How Much Insurance Should You Get? A Lawyer’s Advice
The advice to “Only pay for what you need” sounds good. But when it comes to home, auto and business insurance coverage, four guidelines could help determine how much that really might be.


Thomas, a reader in Chicago, wrote: “Liberty Mutual Insurance television commercials, which state ‘Only Pay for What You Need,’ appear to suggest that other insurance companies will sell you coverages you don’t need. I’ll bet a lot of people wonder what they mean.”
This column has received similar comments, and to find out what ‘Only pay for what you need” means, I contacted the company’s media relations team at Boston-Based Liberty Mutual, asking them that very question. That was weeks ago, and I am still waiting for a response. So, I turned to a trial attorney whose law practice concentrates on insurance company bad faith and asked him what he thought. The discussion that followed surprised me.
Customers Typically Should Insist on More than Minimums
“When they say you will only pay for what you need, they are implying that other insurance companies will automatically sell you coverages that you do not need, which is complete nonsense,” says Los Angeles-based attorney Shant Karnikian.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Actually, the opposite may tend to be true about some insurance companies, he says. They may prefer if customers bought less insurance coverage, not more. And that can be a problem for consumers.
“The insurance industry wants to minimize exposure to future customer losses, and plaintiff lawyers are already seeing this reflected in the companies’ marketing practices, where they only want to sell minimum limits of auto or homeowners insurance, reducing payouts in the event of a claim. If you buy more coverage, they are exposed to paying more for the loss.
“Even if you need it, they don’t want to sell it! But if you ask for more coverage, they are obligated to sell it to you. This means consumers must become educated and learn the coverages they absolutely must have.”
Insurance Agents Not Required to Advise What Coverages You Need
“Auto and property insurance companies let you accept or decline various types of coverage,” Karnikian says, “and today especially, the public needs to be aware that, with some very limited exceptions, insurance agents are not required to counsel their customers as to what they should be purchasing.”
That’s right. Insurance agents are typically not required to tell you what coverages are available or what you likely need. “In most instances, insurance agents are mere order takers, and unless you tell them what you want, they are generally under no obligation of advising you to obtain certain types of coverage,” he observes.
Keep These Coverage Guidelines in Mind
For those shopping for insurance, Karnikian gives these recommendations:
- Auto Insurance: Never buy just the minimum amounts that are required by your state, which varies and may be as low as $10,000 per person or $20,000 per accident. Buy 50/100,000 liability limits or more, meaning $50,000 per person or $100,000 per accident. And always purchase medical payments coverage and uninsured/under-insured coverage in limits no less than $100,000.
- Homeowners/Commercial Property Insurance: Overestimate the cost of rebuilding your home or office, and include coverage to bring the property current with building codes. In a major loss — such as a wildfire — material and labor costs will be far greater than at normal times. Inadequate coverage means you will have to pay out of pocket the difference in price.
- Ask in Writing: “What is the most coverage that I can possibly get for my home, car, liability and business?” The difference in premium costs between the basic policy and a much larger one will not shock the conscience. It is definitely worth it.
- Consider a Broker Instead of an Agent: Brokers are not limited to selling policies from just one company. They work for you. Agents are limited to selling only the policies of the company they work for, which may not have the best policy for your needs.
Karnikian concluded our discussion with this advice: “Imagine the cost of your worst-case scenario and buy insurance in limits high enough to cover it.”
Get Kiplinger Today newsletter — free
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
After attending Loyola University School of Law, H. Dennis Beaver joined California's Kern County District Attorney's Office, where he established a Consumer Fraud section. He is in the general practice of law and writes a syndicated newspaper column, "You and the Law." Through his column, he offers readers in need of down-to-earth advice his help free of charge. "I know it sounds corny, but I just love to be able to use my education and experience to help, simply to help. When a reader contacts me, it is a gift."
-
How We Found This List of the Best REITs to Buy Now
Real estate investment trusts, or REITs, are a special class of stocks that are known for their high dividend yields. Here's how to find the best ones to buy.
By Kyle Woodley Published
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Enjoy a Fed Day Relief Rally
The question now is whether Jerome Powell and other policymakers can get the balance right given all the new noise.
By David Dittman Published
-
Alternative Investments Under Trump: What You Need to Know
As access to alternative markets opens up, retail investors looking to enhance their long-term financial outcomes have more opportunities to carefully consider.
By Henry Yoshida Published
-
Beware of TV/Billboard Personal Injury Law Firms: Here's Why
If you or someone you know is tempted to hire a so-called settlement mill to handle a personal injury case, here are some reasons to reconsider.
By H. Dennis Beaver, Esq. Published
-
How Small Businesses Can Clear the Economic Hurdles Ahead
Shifting rules on taxes, trade and regulation are creating uncertainty for SMBs. Owners can overcome that by focusing on efficiency, flexibility and investment.
By Mark Valentino Published
-
10 Tax Topics Every Retiree Should Know About
A little knowledge can go a long way toward saving on your tax bill. Print this out and take it to your tax planner so you can have a productive chat.
By Michael Miller Published
-
Facing a Layoff? Ask Your Employer These Questions Now
If you're being laid off or forced into early retirement, don't make any decisions without proper guidance — and that starts by asking some key questions.
By Ben Maxwell, ChFC®, AAMS® Published
-
Have $1M+ Saved? Consider a Financial Planning One-Stop Shop
A 'one-stop shop' team — including a financial planner, estate planning lawyer, CPA and more — could serve all of your tax, estate and retirement planning needs.
By Joe F. Schmitz Jr., CFP®, ChFC® Published
-
Five Ways to Safeguard Your Portfolio in Market Downturns
The stock market is nothing if not volatile these days. When it takes a dip, a well-managed, properly diversified portfolio could help you ride out the storm.
By Joel V. Russo, LUTCF Published
-
This Underused IRA Option Offers Tax Benefits and Income Security
Looking to avoid running out of money in retirement? Consider longevity protection provided by a QLAC as a component of your retirement income plan.
By Jerry Golden, Investment Adviser Representative Published