Watch Out for the ‘Medigap Trap’
The Medigap trap can snag those who chose Medicare Advantage and plan to switch to traditional Medicare later as their needs change.

A bit of foresight can save you from the Medigap trap — yet one more rule to learn when navigating Medicare and Medicare Advantage (MA). In short, it’s a mistake to plan to enroll in MA when you’re relatively healthy, thinking you can just switch to traditional Medicare as you get older and sicker, says David A. Lipschutz, co-director of the Center for Medicare Advocacy.
MA can be attractive when first enrolling in Medicare for beneficiaries who aren’t worried about network restrictions on doctors or pre-approval requirements for high-level care.
Technically, people who choose an MA plan can change their minds every year during open enrollment and move to traditional government-run Medicare with its unrestricted access to providers who take Medicare. It may be tempting to think about switching when health declines or there’s a need to see providers not in the MA network. But it’s not that easy. Welcome to the Medigap Trap.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
The Medigap trap
“There's not free movement between traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage in large part because of the barriers to picking up a Medigap policy,” Lipschutz says.
Medigap is the umbrella name for an array of private insurance policies that supplement traditional Medicare, making out-of-pocket costs for care more manageable. Without Medigap, out-of-pocket costs for traditional Medicare enrollees can be overwhelming.
While MA plans cap annual out-of-pocket spending, traditional Medicare does not. And the charges can add up quickly. To start, without Medigap, traditional Medicare patients must pay 20% of the cost for covered medical services after meeting a deductible. And patients who are hospitalized for a long period are charged as much as $816 per day. A separate Medigap policy can pick up a lot of those costs, making treatment covered by Medicare more affordable.
But if a Medicare participant doesn’t enroll in a Medigap plan when first signing up for Medicare, supplemental coverage may be unavailable later. In most states, Medigap plans are automatically available only in the first six months after an enrollee becomes eligible for Medicare. After that, health screening may be required and the plans can refuse coverage or charge higher rates for those with health issues.
Where you live matters
Only four states — Connecticut, Massachusetts, Maine and New York — prohibit insurers from denying a Medigap policy to eligible applicants, including people with pre-existing conditions.
An enrollee in another state who wants to switch from MA to traditional Medicare may be unable to get or afford Medigap. While they retain the option to make this switch during open enrollment, the higher cost of care may make a traditional plan unworkable.
Says Lipshutz: “Unless you're in one of those handful of states, you very well might find that you cannot purchase a Medigap policy and then it could be very expensive.”
Note: This item first appeared in Kiplinger Retirement Report, our popular monthly periodical that covers key concerns of affluent older Americans who are retired or preparing for retirement. Subscribe for retirement advice that’s right on the money.
Read More
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
Elaine Silvestrini has worked for Kiplinger since 2021, serving as senior retirement editor since 2022. Before that, she had an extensive career as a newspaper and online journalist, primarily covering legal issues at the Tampa Tribune and the Asbury Park Press in New Jersey. In more recent years, she's written for several marketing, legal and financial websites, including Annuity.org and LegalExaminer.com, and the newsletters Auto Insurance Report and Property Insurance Report.
-
The Y Rule of Retirement: Why Men Need to Plan Differently
If you have a Y chromosome (because you're a guy), following the 'Y rule of retirement' can help you transition to this new life stage with grace.
-
Retire on This Island for Mediterranean Living on the Cheap
This independent nation has a lower cost of living and more visa options than many of its Mediterranean cousins.
-
A Taxable Brokerage Account May Be What Your Retirement Is Missing
You can supplement your retirement nest egg or save for other goals with a taxable brokerage account.
-
How to Guard Against the New Generation of Fraud and Identity Theft
Identity Theft Fraud and identity theft are getting more sophisticated and harder to spot. Stay ahead of the scammers with our advice.
-
You Need to Have This Financial Talk With Your Spouse
Women are poised to inherit significant wealth from their husbands. Here's how they can prepare for it.
-
Sibling Bonds May Wax and Wane: Here's How To Safeguard Them
Sibling Bonds May Wax and Wane: Here's How To Safeguard Them
-
Your Online Security: 10 Things You Should Know
Online security is more tenuous given the rise of AI. Arm yourself against internet criminals with these tips to strengthen online security.
-
How to Tell Your Own Story
Your life told well could be the best gift you can leave.
-
Can AI Help With Your Finances?
ChatGPT and other artificial-intelligence tools will streamline certain tasks, but don't count on them to get everything right.
-
Nine Things You May Not Know About Social Security
Even if you’ve been collecting benefits for years, you may have more to learn.