10 Best Values in Liberal Arts Colleges 2012-13

10. Haverford College

Location: Haverford, Pa.

Undergraduate enrollment: 1,198

Total cost: $58,186

Average need-based aid: $37,515

Average net cost: $20,671

This small Quaker school, on a tranquil campus that includes an arboretum and a 3.5-acre duck pond, is one of three schools on our liberal arts list with a 91% four-year graduation rate. Haverford encourages the Quaker traditions of consensus -- a decision-making process that emphasizes inclusiveness -- and integrity. The student-run honor code allows students to take unsupervised exams and to live in dorms without resident advisors.

9. Vassar College

Location: Poughkeepsie, N.Y.

Undergraduate enrollment: 2,386

Total cost: $57,910

Average need-based aid: $38,285

Average net cost: $19,625

Vassar\'s high test scores (57% of incoming freshmen score over 700 on the verbal SAT, and 44% score over 700 on the math version), 98% freshman retention rate and strong four-year graduation rate (88%) make it a reliable member of our top ten, where it has appeared four times in the past five years. Two-thirds of students are awarded need-based financial aid. Students who borrow graduate with just over $18,000 in average debt, one-third less than the national average.

8. Davidson College

Location: Davidson, N.C.

Undergraduate enrollment: 1,756

Total cost: $53,155

Average need-based aid: $27,829

Average net cost: $25,326

Unlike most other top-ranked schools, Davidson awards non-need based aid, with an average award of nearly $20,000. The school\'s policy of replacing loans with grants to help reduce student debt means that only 22% of students, the lowest percentage on our list, borrow to finance their education. In addition to academics, the school focuses on leadership and community service. Its honor code gives students the freedom to schedule their own exams and take tests unsupervised.

7. Bowdoin College

Location: Brunswick, Maine

Undergraduate enrollment: 1,778

Total cost: $56,950

Average need-based aid: $35,975

Average net cost: $20,975

One of the country\'s oldest liberal arts colleges, Bowdoin boasts an impressive collection of alumni, including U.S. President Franklin Pierce, Henry Wadsworth Longfellow and five members of Barack Obama\'s administration, including Christopher Hill, U.S. ambassador to Iraq. The school\'s 16% admission rate and high yield (nearly half of admitted students enroll) attest to the school\'s competitive strength.

6. Williams College

Location: Williamstown, Mass.

Undergraduate enrollment: 2,053

Total cost: $57,570

Average need-based aid: $37,836

Average net cost: $19,734

This New England college routinely ranks near the top of our liberal arts list for its stellar academics, including a freshman retention rate of 97%, a four-year graduation rate of 89%, and a seven-to-one student-faculty ratio -- the lowest on our liberal arts list. Fewer than half of students at Williams borrow, and those who do take out loans graduate with an average debt of $8,801, the second-lowest among our top 100 liberal arts schools.

5. Colgate University

Location: Hamilton, N.Y.

Undergraduate enrollment: 2,947

Total cost: $56,755

Average need-based aid: $36,192

Average net cost: $20,563

Colgate jumped to our top ten this year from number 22 last year, thanks mostly to an increasingly competitive admission rate (29%, compared with 33% last year) and an improved four-year graduation rate (88%, up from 84%). A recent capital campaign raised $142 million for financial aid. Just over one-fourth of Colgate students borrow money to finance their education, compared with about two-thirds nationally. Average debt at graduation is $19,721, lower than the national average by almost one-third.

4. Amherst College

Location: Amherst, Mass.

Undergraduate enrollment: 1,791

Total cost: $55,098

Average need-based aid: $41,991

Average net cost: $13,107

Founded by Noah Webster and Samuel Fowler Dickinson (Emily Dickinson\'s grandfather), Amherst College has the second-most competitive admission rate on our list: Only 13% of applicants are accepted at this elite school. Amherst also digs deep to make its education affordable. More than 60% of students receive need-based aid, and the average undergraduate debt ($12,713) is less than half the national average. Through Amherst\'s Five Colleges\' association, students can take classes at Smith, Mount Holyoke, Hampshire College and the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, as well as at Amherst College.

3. Washington and Lee University

Location: Lexington, Va.

Undergraduate enrollment: 1,790

Total cost: $54,612

Average need-based aid: $35,834

Average net cost: $18,778

With high test scores among incoming freshmen (38% score above 700 on the verbal SAT, and 37% score above 700 on the math ), a nine-to-one student-faculty ratio, and an average class size of 16, plus a financial aid package that brings the average net cost below $20,000, Washington and Lee University has maintained its position on our top-ten list each year since 2007. The school has undergone several name changes since its 1749 founding; the current name pays homage to George Washington, who gave the school its first major endowment, and General Robert E. Lee, who served as president from 1865 until his death in 1870.

2. Pomona College

Location: Claremont, Cal.

Undergraduate enrollment: 1,586

Total cost: $55,864

Average need-based aid: $35,883

Average net cost: $19,981

This West Coast school is located within an hour of Los Angeles, the Pacific Ocean, the San Gabriel Mountains and the Mojave Desert. Its top academics include an impressive eight-to-one student-faculty ratio, a 14% admission rate and high test scores among incoming freshmen (69% score above 700 on the verbal SAT, and 70% score above 700 on the math). Pomona also boasts the highest freshman retention rate on our liberal arts list -- all but 1% of first-year students return for their sophomore year -- and it ties with Swarthmore and Haverford for the highest four-year grad rate (91%).

1. Swarthmore College

Location: Swarthmore, Pa.

Undergraduate enrollment: 1,545

Total cost: $56,930

Average need-based aid: $36,385

Average net cost: $20,545

At the top of our liberal arts list for the fourth time since 2007, this small school, founded by Quakers, emphasizes creativity and critical thinking skills. Swarthmore admits only 15% of applicants; 71% of incoming freshmen score 700 or more on their verbal SAT, and 62% score 700 or more on the math. Swarthmore is one of only three schools on our liberal arts list with a four-year graduation rate of 91%. It offers an eight-to-one student-faculty ratio.

More From Kiplinger

SLIDE SHOW: 10 Best Values in Private Universities

SLIDE SHOW: 10 Best Values in Private Colleges Under $20K

Best Values in Private Colleges 2012-13

SPECIAL REPORT: Best College Values