple's future BNPL plans, buying Credit Kudos is thought to help the company's plans to get the Apple Card into the U.K., broadening the scope of the card's use.

Zip

• Market value: $762.7 million
• Analysts' ratings: N/A

In a sign consolidation is coming to buy now, pay later, Australian BNPL company Zip Co. (ZIZTF, $1.14) announced on Feb. 27 that it would buy Minneapolis-based Sezzle for $352.6 million.

The all-stock purchase is a 32% premium to Sezzle's 30-day volume weighted average price on the Australian Securities Exchange. Sezzle shareholders will receive 0.98 Zip shares for each share held in Sezzle. Zip shareholders will own 78% of the combined entity. Together, they'll have 8.8 million customers and 60,500 merchants using their BNPL platforms in the U.S.

"We are delighted to be bringing Zip and Sezzle together under a transformational transaction that is expected to deliver immediate scale and enhanced growth, which will support our path to profitability," says Zip co-founder and Global CEO Larry Diamond. "Combining with Sezzle positions us as a leading global BNPL provider and prioritizes our ability to win in the important U.S. market."

At the same time Zip announced its purchase of Sezzle, it also announced six-month results (July to December 2021) that included a loss of 108 million Australian dollars ($80.9 million).

Sezzle CEO Charlie Youakim will become CEO of the merged entity's Americas business, and he's one of three Sezzle insiders to join Zip's board.

Zip also acquired U.S.-based BNPL company QuadPay in 2020 for almost $300 million.

That said, Zip is the most difficult of the BNPL stocks to invest in. Here in the U.S., it only offers thinly traded over-the-counter shares, with daily volume in the hundreds, meaning that anyone interested in buying will want to use limit orders. For those able to access the Australian Stock Exchange, shares trade as Z1P.