Why You Need TIPS

Worried about inflation? You should be. True, the recession and the listless economic recovery have kept a lid on prices for the past couple of years. But Uncle Sam's profligate deficits and easy-money policy will likely stoke higher prices down the road.

When inflation starts to bubble up, Treasury inflation-protected securities can turn down the heat on your portfolio. Issued with the full faith and credit of the U.S. government, TIPS are one of the few investments guaranteed to earn, under normal circumstances, a "real," or after-inflation, return. Their principal value adjusts in sync with the consumer price index and, because the coupon payments on TIPS cue off this adjusted principal figure, the bonds pay an inflation-indexed income, too.

It's a straightforward promise, but to make the most of it you have to understand what drives TIPS prices. The so-called break-even rate, which you find by subtracting the yield of a TIPS issue from the yield of a regular Treasury bond of similar maturity, refers to the hypothetical future inflation rate that would cause TIPS and Treasury notes to break even with one another. When the break-even rate seems unrealistically low, TIPS are cheap relative to Treasuries, and vice versa. As of February 15, for example, TIPS maturing in five years yielded 0.56%, and Treasury notes due in five years yielded 2.33%. This implies that if inflation averages 1.77% annually over the next five years, your return from holding the five-year TIPS and the five-year Treasury note until maturity will be the same. If inflation turns out to be higher than 1.77%, TIPS will beat the Treasury note, and the reverse will be true if inflation is lower.

Subscribe to Kiplinger’s Personal Finance

Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Save up to 74%

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.

Sign up

If consumer prices rise at their long-term historical rate of 3.23% over the next five years, then TIPS are a screaming buy. But many investors think various economic forces, such as the 9.7% jobless rate and the slack pace of lending, will keep prices in check. "We think inflation will be more like 1% over the next three to five years," says Kenneth Volpert, co-manager of Vanguard Inflation-Protected Securities (symbol VIPSX), a member of the Kiplinger 25. Lately, he and co-manager John Hollyer have been favoring Treasury notes over TIPS, but TIPS still account for more than 80% of their fund's $28 billion in assets.

You don't need a crystal ball to make a case for buying TIPS. After all, TIPS holders won't lose any money if inflation turns out to be lower than expected. But if inflation ends up being much higher than expected, holders of ordinary Treasury notes will lose money in real terms.

How to buy them. You can buy newly issued five-, ten- and 30-year bonds at auction through the U.S. Treasury, at Treasurydirect.gov, free of charge. TIPS auctions for 2010 are tentatively set for April, July, August and October. You can also buy new TIPS or previously issued ones in the secondary market through your broker. Charles Schwab and Fidelity charge no fee for new issues purchased online, but all brokers fold a commission into the price you pay for bonds in the open market.

If you're considering TIPS for a taxable account, holding individual TIPS may not be your best option. Interest income and any inflation-driven growth in principal from TIPS are exempt from state and local taxes but are subject to federal taxes. Trouble is, you'll owe taxes on any inflation adjustments to a bond's principal value for the tax year in which the adjustment occurs, even if you don't sell the bond. "If you own a single TIPS security, that may not be such a big deal," says Jeff Layman, of BKD Wealth Advisors, a Springfield, Mo., money-management firm. "But if you own several different maturities, it can become a bigger headache than it's worth."

Mutual funds simplify the tax treatment. "With a fund, everything rolls into your income distribution," Layman says. The Vanguard fund also gives you diversification across maturities, plus access to the expertise of Volpert and Hollyer, who can boost returns by exploiting inefficiencies in the TIPS market. The fund returned 7.1% annualized from its inception on June 29, 2000, through February 15, 2010. Its annual expense ratio is a low 0.25%.

The downside of investing through a fund is that you're exposed to the price fluctuations of TIPS. As with any investment, TIPS prices are driven by supply and demand and are strongly influenced by investors' expectations for inflation and interest rates. In 2008, for example, the CPI gained 0.1%, but an index of TIPS lost 2.4%. Last year, the CPI gained 2.7%, while the TIPS index gained 11.4%. If you held individual bonds through that period and didn't sell, you were unaffected by the volatility. But if you invested in a TIPS fund, you watched the value of your shares jerk around.

A TIPS fund that keeps maturities short will give you a smoother ride. Historically, TIPS maturing in one to five years have been almost half as volatile as the broader TIPS market, which includes bonds maturing in more than 20 years. The performance of short-dated TIPS has also tracked inflation more closely than the TIPS market as a whole.

ETF entry. Only a single exchange-traded fund specializes in short-term TIPS. Pimco 1-5 Year U.S. TIPS Index (STPZ) tracks the Bank of America Merrill Lynch 1-5 Year U.S. Inflation-Linked Treasury index. This ETF, which charges 0.20% for expenses, is less than a year old, but the index it follows has gained 5.8% annualized since it was created in early 2002.

Prices on all TIPS should hold up well if interest rates rise in response to inflation -- in such a situation you would see the break-even rate between TIPS and Treasuries widen. But if real rates were to rise -- which could happen if, for instance, nominal interest rates jumped but inflation held steady -- TIPS would suffer along with other bonds.

You might wonder, and rightly so, why you should invest in short-term TIPS when many are yielding less than nothing. TIPS maturing in two years recently traded to yield Ð0.49% (remember that TIPS yields are always quoted in real terms; it's highly likely that inflation will be strong enough that investors buying into a negative real TIPS yield will at least come out even in nominal terms). That compares with the two-year Treasury note's yield of 0.81% and implies that inflation would need to average 1.30% over the next two years for TIPS investors to break even with Treasury-note investors.

Blame policymakers for those low yields. Short-term interest rates "are like a coiled spring that the Federal Reserve is holding down," says Volpert. He thinks that the thin supply of new issues in the TIPS market, relative to Treasury notes, has also contributed to the wide yield gap in short-term maturities.

Chances are good that short-term yields will rise over the course of the next year. "The further we get into 2010, the more likely it is that short rates will bounce up," Volpert says. In addition, Pimco, which has a close relationship with policymakers, says it expects the Treasury to increase the portion of its debt issued in TIPS. That should be a boon for TIPS yields. "There are many investors who require inflation protection, and the Treasury wants to issue where there's demand," says John Cavalieri, the product manager for Pimco's inflation-targeting funds. Investors should consider waiting until short-term TIPS yields turn positive before beginning to build a position in the Pimco fund.

The I-bond alternative. Finally, if you desire inflation protection but would prefer to avoid price movements and tax headaches, consider series I U.S. savings bonds. Interest on the bonds accrues according to a fixed-rate component (until May 1, when a new rate will be set, the fixed rate on new bonds is 0.30%), plus an inflation-indexed rate, and you can defer all taxes until redemption. You have to hold the bonds for at least five years to avoid a penalty, but as long as you hold for at least one year, you can redeem them with the Treasury. You can invest a maximum of $5,000 in the paper bonds and $5,000 in the bonds electronically each year, for a total of $10,000 per calendar year.

TIPS or series I bonds should be a core part of your investments -- consider keeping 10% of your fixed-income holdings stashed in inflation-hedged bonds and increasing that figure if inflation ignites. But, particularly in light of the low yields on TIPS, they should be just one component of your portfolio's inflation defenses, which could also include commodities and real estate.