Planning a holiday party or gathering? A white elephant gift exchange might seem like the perfect centerpiece. But will it resonate with your group, or could there be better ways to create a fun and memorable experience?
When it comes to holiday party games, few are as widely known as the white elephant gift exchange. The basic premise is simple: Purchase something inexpensive that will get some laughs or head scratches when someone chooses the gift. White elephant gift exchanges promote light-hearted fun, especially in settings like the workplace, social clubs and family gatherings.
Not sold on the idea of a white elephant exchange? There are other creative ways to celebrate that can still bring holiday cheer to your group's gathering.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Be a smarter, better informed investor.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Festive alternatives to white elephant gift exchange
Here are a few alternative activities that can make your holiday gathering special while creating connection:
Secret Santa exchange - Participants are randomly assigned to buy a thoughtful gift for a specific person in the group. This approach allows for more intentional giving, as it often involves learning about the recipient’s preferences and selecting something they’d enjoy. It still keeps an element of surprise but adds a personal touch that many find more meaningful.
Ornament exchange - Everyone brings an ornament to swap, either through a random draw or by assigning exchange partners in advance. In the end, each participant walks away with a charming keepsake to decorate their home for future holiday seasons.
Holiday donation drive - Instead of a gift exchange, participants contribute to a chosen cause or organization. This approach creates a sense of community, reinforces the spirit of giving, and supports those in need during the holiday season.
Pros and cons of white elephant gifting
Before making a final decision, it helps to weigh the pros and cons of a white elephant gift exchange.
White elephant gift exchanges can offer a great, stress-free way for everyone to be included and have fun, regardless of how expensive a gift they can afford. Additionally, this holiday party game is great for those who don't seem to need or want anything. The point is to have fun and laugh rather than feel pressured about buying something that most people will need.
On the other hand, some people don't enjoy exchanging silly gifts, especially when there's a chance no one will want any of them because they're items intended for laughs. Additionally, some people may feel awkward trying to pick out something for a gift exchange, and those whose gift is stolen might feel hurt. Finally, some people might feel like participating in a white elephant gift exchange is simply a waste of money.
Whether or not white elephant gifting fits your crowd, the goal is the same: to create moments of joy and connection. Choose the activities that best suit your group’s spirit, and you’re sure to make lasting holiday memories.
Holiday gift exchange deals
Setting a maximum budget for your gift exchange can help set expectations and keep everyone included. Tools like Elfster make it easy to organize participants, draw names, create and share wish lists and keep everything on track.
If you're celebrating remotely, platforms like White Elephant Online allow teams and families to join a virtual gift exchange and participate from anywhere.
A $25 limit is a common sweet spot for office groups, friend gatherings and family parties because it keeps gifting fun without adding financial pressure. Below are some retailer gift ideas under $25 to help you get started:
- Shop Amazon gifts under $25
- Shop Costco gifts under $25
- Shop Walmart gifts under $25
- Shop Target gifts under $25
- Shop Etsy gifts under $25
RELATED CONTENT
-
6 Changes to IRAs, 401(k)s and HSAs in 2026Changes to IRAs — Roth and traditional — and 401(k)s may mean more money for you in retirement.
-
Turkey, Tariffs, and Grocery Taxes: The Cost of Thanksgiving Dinner 2025Food Taxes For some who celebrate, Thanksgiving can mean a full table, family, and a sense of gratitude. But in this year, it also means a focus on the bottom line.
-
Amazon Haul Gift Guide: Under-$20 Gifts That Keep Your Holiday Budget in TactFrom stocking stuffers to budget-friendly crowd pleasers, these are the best under-$20 gifts on Amazon Haul right now.
-
7 Frugal Habits That Aren't Worth It (and What to Do Instead)Avoiding waste is important, but some frugal habits are just more trouble than they're worth.
-
How Much Should You Spend on Holiday Gifts This SeasonWith U.S. consumers spending near record levels on holiday items, here's how much to allocate for gift-giving, how to avoid debt and how to fit your budget into your bigger financial picture.
-
Stores Open (and Closed) on Thanksgiving Day 2025From grocery stores to big-box retailers, here’s where you can shop and where you’ll find doors shut on Thanksgiving.
-
10 Cities Where Grocery Prices Are HighestThese 10 cities are paying up to 33% more than the rest of the country to keep food on the table.
-
Protect Your Family From Costly Festive Fails With These Holiday TipsHaving people over this holiday season? Before opening the door to guests, here are some perils to prepare for in advance.
-
Does My Car Insurance Cover Rental Cars?Is it safe to decline the extra coverage car rental companies offer you when booking? Here's what you need to know.
-
Costco Gold Bars Keep Selling Out. Are They a Smart Investment?How Costco's bullion program works, how to get the best deal and whether it makes sense for investors.
