Advertisement
Business Costs & Regulation

Extending the Payroll Tax Cut Is a Cop-out

Shell-shocked consumers aren’t putting the money into the economy, and neither would firms.

It’s an idea bad enough, by today’s standards of leadership, to attract broad bipartisan support: Next week, President Obama is likely to propose another temporary cut in payroll taxes as a way to stimulate the economy.

That’s the way things work now. Good ideas to help the country tend to require sacrifice and also challenge the interests or the orthodoxy of one party. Bad ideas -- those that won’t work and waste money -- have a surface appeal, duck hard choices and are thus irresistible to our political leaders.

Advertisement - Article continues below

It is telling that the debate about Obama’s jobs plan hasn’t been about its content. Instead, like two seventh graders competing for attention, Republicans and the White House bickered over whether the president would deliver his speech Wednesday -- upstaging a Republican presidential debate -- or Thursday, when it might clash with the kickoff of the National Football League season.

White House officials have encouraged the idea that a major piece of the jobs plan will be some form of short-term payroll tax cut such as the one enacted last December.

The idea behind cutting individual taxes to stimulate the economy during a downturn is that the money replaces lost income and heads off a drop in consumer spending (70% of economic activity) that could tip the economy into a recession.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

But that works only when consumers believe that the downturn will be brief. If you think that the bad times will last for years and that you might even lose your job, you tend to save your extra income. That’s been especially true recently, after a financial crisis that encouraged almost everyone to reduce debt. People saved about 2% of their incomes before the financial crisis; now they’re saving 5%.

Advertisement - Article continues below

We don’t know how much of this year’s payroll tax cut -- reducing the normal tax paid by employees from 6.2% to 4.2% -- was actually spent. But research on past examples of such tax rebates suggests it wasn’t very much. In 2008, $100 billion in onetime rebate checks to taxpayers resulted in about $20 billion in added spending, according to Harvard economist Martin Feldstein, who originally supported the idea.

Other research shows that such onetime rebates are about twice as likely to increase spending as rebates dribbled out through lower withholding in paychecks, the approach for the payroll tax cut. A very rough estimate is that a repeat of the $110-billion payroll rebate might deliver as little as $11 billion in added spending, with the majority used to pay down credit cards and other debt.

Obama and other supporters of the payroll tax cut argued that it wouldn’t worsen the long-term budget deficit because it was only temporary. These same voices now warn that expiration of the tax cut would hit the struggling economy with a tax increase. Republicans claim they will oppose more payroll tax cuts, but they’ll go along in the end.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below
Advertisement - Article continues below

One option would be to renew the current rebate for workers. Another would be to reduce the corresponding 6.2% payroll tax that employers pay, in keeping with the president’s focus on job creation. Or both could divide a tax cut.

It seems even less likely that employers, rather than workers, would respond in a way that boosted the economy. The idea is that employers would use the tax savings to hire workers or raise pay. But unlike a onetime purchase by a consumer with a little more money this year, hiring a worker and hiking wages is a longer-term proposition for most employers. It’s not practical to hire and train most workers for only a year, or to raise wages one year and cut them the next.

Small business owners report that the overwhelming reason they aren’t hiring is a lack of demand -- high labor costs aren’t at the top of the list. It seems likely that any employer rebate would pad profits or otherwise be saved.

Advertisement - Article continues below

What are the “good” alternatives that leaders won’t fight for? Direct spending by the government to create jobs has proved to be the most efficient form of stimulus. To offset the impact on the deficit, Congress could tackle some really wasteful things, such as unneeded weapons systems, subsidies to wealthy farmers and mortgage interest deductions for third and fourth homes.

Instead of creating jobs, the president seems likely to logroll with Congress over a transportation bill similar to the spending in the 2009 American Recovery and Reinvestment Act, which was plundered by contractors who created very few private sector jobs. And neither party, both of which are busy raising campaign cash, will declare war on the farm lobby, defense contractors or real estate brokers.

It would be easier to holler about these handouts if we weren’t all about to mutely accept our own, in the form of another payroll tax cut that will go to savings or bill collectors but won’t help the economy.

Advertisement

Most Popular

2020 Stock Market Holidays and Bond Market Holidays
Markets

2020 Stock Market Holidays and Bond Market Holidays

Is the market open today? Take a look at which holidays the stock markets and bond markets take off in 2020.
July 1, 2020
What Are the Income Tax Brackets for 2020 vs. 2019?
tax brackets

What Are the Income Tax Brackets for 2020 vs. 2019?

The IRS unveiled the 2020 tax brackets, and it's never too early to start planning to minimize your future tax bill.
June 20, 2020
Searching for the Perfect Place to Retire
Empty Nesters

Searching for the Perfect Place to Retire

We home in on two places with less traffic and lower costs. 
July 2, 2020

Recommended

Travel Planning in the Time of Coronavirus
business

Travel Planning in the Time of Coronavirus

Insurance may not cover canceled vacations, but airlines and hotels may be flexible.
June 11, 2020
13 Things That May Soon Disappear Forever (The Pandemic Edition)
business

13 Things That May Soon Disappear Forever (The Pandemic Edition)

Emerging technologies (and now the COVID-19 pandemic) are putting an end to these familiar items and practices.
June 9, 2020
Don't Let the Drama Surrounding PPP Distract You from Running Your Business
business

Don't Let the Drama Surrounding PPP Distract You from Running Your Business

If you're so wrapped up in worry about your Paycheck Protection Program loan not being forgiven, think about the worst-case scenario. It might not be …
June 5, 2020
Another Epidemic to Worry About: Identity Theft
business

Another Epidemic to Worry About: Identity Theft

Fraud losses grew in 2019 and are likely to increase in 2020.
June 5, 2020