As traditional pension plans have largely disappeared over the years, many Baby Boomers heading into retirement today will by relying on cash balance pension plans instead. Understanding how to make the most of this employer benefit becomes increasingly important as one nears retirement.
Cash balance pension plans became popular in the late 1980s and early 1990s, especially with companies such as IBM, Xerox and AT&T, which at the time had large liabilities in their traditional defined benefit pensions. Cash balance pension plans emerged as a hybrid between traditional defined benefit plans (aka, a pension) and defined contribution plans (such as a 401(k) plan), offering employees a portable retirement benefit. The plans gained popularity among employers seeking to manage their costs and risks, while providing competitive retirement benefits.
Individuals with a cash balance pension plan face numerous decisions as they near retirement. Understanding the various options available is crucial for maximizing retirement income and ensuring financial security.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Let’s review the considerations and choices one should explore when navigating their cash balance pension options.
The basics
Unlike traditional defined benefit pensions, which provide a specific monthly benefit upon retirement, a cash balance pension maintains a hypothetical account balance that grows based on company contributions and interest credits. Unlike a 401(k), the employee can’t select a menu of investment options from which to invest their balance. The company determines the cash balance plan’s crediting rate, sometimes quarterly, but most often set annually. Here are a few companies’ cash balance pension plans’ crediting rates for 2024:
- GlaxoSmithKline: 3%
- Duke Energy: 4.46%
- IBM: 5%
Upon retirement or separation from service, employees typically have several distribution options.
Option 1: A lump sum payment in cash.
Cash balance participants may consider taking a lump sum payment from their cash balance pension. However, the entire payment is taxed as ordinary income, which can be very costly. Participants should carefully weigh the tax implications associated with a lump sum distribution.
Option 2: An IRA rollover.
Participants can roll over their cash balance pension to an IRA. A direct rollover to a qualified retirement account is not taxable — but any withdrawals you take later on will be taxed. An IRA rollover offers a couple of major advantages: It provides the participant with greater investment options, and it allows for more flexible income tax planning.
Keep in mind that if you leave a company before retirement, some companies don’t allow a rollover until the participant reaches a specified age. In addition, some employers require those with small cash balance pension benefits (say under $10,000) to exit the plan — either in lump sum or IRA rollover — when separating from service.
Option 3: Annuity payments.
Another option is to convert the cash balance pension into a series of annuity payments. Annuities provide a steady stream of income over a specified period, offering retirees a predictable source of retirement income. Retirees should compare different annuity providers and payment options to find the most suitable arrangement for their financial needs and goals.
Participants can also opt for some combination of these different options. For example, a participant might decide to take annuity payments for 50% of their cash balance pension and do an IRA rollover with the other 50%.
Other considerations
As interest rates have risen, the crediting rates of some cash balance pension plans are lower than CD rates, making the rollover option more attractive. Participants should also remember that cash balance pension plans are subject to the same required distribution rules as IRAs.
Cash balance pension plans are an often-overlooked component of one’s retirement nest egg. Navigating retirement options with a cash balance pension requires careful consideration and planning. By understanding the available options, evaluating individual goals and managing cash balance pensions in concert with 401(k) and Social Security benefits, retirees can pave the way for a secure and fulfilling retirement journey.
Related Content
- Five Things Your Annuity Seller Won’t Tell You
- A Public Pension and Full Social Security Benefits? No Way
- Social Security Basics: 12 Things You Must Know to Maximize Your Social Security Benefits
- Pension Lump Sum Option vs. Annuity Payment: Which Is Better?
- Before You Retire, Consider These Five Questions
-
5 Historic Philadelphia Homes for Sale NowPhiladelphia is a goldmine of historic properties that rival the best in New York, London and Paris for charm and opulence. Here are five gems you can own.
-
When to Sell Your StockKnowing when to sell a stock is a major decision investors must make. While there's no one correct answer, we look at some best practices here.
-
Within Five Years of Retirement? Five Things to Do NowIf you're retiring in the next five years, your to-do list should contain some financial planning and, according to current retirees, a few life goals, too.
-
The Home Stretch: Seven Essential Steps for Pre-RetireesThe decade before retirement is the home stretch in the race to quit work — but there are crucial financial decisions to make before you reach the finish line.
-
Three Options for Retirees With Concentrated Stock PositionsIf a significant chunk of your portfolio is tied up in a single stock, you'll need to make sure it won't disrupt your retirement and legacy goals. Here's how.
-
Four Reasons It May Be Time to Shop for New InsuranceYou may be unhappy with your insurance for any number of reasons, so once you've decided to shop, what is appropriate (or inappropriate) timing?
-
Before You Invest Like a Politician, Consider This DilemmaAs apps that track congressional stock trading become more popular, investors need to take into consideration some caveats.
-
How to Put Together Your Personal Net Worth StatementNow that tax season is over for most of us, it's the perfect time to organize your assets and liabilities to assess your financial wellness.
-
Bouncing Back: New Tunes for Millennials Trying to Make ItAdele's mournful melodies kick off this generation's financial playlist, but with the right plan, Millennials can finish strong.
-
Early-Stage Startup Deals: How Do Convertible Notes Work?Some angel investors support early startups by providing a loan in exchange for a convertible note, which includes annual interest and a maturity date.
