Confused About the Fiduciary Rule?
Investor advocates are jubilant while many financial services professionals are apprehensive, as regulations designed to ensure investors have access to objective retirement savings advice, are implemented.


The financial services industry is in the middle of some regulatory tumult. With the much publicized and debated Fiduciary Standard implemented in the financial services industry on June 9, 2017, the name of the game for retirement planning has changed. But, even more than that, the new rule is reflective of an evolving industry, one that has gradually shifted focus from the brokerages and wire houses of yesteryear to the proliferation of registered investment advisers and even online wealth managers today. Overall emphasis has largely shifted from selling products (which are now seemingly limitless) to selling professional advisory services.
Many financial industry groups allied in a bid to either halt or at least delay the implementation of the Department of Labor’s (DOL) Fiduciary Rule – and, for a time, they got their wish. The rule’s initial April 10 compliance date was delayed until June 9. On the other hand, most investors are less apprehensive about the fiduciary rule. In fact, many welcome the higher standard for the professionals managing their money or proffering related advice.
There is some confusion among investors about what the rule means, and what the historical and legal context surrounding it reveal about the financial services industry. In this article (the first of two parts) I will lay out the main points in the debate. The second part will provide some historical context, and conclude with the most significant takeaways from this potentially consequential rule.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
On the surface, the consequences of adopting an industrywide fiduciary standard for retirement accounts would appear relatively benign for investors at best and inconvenient for financial providers at worst. As we delve deeper, though, it becomes apparent that there is far more at stake than the idiosyncratic regulations surrounding retirement accounts. Time will tell whether we have a reaffirmation of the status quo, or set the precedent for a wave of change in the relationships between financial firms and advisers.
Going Beyond What’s Merely ‘Suitable’
First of all, the DOL rule only affects retirement accounts, such as IRAs, 401(k)s and 403(b)s, pensions and employee stock ownership plans. Brokers, insurance agents and some financial advisers merely have been held to a “suitability standard” in the past. Essentially, financial advisers have adhered to a kind of scout’s honor system, where they simply had to ensure their advice or products being sold were suitable to the client and the client’s situation – they wouldn’t necessarily have to be the best, most cost-efficient options out there.
The new rule dictates that such salespeople act as more than just intermediaries, but rather, in the best interests of the client. Unfortunately, with transactional accounts and commission-based compensation structures, conflicts of interest abound in the old-fashioned brokerage and insurance business lines, where advisers are often incentivized to offer certain proprietary products, rather than the best investment option available, to the client.
The DOL rule, if rigidly interpreted, would hold firms and financial intermediaries accountable if they fail to act in the best interests of the client, pursuing the optimal investment decisions to meet those needs. The lone exception to this rule would be where a client or prospective customer specifically asks for a certain product or investment for their retirement account, even after being fully apprised of any related costs and fees.
In the past, regulation focused mostly on disclosure. Essentially, if conflicts of interest were sufficiently disclosed, then advisers could recommend products, as long they were within reason. The nature of commissions and sales charges, in fact, has long been based on a “reasonable standard.” Now, under the new fiduciary rule, regulating intent and simple disclosure would no longer be enough to satisfy a more rigorous standard of the advisory relationship.
Some Financial Firms’ Reactions to Proposal Were Revealing
Already, several large insurance firms have terminated their brokerage and annuity businesses in anticipation of such constraints. That simple fact, and the loud protests emanating from advocates and lobbyists of such interest groups, shows the underlying conflicts of interest in the old way of doing business. The proliferation of independent RIAs (registered investment advisers, who operate under the fiduciary standard) and fee-only advisory platforms in recent years, along with the increase in low-cost passive investment offerings, has further underlined the overall trend in the advisory sector away from product-oriented sales, in favor of a solutions-based approach requiring higher levels of expertise among financial advisers. Clearly, there is a fast-moving current, whether those tides of change are directed from above or generated from below (and it appears to be both).
It has become obvious, given the changes taking place at many firms across the industry, that consumers increasingly expect their financial advisers to follow the spirit of the rule even if the letter is less onerous and exacting. That is encouraging to see, and is indicative of the grass-roots support for the fiduciary movement.
In the second part of this two-part discussion, we’ll outline the regulatory trends and historical backdrop for the DOL rule, along with its ultimate significance and the effect on the nature of the advisory relationship.
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.

Marguerita M. Cheng is the Chief Executive Officer at Blue Ocean Global Wealth. She is a CFP® professional, a Chartered Retirement Planning Counselor℠ and a Retirement Income Certified Professional. She helps educate the public, policymakers and media about the benefits of competent, ethical financial planning.
-
Small Caps Hit First New High in 4 Years: Stock Market Today
The Dow Jones Industrial Average, S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite also notched fresh record highs Thursday.
-
Amex Platinum Just Got More Expensive: $895 Fee and $3,500 in Perks Explained
American Express raises the Platinum Card’s annual fee to $895 and expands its perks. We break down the changes so you don’t have to.
-
Wages Aren't Keeping Up With Inflation: A Financial Adviser's Tips to Bridge the Gap
While we can't control inflation, there are some simple things each of us can do to help keep our heads above water.
-
New Rules, New Opportunities for Student Loans: An Expert Guide to Preparing for What's Next
Major changes are coming to federal student loan rules, so it's a good time for borrowers to understand how these shifts will impact their financial planning.
-
Gray Divorce Can Throw Your Retirement a Curveball: What to Know
If you're entering retirement and going through a divorce at the same time, you've got some work to do to shore up your long-term financial security.
-
I'm a Real Estate Investing Expert: Optional 721 UPREIT DSTs Can Be the Best of Both Worlds
Before investing in any 721 UPREIT exchange, look for one that offers a straightforward, investor-friendly exit.
-
How an Expired Passport Thwarted Blackmail (and What Other Important Documents You Should Keep)
An optometrist produced his expired passport to foil a blackmail attempt by the daughter of a former employee. After proving he was out of the country on the date of a forged diary entry, he took it a step further.
-
Optimize, Grow, Retain: The Power of Annual Client Reviews
Financial advisers can use annual reviews to help enhance client outcomes, strengthen relationships and build their practice.
-
I'm a Real Estate Investing Pro: This Is What Investors Should Know About Truck Stop Investments
Truck stops might seem like good investments, but they can actually be a risky gamble due to unstable fuel prices, unreliable operators and coming changes in transportation. Instead, consider safer options like industrial or residential properties.
-
Don't Disinherit Your Grandchildren: The Hidden Risks of Retirement Account Beneficiary Forms
Standard retirement account beneficiary forms may not be flexible enough to ensure your money passes to family members according to your wishes. Naming a trust as the contingent beneficiary can help avoid these issues. Here's how.