7 Assets to Leave Out of Your Roth IRA, From a Financial Planner
Instead of treating your Roth IRA as "the best account" for everything, consider keeping these seven categories of assets in accounts that offer better tax benefits or flexibility.
A Roth IRA is a powerful account:
- Qualified withdrawals can be tax-free
- There are no required minimum distributions (RMDs) during the owner's lifetime
- The account can be a flexible part of retirement and legacy planning
That power can create a common mistake. People treat the Roth as a "best account," then put everything into it.
In reality, Roth space is limited. A better approach is to think in terms of asset location, which is placing different investments in the account types in which they are most efficient.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
This is not an all-or-nothing list. These are categories often better outside a Roth IRA, depending on your household's goals, tax picture and time horizon.
1. Municipal bonds
Municipal bonds are generally designed to deliver tax-advantaged interest in a taxable account. Putting them in a Roth often adds little benefit, since the interest was already structured to be tax efficient.
In many cases, using Roth space for an asset that's already tax-advantaged creates an opportunity cost. Roth dollars are scarce, so they're often reserved for assets in which tax-free growth has the biggest impact over time.
2. Highly speculative individual positions
If a concentrated, high-risk position goes to zero inside a Roth, the loss is not just the dollars; you also lose the limited Roth contribution "space" that created the tax-free compounding opportunity in the first place.
For those who want a small speculative sleeve, many investors prefer keeping it in taxable accounts where losses may be used for tax purposes.
A related issue is behavioral. Speculative positions tend to invite frequent monitoring and reactive decisions. That pattern can be especially harmful in a Roth, where the long-term benefit is compounded growth.
3. Assets you may need before age 59½
Roth contributions can be withdrawn without tax or penalty, but the rules around early withdrawals of earnings can be complex and restrictive.
If the goal is flexibility for a goal that might happen before retirement age, a taxable account can be a better fit for at least part of that money.
In practical terms, this category includes down-payment funds, a potential business investment or any goal with an uncertain timeline.
The goal is not to avoid the Roth entirely. The goal is to avoid putting "short-horizon money" into a structure designed for long-horizon compounding.
4. Investments that are likely to generate meaningful losses
Tax-loss harvesting works only in taxable accounts. Losses inside retirement accounts generally don't provide the same tax benefit.
If you're intentionally holding a higher-volatility strategy in which losses are a real possibility, you may want that position in an account in which losses can potentially be used.
This is most relevant when the risk is not incidental. If the strategy assumes meaningful drawdowns or uses a concentrated approach, it may be worth asking whether the Roth is the right home.
5. Appreciated assets you plan to donate
Donating appreciated securities from a taxable account is often a highly tax-efficient way to give. The core benefit is avoiding capital gains taxes on the appreciation.
Since Roth assets are already in a tax-advantaged wrapper, they generally do not create the same giving advantage.
If charitable giving is part of the plan, it can be helpful to intentionally "build" future donation positions in taxable accounts, rather than accidentally giving from whatever happens to be easiest to sell.
6. Highly tax-efficient index funds and ETFs
Many broad index funds and ETFs are already designed to be tax-efficient, which is part of what makes them strong candidates for taxable accounts.
If you're deciding where to place assets, Roth space is often best reserved for holdings in which tax-free growth provides a larger advantage.
This point is often misunderstood. It doesn't mean index funds are "bad" in a Roth. It means index funds usually don't need a Roth to be efficient. That distinction matters when contribution limits force tradeoffs.
7. Illiquid or complex alternative investments
Some alternative investments can involve high fees, valuation complexity and liquidity constraints. They can also introduce rules risk if held improperly in a retirement account.
Even when the potential upside is attractive, the operational risk and the lack of flexibility may make these a better fit outside a Roth for many households.
This category can also create planning headaches later. If an investment can't be easily valued or liquidated, it can complicate rebalancing decisions and future distribution planning.
The bottom line
A Roth IRA is valuable precisely because it's scarce. The goal is not to avoid any asset category completely.
The goal is to place each asset where it is most tax-efficient and most practical, while keeping the overall portfolio diversified and aligned with the household's plan.
Related Content
- Here's Why You Shouldn't Put All Your Money Into Roth IRAs
- Should You Jump on the Roth Conversion Bandwagon?
- This Layered Approach for Your Retirement Money Can Help Lower Your Stress
- 5 Smart Strategies to Create Your Retirement Paycheck Without the Stress
- 7 Tax Blunders to Avoid in Your First Year of Retirement
