Is Black Friday Worth It or Is It a Marketing Mirage?
Is Black Friday still worth it as the best day for deals? We share top tips for smart holiday shopping.

In years past, Black Friday deals were only good the day after Thanksgiving. However, that's all changed, with the Black Friday sales period usually extending from Thanksgiving evening through Sunday night, followed by Cyber Monday — which is traditionally when lots of online shopping deals appear.
Years ago, hordes of shoppers lined up outside stores to be the first to dive into the best Black Friday deals they could find. Deep discounts on highly sought-after toys and electronics drew the masses into brick-and-mortar stores. Online shopping has changed this tradition, especially with many retailers offering Black Friday offers early, way before the big sales day actually arrives.
Added to that, there can be suspicion about the extent to which the deals offered around this time represent... a good deal. There's no denying that some of the early excitement has come out of Black Friday. But, coming just after Thanksgiving and in the run-up to the holiday gift-giving season, many people still (and may always) associate Black Friday with sales shopping.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
So, how do you work out when the best deals are on offer? And is it worth shopping on Black Friday anyways? Let's dive in.
Is Black Friday worth it? Pros and cons
The pros of Black Friday are fairly obvious: Prices are lower on certain products and memberships, like Amazon Music Unlimited and Black Friday streaming deals. If you're shopping for holiday gifts, it's a great time to save on costs. If you were planning to buy certain other items, like computer monitors or large appliances, you could also find deals to save there, too, on items you were already planning to spend on.
The cons of Black Friday come with a little more nuance. For one, you may not be aware exactly how much of a discount you actually are getting, which is why it's worth doing some research and making a plan of what you're going to buy. The other negative to Black Friday is the basic concept of spending. You could get so swept up in the deals and the adrenaline of shopping that you spend more than you need to. This is where having a plan and using one of the best budgeting apps comes in handy.
In terms of timing: As far as the quality of Black Friday deals vs sale prices on the days leading up to Black Friday, it's safe to say that usually shopping on Black Friday itself will bring the best prices. On the other hand, you're more likely to have the choice of what you want to buy if you shop early, due to potential shortages of some products advertised on Black Friday. It all comes down to what's most important to you.
One thing to note is that heading to brick-and-mortar stores, on the day, may bring some interesting gift-with-purchase offers that you won't get online or on other days.
If you wait until after Black Friday, you may get different offer options for Cyber Monday and heading into the Christmas holiday season.
Black Friday vs. Cyber Monday
When looking at Black Friday vs. Cyber Monday, some themes emerge immediately.
Generally, Cyber Monday is a continuation of the prices offered on Black Friday rather than a new raft of discounted items. So, you probably won't see better prices if you wait for Cyber Monday, instead of buying on Black Friday weekend. That does, thankfully, give you more time to make decisions.
Shopping strategies for Black Friday
When it comes to maximizing your savings on Black Friday, it helps to have a strategy.
The hottest items like electronics, toys and gadgets will be the first to sell out. Thus, it's best to prioritize those over other items like apparel, which may still have the best prices of the year but also less competition from shoppers early in the day.
Here are some other smart shopping tips for Black Friday:
- Use price-tracking tools like CamelCamelCamel, PayPal Honey, Capital One Shopping, Keepa and Slickdeals.
- Make a shopping list.
- Make a schedule of which stores to hit when prioritizing the items with the most competition for their Black Friday deals.
- Avoid impulse buys.
- Skip certain big-ticket items like appliances or mattresses if you can wait. Better deals may be coming around Presidents' Day.
- For online shoppers, set up deal alerts on Alexa or the Amazon app.
- If you're a member of Costco, Sam's Club, BJ's Wholesale, or other members-only warehouse clubs, check your ads for exclusive members-only deals.
There are two types of memberships available, Gold Star Membership and Executive. These are available as personal and business memberships. All memberships come with two cards.
> Gold Star Membership is $65 (plus sales tax)
> Executive Membership comes with 2% annual rewards and is $130 (plus sales tax)
Stack Social is offering a $45 Digital Shop Card when you sign up for either membership, effectively saving you $45 on your Costco membership fee.
Win Black Friday by planning ahead
Stores advertise Black Friday deals for weeks before the actual day, but those deals may not actually offer the best prices.
It can be easy to be overwhelmed by the numerous deals being offered for weeks on end, but with a clear head and a plan in place, you'll be sure to make the most of the holiday shopping season.
Related content
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
Jacob is the founder and CEO of ValueWalk. What started as a hobby 10 years ago turned into a well-known financial media empire focusing in particular on simplifying the opaque world of the hedge fund world. Before doing ValueWalk full time, Jacob worked as an equity analyst specializing in mid and small-cap stocks. Jacob also worked in business development for hedge funds. He lives with his wife and five children in New Jersey. Full Disclosure: Jacob only invests in broad-based ETFs and mutual funds to avoid any conflict of interest.
-
The 28% Rule for Housing: Does It Still Work in Today’s Market?
Rising home prices and stubborn mortgage rates put this long-standing rule to the test.
-
Spirit Airlines' Future in Doubt: What This Means for Budget Travel
Spirit Airlines says it may not survive another year. Here's how its potential collapse could affect low-cost flights and what it means for travelers seeking affordable airfare.
-
Amazon Expands Same-Day Fresh Food Delivery to 1,000 Cities
Amazon's expanded grocery delivery service costs less than Amazon Fresh. Is it a better deal?
-
Walmart to Pay $5.6 Million for Overcharging Shoppers
The retail giant's latest settlement highlights ongoing pricing accuracy issues and what consumers should know before their next shopping trip.
-
One of T-Mobile’s Most Valuable Offers for Seniors
If you're looking to save money on your cell service, consider this T-Mobile deal for seniors.
-
How Apple’s Tariff Strategy Could Affect Your Next iPhone Upgrade
Apple’s $100 billion U.S. expansion could shift iPhone assembly stateside — impacting pricing, availability and your next upgrade decision.
-
Roku Launches $2.99 Ad-Free Streaming Plan: Howdy Explained
Roku just launched Howdy, an ad-free streaming service with 10,000 hours of classic content. Here's how it compares to other platforms.
-
Japan Tariffs: 5 Things That Might Get More Expensive for You
President Donald Trump's trade agreement with Japan features a 15% reciprocal tariff for all imported products, which could impact the prices of these items when you shop.
-
Price Hikes on Ikea, Cars and Medication: What the EU Trade Deal Means for Your Wallet
Trump's trade deal with the EU averted the worst case scenario, but U.S. consumers might still see price hikes on some key goods.
-
119 JCPenney Stores Just Sold — Here’s What Shoppers Should Know
The $947 million JCPenney deal hints at bigger retail and real estate shifts.