Becoming an Investor

When to Give Up on a Stock

Selling should have little to do with price. What matters is the business itself and whether it has changed for the worse.

Buying stocks is much easier than selling them. When you decide to purchase shares, you usually act with enthusiasm.

But selling is drenched in ambivalence. Many in­vestors just aren’t sure whether it’s the right time. The psychology can be perverse. Selling a stock in March at a 40% profit and then watching the price double by September can feel worse than selling it and watching the company go bankrupt – even though in both cases, your gain is the same.

The ones that got away hurt the most. I bought Netflix (NFLX, $510) shortly after its 2002 initial public offering. I liked the idea of circumventing video stores and believed that someday the company would figure out how to send me movies online. I sold out with what Peter Lynch called a three-bagger – a tripling in price. By December 2020, Netflix had become a 470-bagger for those who bought the IPO.

Although I continue to like the company, I can’t bring myself to buy the stock back. (Stocks and funds I like are in bold; prices are as of January 8.)

Many investors fall prey to the psychology of anchoring. If they buy a stock for $50 a share and it falls sharply, their strategy is to wait until the stock gets back to the anchor price of $50 before selling – even if they no longer like the company. Why not take the remaining proceeds and make a better investment? This misguided approach to selling is also driven by loss aversion: the idea, proven by researchers, that people would rather avoid a $1,000 loss than score a $1,000 gain.

Then there’s the desire to prevent regret. One of America’s most successful private-equity managers once told me that when he sold a stock, he took “schmuck insurance.” He always tried to maintain a small interest in the company he was selling, just in case it soared in value afterward and he looked like a fool or a jerk – a schmuck, in other words – for exiting too soon.

Buy and Hold ... And Hold

The simple antidote to being captured by the perverse psychology of selling is never to sell at all. As Warren Buffett wrote, “Inactivity strikes us as intelligent behavior.”

History shows that, for long-term investors, not selling is a profitable strategy. From 1973 through 2020, the worst rolling 20-year period (that is, January 1, 1973, to December 31, 1992; February 1, 1973, to January 31, 1992; and so on) for the S&P 500 still produced an annual average gain of 4.8% – a lot more than long-term bonds yield these days. Also, if you don’t sell, you have to make only one decision (to buy) rather than three (to buy, to sell and to buy something else). And, not selling lets you postpone capital gains taxes.

My own view is that although you should hope your stock purchase is a forever investment, you should be aware that selling is sometimes intelligent behavior. But when to sell? The late investment guru Philip A. Fisher, author of the 1957 classic Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits, focused on a company’s performance and prospects. He wrote that you should sell if there has been “a deterioration of management, or the company no longer has the prospect of increasing the markets for its products as it formerly did.”

Fisher’s concern was not the state of the economy or the actions of the Federal Reserve. What mattered to him was the business itself and whether it had changed for the worse. I will add that you cannot identify that change unless you can articulate the reason you bought the company in the first place. In other words, you can’t know when to sell unless you know why you bought.

For example, I rec­ommended (and later bought) Lululemon Athletica (LULU, $365) after its founder, Chip Wilson, a brilliant leader who had too limited a vision, resigned as chairman, and the company’s new CEO broadened the appeal of the product line and vastly increased internet sales. Since I made Lululemon my personal choice among the 10 stocks I recommended for 2018, the price has more than quintupled. Why would I sell? If new management decided to revert to Wilson’s yoga-fixated approach, if the brand tried to become all things to all people, or if fierce new competition developed.

I recommended New York Times (NYT, $48) stock on the 2019 list when it appeared the company had figured out a way to supplant lost ad revenues with online subscription dollars. The stock has nearly doubled. For now, the company has few peers as a source of sophisticated news, features and analysis. Perhaps more competitors will spring up or Times management will enter into less-worthy businesses, such as theme parks. Then, I would advise selling.

table

Like Fisher’s selling strategy, mine has little in common with the one that motivates most investors. They sell because of price: Either a stock has gone up and they want to take profits, or it has gone down and they want to avoid more losses.

It is true there are sometimes good reasons to cash in your chips. You may have a better use for the money – another investment, perhaps, or paying for your child’s education. But setting a price goal often means sacrificing huge gains. Yes, a declining price could be a signal that something is seriously wrong with the company. Examine the business for defects, as Fisher advises. If you are still passionate about it, then price declines are opportunities to buy more.

