Advertisement
Business Costs & Regulation

Should Execs Return Bonuses They Don’t Merit?

Getting ill-gotten gains returned to shareholders remains the exception, not the rule.

Q. I own stock in a company that saw its share price plunge after previously hidden problems came to light, resulting in a restatement of earnings for two previous years. The CEO apologized and took “full responsibility” for not knowing about all this, but he and other executives haven’t offered to return any of the huge bonuses they got when the stock was flying high. Your thoughts, please.

Advertisement - Article continues below

SEE ALSO: The Money and Ethics Quiz

A. I would like to see senior executives in such situations offer truly voluntary restitution, which is what "taking responsibility" should mean. But this almost never happens. Even the seemingly voluntary giveback of bonuses by a few executives at AIG -- bailed out by U.S. taxpayers in 2008 -- occurred in the glare of negative publicity.

Under federal mandates (Sarbanes-Oxley, and soon, Dodd-Frank), most publicly traded companies today have "clawback" provisions in their executive employment contracts, enabling their boards to seek return of past pay when things go seriously wrong.

But boards rarely initiate this -- a sign of their being too cozy with senior managers, their supposed servants. Most cases of restitution have resulted from Securities and Exchange Commission action ($468 million from the former head of UnitedHealth Group), criminal prosecution (against Tyco's former CEO, for example) or the threat of protracted civil litigation (the recent $104 million settlement with former partners of law firm Dewey & LeBoeuf). Huge trading losses at UBS and JPMorgan Chase are likely to trigger clawback rules at those banks, but it's unclear how far up the executive ladder the restitution will go.

Most corporations try to avoid the acrimony of forced clawbacks by not paying cash bonuses after the books close each year. Instead, they use a variety of deferral methods -- restricted stock and options that can't be sold or exercised for several years, or cash bonuses paid into accounts that can't be tapped for several years and can be docked if an executive's actions are later found to have caused big losses.

These are small steps in the right direction.

Research was performed by editorial intern Ted Leonhardt from Duke University. Have a money-and-ethics question you'd like answered? Write to editor in chief Knight Kiplinger at ethics@kiplinger.com.

This article first appeared in Kiplinger's Personal Finance magazine. For more help with your personal finances and investments, please subscribe to the magazine. It might be the best investment you ever make.

Advertisement
Advertisement

Most Popular

How To Buy a Roth IRA When You Make Too Much To Qualify For One
Roth IRAs

How To Buy a Roth IRA When You Make Too Much To Qualify For One

With their tax-free growth and tax-free withdrawals, Roth IRAs are a great deal — if you qualify. If you don’t, well, there’s still a way to get into …
September 23, 2020
High-Tech Aids for Aging in Place
Caregiving

High-Tech Aids for Aging in Place

Apple Watch and other technology provides fast feedback, comfort for older users, and a powerful assist for caregivers.
September 23, 2020
Social Security Recipients, Veterans Must Act Now to Get Extra $500 Stimulus Check
Coronavirus and Your Money

Social Security Recipients, Veterans Must Act Now to Get Extra $500 Stimulus Check

The deadline for seniors and veterans to request an additional $500 stimulus check for a dependent child is approaching fast. See how you can claim yo…
September 25, 2020

Recommended

Election 2020: Joe Biden's Tax Plans
taxes

Election 2020: Joe Biden's Tax Plans

With the economy in trouble, tax policy takes on added importance in the 2020 presidential election. So, let's take a look at what Joe Biden has said …
September 18, 2020
The Most Expensive Natural Disasters in U.S. History
Economic Forecasts

The Most Expensive Natural Disasters in U.S. History

Wind, water, fire and drought have all wreaked havoc on the United States. What’s been the worst?
August 26, 2020
Vote by Mail: A State-by-State Guide to Absentee Ballot Voting
Politics

Vote by Mail: A State-by-State Guide to Absentee Ballot Voting

With health authorities recommending people continue to social distance, the idea of voting by mail is becoming an increasingly hot topic.
August 4, 2020
Answers to PPP Loan FAQs (Now That There's Fresh Funding for the Loans)
small business loans

Answers to PPP Loan FAQs (Now That There's Fresh Funding for the Loans)

Small business owners are getting another crack at Paycheck Protection Program loans. Here are answers to some frequently asked questions about the lo…
July 21, 2020