Why Commission-Based Compensation Can't be Transparent
The cost of investing through a broker-dealer may not be what you think it is. Believe it or not, your broker might not know the full cost structure, either.


Admittedly, commission-based brokers do have a compelling story to tell prospective clients. They will “consult” with them for free, put together a financial or investment plan at no charge and they will even make a product recommendation that won’t result in any charges unless the client decides to buy. In many cases, clients won’t have to pay the adviser anything for purchasing the investment. How could that be bad?
Today’s consumers are savvy enough to know that there are no free lunches. Most people are willing to pay for what they perceive as quality advice. In fact, with their financial futures at stake, most people want to know that their adviser is being well compensated. This is why, when told that an investment product won’t cost them anything, they are quick to ask, “Well, how do you get paid?” To which a commission-based adviser might answer, “I get paid by my firm,” or “[the name of the product provider] pays me.” This is, to a great extent, very true. In fact, with most commission-based or fee-based product sales, the adviser is not paid directly by the client, but rather by a third party in the form of a commission or fee, which is the essence of a “sales transaction.”
So, the broker cannot be accused of obfuscation because it’s how the process works. The client is satisfied that the broker will receive compensation, and he is especially pleased that there is no out-of-pocket cost for the investment purchase. But that is the extent of the compensation disclosure. The client will never know how much the broker earned on the sale, nor will he know what the firm or the third-party provider earned. While the client may not feel worse off for not knowing – after all, it didn’t cost him anything – his ignorance may be costing him a great deal more than he knows. In fact, to some extent, the broker-dealer relies upon client ignorance in order to maximize its revenue.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
What the client doesn’t know about the way commission-based advisers are compensated, or how the revenue food chain works, allows the broker-dealer to mark up the price of products, or increase their share of the revenue generated by third-party fees charged against the client’s assets. Whatever the method used by the broker-dealer, the net result is a more expensive investment product for the client over the long run. To understand the revenue food chain is to understand that investments sold through broker-dealers must be able to compensate all parties in order to make it worthwhile to offer the product.
If it sounds convoluted, it is. Even the brokers often aren’t privy to the food chain compensation structure; so, the lack of transparency cuts across two layers – the client level and the adviser level. That means, in many cases, brokers couldn’t provide full disclosure to the client even if they wanted to.
The crux of the problem in commission-based sales is that the broker is not compensated directly from the client, but from the firm or a third party. Ultimately, brokers represent the source of their compensation. The only way they can represent their clients exclusively is if they are compensated directly by the client. In the end, the client cannot be assured that he is receiving unbiased advice because the broker is being compensated by the firm.
In a fee-only fiduciary relationship, the adviser is compensated directly by the client, which means the adviser is in a position to fully disclose how the fee is applied and how all parties to a transaction are compensated. That kind of transparency is a crystal-clear benefit to consumers saving for retirement.
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.

Woodring is founding partner of San Francisco Bay area Cypress Partners, a fee-only wealth consulting practice that provides personalized, comprehensive services that help retirees and busy professionals to enjoy life free of financial concern.
-
Stocks Swing in Volatile Session: Stock Market Today
The main indexes fell sharply in early trading on rising China tensions, but rebounded thanks to encouraging bank earnings.
-
Don't Miss Out! A Quiz on Medicare Enrollment Deadlines
Quiz Test your basic knowledge of Medicare enrollment periods in our quick quiz.
-
A 'Fast, Fair and Friendly' Fail: Farmers Irks Customers With Its Handling of a Data Breach
Farmers Insurance is facing negative attention and lawsuits because of a three-month delay in notifying 1.1 million policyholders about a data breach. Here's what you can do if you're affected.
-
Serving the HNW Market: How Financial Advisers Can Break Through and Deliver Lasting Value
Financial advisers have a significant opportunity to serve high-net-worth clients by elevating their capabilities, delivering comprehensive planning, building diverse teams and prioritizing family wealth education.
-
Don't Just Sell, Connect: How Financial Advisers Can Ignite Their Sales Growth
Avoid complacency and embrace small, consistent improvements to optimize your sales process and results.
-
Are You a Small Business Owner Buckling Under Economic Pressure? Here's How You Can Cope
Significant emotional and financial challenges, including tariff worries, are piling up on small business leaders. Here's how leaders can develop more healthy coping strategies and systems of support.
-
To Raise Prices or Not to Raise Prices: Tariff Tips for Small Businesses
Small businesses are making critical decisions. Should they pass on higher costs due to tariffs, or would that only cost them more in lost customers?
-
Five Retirement Planning Traps You Can't Afford to Fall Into, From a Wealth Adviser
To help ensure you reach your savings goals and enjoy financial security in your golden years, be aware of these common pitfalls. The key is to be proactive, informed and flexible.
-
Your 401(k) Can Now Include Alternative Assets, But Should It? A Financial Adviser Weighs In
Many employer-sponsored plans offer limited investment options, which can stunt growth. But participants considering alternatives might need some sound advice to get the most from their accounts.
-
Will Taxes Shred Your 401(k) or IRA During Your Retirement? It's Very Likely
Conventional wisdom dictates that you save in a 401(k) now and pay taxes later, but turning that rule on its head could leave you far better off. A financial planner explains why.