After months of sluggish activity, the market recently turned the tide. Whether the market is up or down, it’s always a good time to keep your taxes in mind and, more specifically, how you can put yourself in an advantageous position by keeping more of your own money in your pockets.
When it comes to tax optimization, there are two common strategies: Roth conversions and tax-loss harvesting. But, as is always the case in financial planning, there are no be-all, end-all strategies.
Indeed, there are several things to consider when utilizing both of these options.
Taxes are extremely important and can have a huge impact on your retirement income. One strategy that can help lessen your tax burden later in life is converting your accounts to Roth IRAs.
The idea behind Roth conversions is to take money from a tax-deferred IRA, pay taxes on that amount at your ordinary income rate and convert that money into a Roth IRA. By doing this, you’ll be clear of future taxes on the amount you converted, and the money you put in grows tax-free for your lifetime!
At the end of 2025, our current income tax brackets will likely revert to their pre-2018 rates. When we look at the national debt and potential changes coming to Social Security, it's likely that taxes will increase in the future.
Even if you stay in the same tax bracket for years to come, the rate that applies to that bracket will likely increase down the road. If you have a tax-deferred IRA, you will pay more in taxes when you withdraw from the account in retirement than you would if you converted now.
You don’t have control over the tax rate changes the IRS will make in the future — there are no certainties when it comes to tax policy. But by utilizing Roth conversions now, you are guaranteed tax-free withdrawals throughout your retirement years.
What are the main benefits of a Roth?
To understand the tax advantages that come with Roth IRAs, think of an oak tree.
Let’s say you own shares with a market value of $300. Those shares are like a small acorn. If you convert those shares to a Roth while they are at a lower value, you’ll likely pay less in taxes. As those shares start to increase in value over time, you suddenly have a full-grown oak tree! Let’s say those shares are now worth $3,000, and all of that growth is tax-free. By the same token, you can also consider converting shares that have recently depreciated in value and get more bang for your buck!
Another benefit of Roth IRAs is that they are exempt from required minimum distributions (RMDs) because the IRS has already received its share of taxes from the conversions you’ve made. Therefore, you’re able to leave as much money as you’d like in your account without being forced to take distributions.
Those with lots of assets in 401(k)s and traditional IRAs will be required to take out huge RMDs, which will increase their overall income even if they don’t need the cash when the RMD is due.
What to consider before converting to a Roth
If you’re debating whether you should convert to a Roth, take inventory of where you’re at with taxes now. Ask yourself, “What tax bracket will I be in 20 to 30 years from now?” In the past, people believed it was best to pump all your contributions into a traditional IRA because you’d likely be in a lower tax bracket in retirement. However, even if you’re in a lower bracket, the tax rate might still be higher. The tax rate is what matters more.
Do keep in mind that for each conversion, you must wait five years before you access the converted funds in order to keep their tax-free status.
Additionally, if you’re considering leaving your IRA to any beneficiaries, keep in mind that the SECURE Act of 2019 changed how inherited IRAs work. Most non-spousal beneficiaries now have to deplete those inherited funds within 10 years. If you plan on leaving a traditional IRA to your kids, friends or non-immediate family, it will be fully taxable at the beneficiary’s ordinary income tax rate.
Lastly, if you don’t have individual beneficiaries, converting to a Roth account might not be the best fit for your situation. Assuming you plan to leave that money to a charity or organization, those donations are tax-free anyway, so it is not a good use of your money to pay taxes to convert.
When you sell securities within a non-qualified account, you typically either have a gain or a loss. Tax-loss harvesting is a strategy used when you sell a security at a loss to offset the capital gains taxes that you owe on a different, more profitable investment.
For example, if you buy a share of a particular stock for $5,000 and sell it when its value reaches $15,000, that is a $10,000 gain on your investment. Since you have gains, you have to pay the capital gains rate, which is typically 15%. However, if you instead had a loss, you can use that for tax planning purposes to offset your gains on another investment, with the net result being less capital gains taxes to pay. For this to work, you must liquidate the losing investment before you can offset any gains on the winning one.
