2011 Best New Car Values: New Models

published 12 January 2011

New designs and redesigns bring a breath of fresh air with each new year. Usually you pay a premium for these newly minted models. Not this year, however.

When we asked CarBargains, the buying service of the nonprofit Consumers' Checkbook organization, to help us shop for our Best New picks, they found that two-thirds were selling below invoice price. Winners are chosen based on performance, value and safety, plus our own driving impressions. The slide show begins to your right.

Data comes from Kelley Blue Book's kbb.com (new vehicle data from 12/28/10, resale values from January/February 2011 Kelley Blue Book® Residual Value Guide); Vincentric (service and insurance costs); and Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (Top Safety Picks). Fair Purchase Price, also supplied by Kelley Blue book, is based on actual new vehicle transactions across the country.

Best New Model: Cars Under $20,000

Hyundai Elantra

Sticker price: $15,550 (GLS, manual)

Invoice price: $15,146

Fair Purchase Price: $15,550

Five-year service cost: $3,907

One-year insurance cost: $1,153

Resale value after 3 years: NA -- 5 years: NA

City: 29 mpg -- Highway: 40 mpg

Compact no longer equals econobox. Elantra is built with midsize interior space, heated mirrors, and available Bluetooth, rearview camera and heated seats–in both rows. It boasts more power and better fuel efficiency (40 mpg on the

highway) than Honda Civic and Toyota Corolla.

Sponsored Content

Best New Model: Cars $20,000 - $25,000

Hyundai Sonata

Sticker price: $24,865 (SE 2.0T)

Invoice price: $23,545

Fair Purchase Price: NA

Five-year service cost: $4,605

One-year insurance cost: $1,297

Resale value after 3 years: 49% -- 5 years: 32%

City: 22 mpg -- Highway: 33 mpg

No longer content to be a faceless member of the midsize class, the new Sonata dons sculpted lines and an aggressive stance more apropos of luxury models. Nixing a six-cylinder engine from the lineup, Hyundai added a speedy turbocharged four cylinder and a hybrid for 2011.

Sponsored Content

Best New Model: Cars $25,000 - $30,000

Kia Optima

Sticker price: $25,190 (EX 2.0T)

Invoice price: $23,585

Fair Purchase Price: NA

Five-year service cost: NA

One-year insurance cost: NA

Resale value after 3 years: NA -- 5 years: NA

City: 22 mpg -- Highway: 33 mpg

Optima asserts itself as a high content, high-value player. A Top Safety Pick, it features sporty design, a comfy, classy interior and plenty of upscale amenities. You can opt for either a hybrid or one of two direct-injection four-cylinder models.

Sponsored Content

Best New Model: Cars $30,000 - $45,000

Lincoln MKZ Hybrid

Sticker price: $35,180

Invoice price: $32,472

Fair Purchase Price: $34,476

Five-year service cost: $3,249

One-year insurance cost: $1,408

Resale value after 3 years: 45% -- 5 years: 27%

City: 41 mpg -- Highway: 36 mpg

In a bold move, Lincoln gave the hybrid variant of the MKZ the same price tag as the gasoline-engine model, sidestepping the average hybrid price premium of $5,000. With 41 mpg in the city and 36 on the highway, it takes the

cake for near-luxury fuel efficiency, too.

Sponsored Content

Best New Model: Cars $45,000 and Over

Infiniti M

Sticker price: $58,775 (M56)

Invoice price: $53433

Fair Purchase Price: $55,836

Five-year service cost: $4,094

One-year insurance cost: $2,152

Resale value after 3 years: 51% -- 5 years: 31%

City: 16 mpg -- Highway: 25 mpg

Bells and whistles are a given at this price point, but the M wows with high resale value, low insurance and service costs, and reasonable miles per gallon for such serious power (420 horses on the M56). Optional blind-spot

intervention will steer you back into your lane should another car be in your way.

Sponsored Content

Best New Model: Sports Cars

Ford Mustang

Sticker price: $30,495 (GT coupe, manual)

Invoice price: $28,235

Fair Purchase Price: $30,495

Five-year service cost: $3,831

One-year insurance cost: $1,397

Resale value after 3 years: 56% -- 5 years: 39%

City: 17 mpg -- Highway: 26 mpg

The classic pony car nails value almost as well as it nails your back to the seat with a new 412-horsepower engine. High resale value, low service and insurance costs (for a sports car) and decent fuel economy—26 mpg on the highway—meet a modest price.

Sponsored Content

Best New Model: Small Crossovers

Kia Sportage

Sticker price: $20,990 (LX)

Invoice price: $20,305

Fair Purchase Price: $20,465

Five-year service cost: $4,117

One-year insurance cost: $1,021

Resale value after 3 years: NA -- 5 years: NA

City: 22 mpg -- Highway: 31 mpg

The second-generation Sportage is wrapped in sporty new sheet metal and gets a boost in cargo room as well as a more powerful engine. But it delivers better fuel efficiency, at 31 miles per gallon on the highway. Plus, you still get a five-year

warranty and the full line of safety equipment.

Sponsored Content

Best New Model: Midsize and Large Crossovers

Ford Explorer

Sticker price: $30,995 (V6 AWD)

Invoice price: $29,375

Fair Purchase Price: NA

Five-year service cost: $3,922

One-year insurance cost: $1,022

Resale value after 3 years: 54% -- 5 years: 34%

City: 17 mpg -- Highway: 23 mpg

America’s favorite SUV is reborn in a crossover body for 2011. The V6-powered version gets 20% better fuel economy and starts at $1,100 less than the outgoing model; an optional four-cylinder EcoBoost engine improves mileage by 30%. It earns a Top Safety Pick, too.

Sponsored Content

Best New Model: Truck-based SUVs

Infiniti QX56

Sticker price: $58,800

Invoice price: NA

Fair Purchase Price: $58,568

Five-year service cost: $4,905

One-year insurance cost: $1,337

Resale value after 3 years: NA -- 5 years: NA

City: 14 mpg -- Highway: 20 mpg

All-new all over, the second-gen QX56 raises the bar for full-size luxury SUVs. Slightly bigger this year, it delivers more horsepower (400), more towing power (up to 8,500 pounds) and better fuel economy (20 mpg on the highway).

Check out the chrome accents inside and out.

Sponsored Content

Best New Model: Minivans

Honda Odyssey

Sticker price: $28,580 (LX)

Invoice price: $25,976

Fair Purchase Price: $28,580

Five-year service cost: $3,995

One-year insurance cost: $960

Resale value after 3 years: 54% -- 5 years: 34%

City: 18 mpg -- Highway: 27 mpg

Odyssey ditches the Mom mobile image and adds edge for 2011. The perennial Kiplinger’s favorite returns to Best in Class status and sweeps awards in its category, winning Best New Minivan, Best Resale and Most Fuel-Efficient. Better driving dynamics and interior design are icing on the cake.

Sponsored Content

Best New Model: Wagons

Acura TSX

Sticker price: $31,280

Invoice price: $29,872

Fair Purchase Price: NA

Five-year service cost: NA

One-year insurance cost: NA

Resale value after 3 years: NA -- 5 years: NA

City: 20 mpg -- Highway: 30 mpg

Acura’s luxury sport compact goes wagon for 2011, and it’s not just another grocery-getter. With 32 cubic feet of storage space behind the second row, TSX will take you and your stuff where you need to go in style. The peppy 201-horsepower four-cylinder engine gets a respectable 30 mpg on the highway.