Stock Market Losses or Lower Returns: Which Is More Dangerous to Your Retirement?
One eye-opening, simple math equation can clearly show retirement savers the answer to that question, and if you are among those investors who take pride in their high-performing portfolios, you may be surprised.
- (opens in new tab)
- (opens in new tab)
- (opens in new tab)
- Newsletter sign up Newsletter

Do you want to make your savings last throughout retirement? If you do (and of course you do), I believe that once you are within five years of retirement, you need to invest more conservatively than you did while you were growing your savings. But in most cases, a more conservative approach translates into lower returns. Is it a worthwhile trade-off?
I believe so, and I’d like to illustrate my point with a question: If you lost 50% of your money in a bear market, how much would you need to make to get back to even? Did you say 50%? If so, you’re in good company: When I ask this question during seminars, that’s usually the answer I receive. It’s also a wrong answer. Let’s do the math:
How a 50% Gain Can Result in a $250,000 Loss
If you had $1 million saved for retirement and lost 50%, you would have $500,000. Ouch. If you made 50% on that $500,000, you’d make $250,000, which would bring your total up to $750,000, not $1 million. You’d need to make 100% to get back to even.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
And if you did need to make 100% to get back to even, how long would that take you? At 2% per year, it would take you 35 years to recover. If you made 6% per year, you would need 12 years to get back to even. Even if you made 10% per year, it would still take you seven years to recover your money. And what are the odds you’d make 10% every year for the next seven years? Sounds like a pretty high expectation to me.
How Realistic Is a 50% Loss?
That's the cost of losing money, and that’s why I believe losing money is more dangerous to your retirement than lower returns. Yes, losing 50% of your money may be an extreme example, but people have lost that much, and in recent memory. The S&P went down almost 50% in the Y2K bear market, and dropped 57% in 2008.
One more factor to consider: I don’t believe many retirees can afford the time cost involved with waiting. If you were retired and living on your investments, would you be able to drastically cut your cost of living while you were waiting for your money to come back to even?
What People Near Retirement Should Do
In my opinion, the best way to make your savings last is to employ a conservative investment approach once you’re within five years of retirement. That approach should include:
- Taking only as much risk as is necessary to accomplish your financial goals.
- Employing a strategy that can protect your investments during bear markets.
Yes, those tactics may result in lower returns. But as I think I’ve shown, the cost of lower returns can be worth the cost of protecting your retirement.
Ken Moraif, CFP, is CEO and senior adviser at Retirement Planners of America (opens in new tab), a Dallas-based wealth management and investment firm with over $4.3 billion in AUM and serving over 8,000 households (as of May 2019). He is also the host of the radio show "Money Matters with Ken Moraif," which has offered listeners retirement, investing and personal finance advice since 1996.
-
-
Tax Season is Here. What to Know Before You File
The IRS is accepting tax returns for the 2023 tax season, but there are some important things to know before you file.
By Kelley R. Taylor • Published
-
6 Questions Your Financial Adviser Should be Asking
To effectively help you with your retirement strategy, a retirement professional must get a clear picture of what you have and what you need.
By Tyler Hill, Investment Adviser Representative • Published
-
6 Questions Your Financial Adviser Should be Asking
To effectively help you with your retirement strategy, a retirement professional must get a clear picture of what you have and what you need.
By Tyler Hill, Investment Adviser Representative • Published
-
Financial Planning Should Be Intergenerational
Overcoming the unspoken rule that money is too taboo a topic to discuss among family members is important going forward. The reality is that families, at some point, will need to be on the same page about wealth planning.
By Aditi Javeri Gokhale • Published
-
In Retirement Planning, What’s Your Retirement Personality?
There are many ways to think about retirement planning, and your personality can influence yours. If your personality and plan match, you have a greater chance of retirement success.
By Samuel V. Gaeta, CFP® • Published
-
Inflation’s Toll: Cuts to Retirement Savings and Health Care
Many consumers struggling to make ends meet amid inflation are reducing retirement planning and health care, both of which can have disastrous results later in life. A professional could help.
By Kristi Martin Rodriguez • Published
-
Considering a Roth IRA Conversion? 6 Reasons It Makes Sense
Avoiding possibly higher taxes in retirement, having no RMDs and the markets being lower are just three reasons to switch to a Roth IRA.
By Kevin Webb, CFP® • Published
-
Am I Going to Be OK in Retirement? Yes, With Focus on 5 Key Areas
All it takes is protecting what you save, having an income plan, knowing your health care options, reducing your tax burden and making an estate plan.
By John Goodhue • Published
-
Estate Planning? 3 Ways to Know If Your Financial Adviser ‘Gets It’
If they understand the value and mechanics of estate planning, they can offer you peace of mind and the support your loved ones will need when you’re gone.
By Allison L. Lee, Esq. • Published
-
2023 Investment Outlook’s Big Question Focuses on Recession
Fundamentals, earnings and diversification are key after a year that left us feeling like we have a bit of a hangover.
By Michael Aloi, CFP® • Published