Thinking About Day Trading? Read This First

In the midst of the pandemic, you may have noticed a rather unusual trend: More and more people are jumping into the stock market.

Despite, or perhaps even because of, extreme volatility in the market and endless speculation about what could happen next — not just with the economy but in the wider world due to the seismic shifts we’re experiencing because of COVID-19 — there’s been a recent proliferation of day trading.

While the mediums might be new — Robinhood wasn’t around 20 or even 10 years ago — the sudden spike in the popularity of day trading isn’t. We saw a similar rush of interest during the dot-com bubble.

Subscribe to Kiplinger’s Personal Finance

Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Save up to 74%

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.

Sign up

That might point to one of the reasons for the recent interest in this extremely speculative (and therefore exceedingly risky) way of participating in financial markets: When times are bad and things get tough, people will look for seemingly new or easier ways to make ends meet.

Unfortunately, despite what you might hear from a co-worker, neighbor or friend, day trading is rarely a good solution for most folks. So, if you’ve been considering joining in on this currently popular trend, I’d urge you to reconsider before you put your hard-earned money at risk.

Day Trading Isn’t an Easy Way to Wealth

The Wall Street Journal recently wrote a piece on the flurry of activity on day trading platforms (opens in new tab). It’s an article that gives reason for concern on many levels.

For example, take Sharmila Viswasam, who shared some of her story with the WSJ for the article. She’s a 38-year-old real estate agent who couldn’t work due to the pandemic — and found that her unemployment checks weren’t enough to pay her bills. Her boss suggested she try day trading as a way to solve this problem and close the gap between her benefits and her expenses. Viswasam read Trading for Dummies and watched YouTube videos before she opened an ETrade account and tried her hand at day trading.

The problem here is that the very people who cannot afford to take the inherent risks associated with highly speculative investments are engaging in day trading in an attempt to hit it big.

But that’s just it: Day trading is hardly investing. It’s much more like gambling, and the odds of winning aren’t good. In fact, the same Wall Street Journal article noted that Barclays “examined trades by Robinhood customers between March and early June and concluded that the more they bought a specific stock, the worse that stock performed.”

Investing Works, But Day Trading Is More Like Gambling

To be clear, I do believe that investing in stocks and bonds is the best way to grow wealth. But you need to do so strategically, which means adjusting for risk, considering diversification, and allocating your portfolio in such a way that it is aligned with your goals and time horizon.

Day trading takes none of this into account, and again, is more akin to gambling than wise, strategic investing where you can reasonably expect to earn a moderate return over time. And in this gambling game, the odds are stacked against you.

Don’t just take my word for it, though. Day traders — and even average investors who are trying to DIY their own portfolio management along the way — fall short of a variety of benchmarks in various asset classes:

Why does this happen? Because as a day trader, you are attempting to outsmart giant financial markets with millions of participants — some of which are corporate entities that exist solely to attempt to gain an edge, advantage or piece of information before anyone else knows about it in order to make money in the market, and who have entire departments of experts dedicated to these tasks.

The odds that you, as an individual with no such powerful tools at your disposal, would outguess everyone else are, to put it mildly, rather slim. Think about playing a game of poker with you and four friends. You might have a good chance to win some money. But what if you sat down to the table with four of the best poker players in the world? How good are your chances now?

That’s what the scenario looks like for you against the rest of the traders of the world.

If You Must Speculate, Mitigate the Risks First

While I suggest that you use a diversified, low-cost portfolio of index funds and ETFs to invest and cultivate your money in the market over time, you may be dead-set on trying day trading for yourself. If so, then first, I recommend watching this video on penny stocks from the Motley Fool (opens in new tab). Then, try to stick to these rules whenever dipping your toe into more speculative investment waters:

• Only invest what you are prepared to lose. And by lose, I mean losing all of it. If you can’t handle the idea of losing 100% of what you put into a single stock position, then you should not be making that investment (or, more accurately, that bet). If you are buying individual names, you must be prepared — and actually able to afford — to lose your principal. Therefore, I recommend that you trade with less than 5% of your net worth to avoid racking up losses that you will struggle to recover from.
• Don’t buy on margin. Buying on margin means that you’re borrowing money to buy even more shares. It’s a bad idea for newer investors and can quickly amplify your losses.
• Avoid penny stocks. If that video wasn’t enough, let me reiterate it here: Companies are penny stocks for a reason. Stay away!

So, all this being said, I suppose it’s fair to ask … can’t you just get lucky? Isn’t it at least possible to strike it rich with something like day trading?

Sure. It is possible. But that doesn’t mean it’s likely, and in order to get lucky you might have to spend and lose a significant amount of money along the way (which clearly would have been better off in a more reliable investment vehicle, or even in cash!).

You can get lucky … but even slot machines pay out every once in awhile, and no one with any sense is claiming those are a great retirement plan.

And it isn’t spare change that most day traders are flinging into the market. It’s hard-earned dollars — dollars that could be working hard for you in turn if you only allocated them to a safer, more strategic, and more reliable way to grow wealth in the market instead.