It may not be obvious why you should put stock, so to speak, in consistency. After all, you'll double your money in five years whether a fund returns 14.9% each year or whether it earns 100% in the first year, loses 50% the next, makes another 100%, loses 50% and then climbs 100% again.
But we think consistency matters for two reasons. First, the more often managers beat their peers and their benchmarks, the greater the likelihood that skill, rather than luck, is driving their performance. If a superior long-term record is the product of one or two fabulous years, be wary.
But consistency also counts when it comes to your behavior. As Morningstar data on what investors actually earn (as opposed to fund-reported returns) have shown, people often pile into funds after they've sizzled and bail out of them after they've fizzled (see Your Real Total Return, Jan. 2007). So, you're less likely to buy high and sell low if you invest in steady Eddies rather than wacky Willies.
We don't mean to suggest that consistency is all that matters when selecting a fund. Morningstar analyst Paul Herbert suggests that investors should "combine consistency with other factors, such as low expenses, experienced management and a reasonable strategy." But funds that deliver consistently good results deserve a bit of extra consideration.
You can measure consistency in a variety of ways. We asked Morningstar to help us identify consistent performers from four different perspectives. Funds that appear in more than one of our groupings are marked with an asterisk.
These selected funds have beaten their benchmarks in at least 85% of calendar years since 1990.
Index Beaters 2
These selected funds are at least five years old and have outpaced their benchmarks in at least 85% of rolling 12-month periods.
In the Black
These selected funds have delivered positive total returns in at least 90% of calendar years, including the first half of 2007.
10% or Bust
These selected funds have delivered double-digit returns in at least 80% of calendar years and at least 5% in the first half of 2007.
The Complete List (opens in new tab)
See all the funds that meet our four criteria.
Stock Market Today (09/27/22): Relief Rally Fizzles for Dow, S&P 500
A pair of "good news is bad news" economic reports had the stock market turning lower in afternoon trading on Tuesday.
By Karee Venema • Published
The Divorce Gap: Unique Retirement Issues for Women Over 50
The shocking loss of income and retirement savings that disproportionately affect divorced women is a big challenge – especially for those over 50.
By Stacy Francis, CFP®, CDFA®, CES™ • Published
This New Sustainable ETF’s Pitch? Give Back Profits.
investing Newday’s ETF partners with UNICEF and other groups.
By Ellen Kennedy • Published
As the Market Falls, New Retirees Need a Plan
retirement If you’re in the early stages of your retirement, you’re likely in a rough spot watching your portfolio shrink. We have some strategies to make the best of things.
By David Rodeck • Published
Where the Midterm Election Races Stand Today
Economic Forecasts In a tight race, these state elections may make the difference when midterm results are announced in November.
By Sean Lengell • Published
FedEx (FDX) Earnings Warning: Recession Harbinger or Single-Stock Hiccup?
Markets When a firm as big and broad-reaching as FedEx forecasts a sharp earnings drop, the market’s going to react. What’s this say for upcoming earnings?
By Anne Kates Smith • Published
The White House Touts A Digital Dollar: What Does That Mean?
cryptocurrency A CBDC, or Central Bank Digital Currency, is a step closer in the U.S., but going digital will take years.
By Ellen Kennedy • Published
What Ethereum's 'Merge' Means for You, the Market, and the Climate
cryptocurrency The "Merge" seems to have worked. What you need to know about crypto's biggest story of 2022.
By Rodrigo Sermeño • Published
Why a Target-Date Fund Works for Me
investing Target-date funds are attractive for their simplicity. And while I've invested in one in the past, that doesn't mean it's the right choice for you.
By Lisa Gerstner • Published
How to Spend $1,000: Find Cheap (or Free) Online Courses to Build Career Skills
Smart Buying There's a huge array of skill-building online courses that can level up your career for under $1,000.
By Kim Clark • Published