Q: I recently learned that a very successful competitor -- who always seems to be undercutting my pricing -- employs very few of his staff directly. Most of his work is done by people he defines as independent contractors. (I hear that some of them used to be his employees, but he laid them off and promptly hired them back as "freelancers.") He apparently saves all the money that I pay for my staff's Social Security, unemployment insurance, worker's comp, health care and vacations, not to mention my HR administrative costs. Am I being a chump, or is he unethical?
It is not unethical for a business owner to try to reduce costs and lower prices to his customers, especially if it can be accomplished through efficiency, economies of scale and innovation. That's working smart. But fattening the bottom line at the expense of one's employees is not ethical. The most respected employers offer good benefits to full-time employees.
Maybe your competitor's workers are bona fide independent contractors. If so, in addition to his savings in taxes and benefits, he also enjoys the flexibility of reducing his labor costs without having to lay off real employees.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
But your competitor might be one of thousands of employers who are breaking federal law by misclassifying long-term, full-time employees as freelancers and independent contractors. This is the subject of heightened scrutiny by the IRS and the Department of Labor. The IRS has a multipart test for this classification, and it requires a surprisingly high degree of autonomy on the part of these workers. True independent contractors typically work for more than one client at a time, set their own hours, and don't receive training or close supervision from their clients.
In addition to the risk of government audits, employers who don't heed the accepted rules of independent contracting could be vulnerable to whistle-blowing by disgruntled workers and former employees.
-
-
Trusting Fintech: Four Critical Moves to Protect Yourself
A few relatively easy steps can help you safeguard your money when using bank and budgeting apps and other financial technology.
-
Four Ways Women Can Take Control of Their Financial Health
Adjusting for life events, taking advantage of workplace benefits and preparing for caregiving can make a big difference in your financial future.
-
Airbnb Host Tells What It's Like
Business Costs & Regulation This Denver pharmacist began booking her ski condo a few months after the pandemic hit.
-
Tough Times for a Family Business
Business Costs & Regulation His dry-cleaning operation was rocked by the pandemic, but he is staying optimistic.
-
IRS Gives Truckers a Tax Break in Response to the Colonial Pipeline Shutdown
Tax Breaks The tax penalty for using dyed diesel fuel for highway use is temporarily suspended.
-
Reliving a Harlem Renaissance
Business Costs & Regulation After a tough winter, two sisters look forward to reviving their restaurant’s business.
-
Add a VPN to Surf the Internet Safely
Technology To help you fight identity theft, consider adding a VPN.
-
Stephanie Creary: Making the Case for Diversity on Corporate Boards
Business Costs & Regulation Adding underrepresented voices can improve a company’s bottom line.
-
How We Lose When We Overlook Black Talent
Business Executives Comments from Wells Fargo CEO Charles Scharf (pictured) reflect a culture that tramples on clients’ trust and limits opportunities for people of color.
-
Retirees, Create An Emergency Fund for Rental Property
Business Costs & Regulation Build a cushion to protect your income from an unforeseen crisis.