Call in the Pros

A business-centric selling strategy is not easy to follow. It requires time and a temperament for research. A good substitute is owning index funds, letting index compilers like S&P weed out deteriorating companies, and then never selling.

For this reason and because of their low expense ratios, I am always fond of index funds such as Vanguard 500 Index Admiral (VFIAX), which charges 0.04%, and exchange-traded funds including SPDR Dow Jones Industrial Average (DIA), or “Diamonds,” with expenses of 0.16%.

Established managed mutual funds that own large-cap stocks and have relatively low turnover represent another excellent approach. My favorites include Fidelity Contrafund (FCNTX), which has returned an annual average of 15.4% over the past 10 years; T. Rowe Price Growth (PRGFX), launched 71 years ago and returning 16.8% annually over the past decade; and Parnassus Endeavor (PARWX), returning 15.4%. (Note: Parnassus founder Jerome Dodson is no longer managing Endeavor, but I expect his successor, Billy Hwan, to continue the successful run.)

Another good way to avoid the pain of selling is a strategy I like to call faith-based investing. Own long-running businesses with powerful brand names and solid markets that perform well through thick and thin. Many such companies consistently raise their dividends.

For example, Johnson & Johnson (JNJ, $160), with a portfolio of pharmaceuticals, consumer health products such as Tylenol, and medical devices, increased its quarterly payout in 2020 for the 58th consecutive year. The stock currently yields 2.5%. Companies that have raised dividends for more than 40 straight years include Archer Daniels Midland (ADM, $53), an agricultural products and services company, yielding 2.7%; McDonald’s (MCD, $216), by far the most profitable restaurant chain, 2.4%; Automatic Data Processing (ADP, $171), employer services, 2.2%; and Genuine Parts (GPC, $103), vehicle products, 3.1%.

Buying and holding should be your default position. But if you believe you need to sell, try to summon at least as much conviction as when you bought.

James K. Glassman chairs Glassman Advisory, a public-affairs consulting firm. He does not write about his clients. His most recent book is Safety Net: The Strategy for De-Risking Your Investments in a Time of Turbulence. Of the securities mentioned in this column, he owns Lululemon Athletica, New York Times and Diamonds.

Most Popular

Are You Still Chasing the Almighty Dollar, Even Though You Have Plenty to Retire?
retirement

Are You Still Chasing the Almighty Dollar, Even Though You Have Plenty to Retire?

In our experience, many have saved enough money to retire comfortably. Yet too many worry about their money running out and want more. Maybe it’s tim…
May 6, 2021
Child Tax Credit 2021: Who Gets $3,600? Will I Get Monthly Payments? And Other FAQs
Coronavirus and Your Money

Child Tax Credit 2021: Who Gets $3,600? Will I Get Monthly Payments? And Other FAQs

People have lots of questions about the new $3,000 or $3,600 child tax credit and the advance payments that the IRS will send to most families in 2021…
May 4, 2021
20 Dividend Stocks to Fund 20 Years of Retirement
dividend stocks

20 Dividend Stocks to Fund 20 Years of Retirement

Each of these high-quality dividend stocks yields roughly 4%, and you can expect them to grow their payouts even more. That's a powerful 1-2 combo for…
May 7, 2021

Recommended

Stock Market Today 5/7/21: Stocks Rise as Jarring Jobs Miss Cools Taper Talk
Stock Market Today

Stock Market Today 5/7/21: Stocks Rise as Jarring Jobs Miss Cools Taper Talk

The Dow and S&P 500 ended the week at new highs after a big nonfarm payrolls miss eased anxiety the Fed will tighten the purse strings.
May 7, 2021
Kiplinger's Weekly Earnings Calendar
stocks

Kiplinger's Weekly Earnings Calendar

Check out our earnings calendar for the upcoming week, as well as our previews of the more noteworthy reports.
May 7, 2021
20 Dividend Stocks to Fund 20 Years of Retirement
dividend stocks

20 Dividend Stocks to Fund 20 Years of Retirement

Each of these high-quality dividend stocks yields roughly 4%, and you can expect them to grow their payouts even more. That's a powerful 1-2 combo for…
May 7, 2021
Stock Market Today 5/6/21: Dow Hits Record, Nasdaq Snaps Skid After Late Push
Stock Market Today

Stock Market Today 5/6/21: Dow Hits Record, Nasdaq Snaps Skid After Late Push

A sharp drop in unemployment claims had the Dow poised for another record, but an afternoon push got the Nasdaq into the black, too.
May 6, 2021