What to consider before harvesting your losses
Before you consider harvesting your losses, you want to make sure that you are comfortable incurring the loss. Don’t be willy-nilly and sell a security when the market is down just to harvest a loss. If this is a long-term investment you have faith in, you probably shouldn’t sell it. If you think it’s going to appreciate in value again, you don’t want to be hasty in selling that investment for the sole purpose of harvesting the loss.
Who does (or doesn’t) benefit from tax-loss harvesting?
If you’re in a higher tax bracket, you have to pay capital gains taxes on your investments, and tax-loss harvesting can afford you huge savings on that tax.
However, in order for tax-loss harvesting to work, you have to have a non-qualifying account — that is, an investment vehicle that can never be subject to tax benefits. Capital gains do not apply to accounts that aren’t in this group, so you can’t harvest your losses with a 401(k), 403(b) or IRA, for example.
Tax-loss harvesting also doesn’t work for someone to whom capital gains taxes do not apply. If you’re in an ordinary income tax bracket of 12% or below, you have no capital gains tax to pay, so there is no need to “harvest” losses.
Regardless of market conditions or what stage of life you may find yourself in, there are always strategies to help optimize your taxes. With tax-loss harvesting, you can sell low-performing securities and use that liquidation to offset any capital gains taxes, and by converting to Roth accounts, you spare yourself future tax liabilities that may come from any growth in value your securities may accrue.
Given the layers of nuance that come with each, it’s best to consult your financial adviser and tax adviser before employing either of these strategies.
After 12 years of working as a successful commercial litigation attorney, Laura Schultz made the transition to being a wealth adviser to connect with clients and change their lives for the better by preparing them for retirement success. Now the co-owner of Preservation Retirement Services with her husband, Tim, she is a Series 65 securities-licensed and insurance-licensed financial professional and holds a Series 65 license and is an Investment Adviser Representative of Creative One Wealth, LLC. When she’s not helping clients understand and simplify their investment options, she loves cheering on the University of Iowa and spending time with her family.
Starbucks Is Making Its Stores More Accessible. Here's How.
The coffee chain's move comes at a time when the number of older adults with disabilities is expected to rise.
By Jamie Feldman Published
Amazon to Replace Walgreens in the Dow: Why This Matters
Amazon joins the elite club of Dow Jones stocks, while troubled Walgreens gets the boot.
By Dan Burrows Published
To Make the Case for Equities in the Long Term, Look to the Past
While cash yields are attractive now, if we look at the performance of equities in the past, we can expect that, going forward, they could be a better bet.
By David Blanchett, PhD, CFA, CFP® Published
Workplace Financial Coaching Has Become Ever More Important
Employees face growing challenges to their financial wellness today, so it’s more critical than ever that employers provide the help they need to navigate them.
By Greg Ward, CFP® Published
Six Reasons to Use a Real Estate Agent When You Sell
So many financial factors depend on the outcome when you downsize for retirement that enlisting a professional can be well worth the price.
By Evan T. Beach, CFP®, AWMA® Published
Looking into Leasing Solar Panels? Think Twice
Leasing solar panels hasn’t turned into the great deal that many expected as solar companies go out of business and tax breaks and incentives get slashed.
By H. Dennis Beaver, Esq. Published
Three Reasons Not to Use a Real Estate Agent When You Sell
While this financial adviser doesn’t recommend taking that route, he does see scenarios where it could make sense for you.
By Evan T. Beach, CFP®, AWMA® Published
Soon-to-Be Retirees, Beware: Small-Caps Are Cheap for a Reason
Higher interest rates make debt more expensive for smaller companies, and that could become challenging for them if we head into slower economic times.
By Michael Joseph, CFA Published
The Five Stages of Retirement (and How to Skip Three of Them)
Getting the first step wrong inevitably means you’ll go through stages three through five. Get step one right, and it’s a two-step process.
By Richard P. Himmer, PhD Published
Six Financial Actions to Take the Year Before Retirement
Having your income, health care and tax plans in place before you exit the day job can make it more likely that you'll have a happy retirement.
By Evan T. Beach, CFP®, AWMA® Published