An Investment Strategist Demystifies Direct Indexing: Is It for You?
You've heard of mutual funds and ETFs, but direct indexing may be a new concept ... one that could offer greater flexibility and possible tax savings.


Client demand for personalized investment strategies continues to increase, and direct indexing has become one of the fastest-growing segments in the managed account space.
Direct indexing is the leading category for manager-traded SMAs, with direct indexing assets closing 2024 at $864.3 billion, according to Cerulli Associates.
Direct indexing provides an alternative to index mutual funds and passive ETFs for investors who want more choice, greater flexibility and the potential tax advantages that those commingled investments simply can't offer.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
The Kiplinger Building Wealth program handpicks financial advisers and business owners from around the world to share retirement, estate planning and tax strategies to preserve and grow your wealth. These experts, who never pay for inclusion on the site, include professional wealth managers, fiduciary financial planners, CPAs and lawyers. Most of them have certifications including CFP®, ChFC®, IAR, AIF®, CDFA® and more, and their stellar records can be checked through the SEC or FINRA.
What is direct indexing?
Most of us are familiar with mutual funds and passive exchange-traded funds (ETFs), which package underlying securities into a single vehicle accessible to investors.
Anyone who purchases shares in a passive index-tracking ETF can gain broad market exposure to the benchmark of their choice — for example, the S&P 500, the Russell 3000 and so on.
Direct indexing takes this idea in a different direction. Instead of owning shares in a commingled fund, the investor owns the individual securities in the portfolio directly, in a separately managed account (SMA).
The investor gets the same kind of broad market exposure but with compelling advantages, including the potential to improve after-tax outcomes.
For example, unlike an ETF, direct indexing allows investors to customize their portfolios to actively harvest capital losses from individual securities.
What are some advantages of customization?
Different investors have different priorities, and direct indexing may not be ideal for all investors. Is the client willing to invest in more complex products? What has their previous investment experience been like?
Understanding the investor's perspective can help advisers build the right portfolio for them.
Direct indexing allows investors to personalize their portfolios based on their priorities and may help them to:
- Identify and seek to take advantage of tax efficiencies
- Avoid overconcentration in a particular stock or sector by avoiding redundant or risk-compounding portfolio holdings
- Adjust allocations to overweight or underweight certain market sectors
- Combine multiple benchmarks to achieve their desired exposure
- Screen out certain industries or companies that don't align with their values
Direct indexing's direct ownership of individual securities offers powerful flexibility around charitable giving and estate planning. And direct indexing isn't limited to equities. You can build a direct indexing custom SMA using fixed income, too.
Is direct indexing right for all investors?
Direct indexing's benefits can vary depending on an investor's profile, but the types of investors who may see the greatest value from it include those who:
- Are in a higher tax bracket, so they may have more taxes to save
- Have a long-term investment focus, so they may reap more benefits from tax deferral
- Express convictions about responsible investing, so they may appreciate values-related customization
- Fund a portfolio with existing securities, so they may see real tax savings over selling all positions and reinvesting in a commingled fund
Those whose profiles don't align with one or more of these traits might not see as many benefits to direct indexing — especially after taking costs into account.
Looking for expert tips to grow and preserve your wealth? Sign up for Building Wealth, our free, twice-weekly newsletter.
Compared with commingled vehicles such as ETFs, custom passive SMAs have higher fees and more operational complexity.
And because direct indexing involves customizing the broad market allocation, performance can deviate from the investor's chosen benchmark returns — often referred to as tracking error.
Many important roles in investing
Investors seeking to take advantage of direct indexing's benefits must be willing to tolerate some carefully managed tracking error.
For these reasons, many investors who don't naturally benefit from customization may continue to get market exposure through mutual funds and passive ETFs.
But we would stress that funds, passive ETFs, direct indexing and even active management aren't mutually exclusive: All have important roles to play in the investment ecosystem.
Direct indexing continues to grow in popularity and expand its range of use cases.
More and more investors are beginning to see the potential benefits of direct indexing, which can be a powerful tool to help them take greater control of their broad market holdings, while realizing more after-tax value from them.
Related Content
- How to Master Index Investing
- A Wealth Adviser's Seven Savvy Tips on Alternative Investments
- I'm a Financial Planner: This Is the Key to Successful Retirement Planning
- Here's Why You Shouldn't Do an Estate Plan Without a Financial Planner
- Buffered ETFs: What Are They And Should You Invest in One?
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.

Jeremy is responsible for Parametric’s tax-managed equity strategies. As the lead strategist for Custom Core®, he works closely with taxable clients and advisers to design, develop and implement custom portfolio solutions. He was previously a portfolio manager on the Custom Core team for six years. Prior to joining Parametric in 2012, Jeremy worked as an instructor in economics at the University of Washington and as a private client associate for Bernstein Investment Research and Management.
-
Q2 2025 Post-Mortem: Rebound, Risks and Generational Shifts
As the third quarter gets underway, here are some takeaways from the market's second-quarter performance to consider as you make investment decisions.
-
Stock Market Today: Another Quarter, More Mixed Price Action
"Up and to the right" remains the general trend despite persistent uncertainty around critical policy issues.
-
Q2 2025 Post-Mortem: Rebound, Risks and Generational Shifts
As the third quarter gets underway, here are some takeaways from the market's second-quarter performance to consider as you make investment decisions.
-
Stock Market Today: Another Quarter, More Mixed Price Action
"Up and to the right" remains the general trend despite persistent uncertainty around critical policy issues.
-
Over 100k Medicare Accounts Breached in Latest Hack: Was Yours One?
Letters are going out to 103,000 Medicare beneficiaries who may have been impacted. Here's how to protect your identity and benefits.
-
10 Best Free (or Cheap) Online Classes for Seniors and Retirees
Check out these free or affordable online classes for retirees and grab some extra smarts.
-
This 401(k) Withdrawal Snafu Could Knock Your Portfolio off Course
Few financial advisers have heard of this 401(k) withdrawal issue. Here's how to safeguard your portfolio.
-
Why Homeowners Should Beware of Tangled Titles
If you're planning to pass down property to your heirs, a 'tangled title' can complicate things. The good news is it can be avoided. Here's how.
-
A Cautionary Tale: Why Older Adults Should Think Twice About Being Landlords
Becoming a landlord late in life can be a risky venture because of potential health issues, cognitive challenges and susceptibility to financial exploitation.
-
Home Equity Evolution: A Fresh Approach to Funding Life's Biggest Needs
Homeowners leverage their home equity through various strategies, such as HELOCs or reverse mortgages. A newer option: Shared equity models. How do those work, and what are the pros and cons?