Why Are the Notes Found in Aretha Franklin’s Couch a Valid Will?
The late Queen of Soul’s discovered notes had to meet certain Michigan requirements to be considered a valid will. The outcome might have been different in other states.


Aretha Franklin was known as the Queen of Soul. She will be forever remembered for her musical legacy, which includes “(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman,” “Respect,” “I Say a Little Prayer” and “Chain of Fools.” She died in 2018 at the age of 76 from pancreatic cancer.
Franklin’s entertainment attorney for almost 30 years, Don Wilson, indicated that Franklin was “a very private person who did not want to share private information” with others, including an attorney, which is why she would write her wishes and estate plan informally by herself.
Franklin prepared a 2010 will that was securely maintained. The 2010 will was discovered in a locked cabinet in her home. That will was not formally typed, but it was written in her own hand. This type of handwritten will is referred to as a “holographic will.”

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Each state has its own requirements for a holographic will to be valid. In Michigan, where Franklin lived, the document must be substantially written in the maker’s own hand, be dated and be signed. These requirements are critically important for the Queen of Soul’s estate. Alternatively, a formal “typed” will, such as a will prepared by an attorney, must be signed in the presence of two witnesses.
Michigan jury considers notes a valid will
Two crumpled notes were found after her death underneath Franklin’s couch cushions. Those notes, taken together, were determined by the Michigan court to constitute a valid will. Those notes were dated in 2014 (after the 2010 will). The notes were written entirely in Franklin’s own hand and signed with a smiley face and “A. Franklin.” The Michigan court determined that these “couch notes” constituted a valid will under Michigan law.
Both the 2010 will and the 2014 will provided for Franklin’s four sons to share income from music and copyrights. However, the 2014 will left Franklin’s primary residence to her son Kecalf Franklin and her grandchildren. That home was valued at $1.1 million at the time of her death in 2018 but is worth substantially more now.
The 2010 will required her sons Kecalf Franklin and Edward Franklin to take business classes and obtain a certificate or degree to benefit from the estate. That requirement was not present in the 2014 will. When a court is presented with multiple documents as the decedent’s will, only the last or most recent will controls.
However, the court will also consider whether the second writing is an informal amendment to the first. In other words, can the two documents be read together, or are there inconsistencies that prevent that interpretation? Note that all formally lawyer-prepared wills typically begin with this or a similar sentence: “This is my last will and testament, and I revoke all prior wills” to prevent such an analysis.
Here, the court determined that the “crumpled notes in the sofa” alone constituted Aretha Franklin’s final controlling will. Under Michigan law, the decision that this was a valid will was made by a jury.
How the case might have played out in other states
In California, California Probate Code Section 8252 generally provides that the court (and not a jury) will try and determine contested issues of fact that affect the validity of a will. In California, this would likely have been decided by a judge and not a jury. A judge may have reached a different conclusion due to the interlineations and scribbling, which may not have been viewed as a final expression of her wishes.
Note that Florida does not recognize handwritten wills that are not signed in the presence of two witnesses. If in Florida, Franklin would have been intestate (not having a will), and the beneficiaries would be determined under the Florida probate code.
Most people seek to avoid formal probate court proceedings because the cost is higher, that process takes more time, and all information, including asset information, is completely available to the public as public information.
Franklin’s estate was, at one time, valued at over $80 million. This was substantially reduced by estate tax, the legal fees resulting from years of litigation between her family members, probate court costs and related fees and other unpaid taxes.
Proper planning could have avoided virtually all of those costs and expenses. A revocable trust could have been used to avoid probate costs and expenses. Estate tax planning with irrevocable trusts and other entities could have entirely avoided the estate tax liability.
The legacy left to her children could have been provided in a secure asset protected formally. She could have better planned to pass down her family values and priorities. Instead, the family was embroiled in expensive, long-lasting litigation to resolve this dispute.
Get Kiplinger Today newsletter — free
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.

Founder of The Goralka Law Firm, John M. Goralka assists business owners, real estate owners and successful families to achieve their enlightened dreams by better protecting their assets, minimizing income and estate tax and resolving messes and transitions to preserve, protect and enhance their legacy. John is one of few California attorneys certified as a Specialist by the State Bar of California Board of Legal Specialization in both Taxation and Estate Planning, Trust and Probate. You can read more of John's articles on the Kiplinger Advisor Collective.
-
80-Year Old Dick Durbin, the Senate’s No. 2 Democrat, To Retire After 44 Years in Congress
‘In my heart, I know it’s time to pass the torch,’ Senator Durbin said in a statement.
By Kathryn Pomroy
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Rise on Good Volatility
Investors, traders and speculators continue to process the "known unknown" of global tariff-and-trade war negotiations.
By David Dittman
-
Before You Invest Like a Politician, Consider This Dilemma
As apps that track congressional stock trading become more popular, investors need to take into consideration some caveats.
By Ryan K. Snover, Investment Adviser Representative
-
How to Put Together Your Personal Net Worth Statement
Now that tax season is over for most of us, it's the perfect time to organize your assets and liabilities to assess your financial wellness.
By Denise McClain, JD, CPA
-
Bouncing Back: New Tunes for Millennials Trying to Make It
Adele's mournful melodies kick off this generation's financial playlist, but with the right plan, Millennials can finish strong.
By Alvina Lo
-
Early-Stage Startup Deals: How Do Convertible Notes Work?
Some angel investors support early startups by providing a loan in exchange for a convertible note, which includes annual interest and a maturity date.
By Murat Abdrakhmanov
-
SRI Redefined: Going Beyond Socially Responsible Investing
Now that climate change has progressed to a changed climate, sustainable investing needs to evolve to address new demands of resilience and innovation.
By Peter Krull, CSRIC®
-
Here's When a Lack of Credit Card Debt Can Cause You Problems
Usually, getting a new credit card can be difficult if you have too much card debt, but this bank customer ran into an issue because he had no debt at all.
By H. Dennis Beaver, Esq.
-
Going to College? How to Navigate the Financial Planning
College decisions this year seem even more complex than usual, including determining whether a school is a 'financial fit.' Here's how to find your way.
By Chris Ebeling
-
Financial Steps After a Loved One's Alzheimer's Diagnosis
It's important to move fast on legal safeguards, estate planning and more while your loved one still has the capacity to make decisions.
By Thomas C. West, CLU®, ChFC®, AIF®