I Resolved to 'Shop My Closet.' Here's How It's Going

As the clock struck midnight on New Year's, I was thinking about a purse.

I'd recently gone to a women's alumni networking event and was struck by how neat everyone looked with their smooth leather crossbody bags. I clocked Kate Spade flaps and Donna Karan saddles, smartly paired with wool coats. I was thinking about buying a new purse to better fit in.

But as we headed into the new year, I remembered something relatively important: I already own a bunch of purses. Why was I so set on buying a new one?

From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance

Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues

CLICK FOR FREE ISSUE

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.

Sign up

I was already planning on participating in "Dry January," where you don't drink alcohol for the month, and decided to take a similar tact with shopping, as some people do with a "no-buy" or "no-spend" month. Part of Dry January is to consider your drinking habits — why you feel compelled to drink in certain situations — as well as to gain the health impacts of abstaining for 31 days.

The same can be said for shopping. Throughout January, I recognized my compulsion to buy a new bag as a way to meet the perceived need of fitting in. I thought about how I was chasing the dopamine rush that comes with making a purchase.

I also considered, like the health impacts of alcohol, the financial impacts of following through on those shopping yens. Six months ago, I bought a purse that I reasoned with myself, as a bit of girl math, was an "investment." But the more I wore it, the more I thought about it as "the same bag every woman in the West Village has." The initial rush of dopamine turned into "why did I spend $[redacted] to look like every other woman on the block?" Was I really going to waste that amount of money every six months for the rest of my life?

So, rather than buying a new purse, I decided to "shop my own closet" — make use of what I already own. Here's what that looked like to me.

1. Change what you own to fit your needs

As I thought about the type of purse I wanted, I realized it was already sitting in a pile in my closet — it just needed a little adjustment.

My grandmother was a tailor, and because of her, I look for high-quality materials and construction when I buy clothes and bags. This means products last longer instead of falling apart, and it also means they can be changed as trends (and waistlines) evolve. So when I think about shopping my own closet, I also think about how I can change what I have to fit what I want now.

One option is tailoring.

A few years ago, I gave my grandma a handful of dresses that I no longer fit into and asked what she could do. Some she was able to alter so they'd fit; others we turned into tops and skirts. Following her lead, I took a sewing class so I could alter my own clothes. This can save on exorbitant tailoring prices for something simple like hems as well as give the option to make a shirt fit exactly how I want it to, rather than let it rot in my closet.

Of course, you don't have to learn how to sew yourself: You can always go to a local tailor. Often, altering a garment is less expensive than buying a new one, and it almost always means preserving fabric rather than sending it to a landfill. But if you live in a high-cost-of-living place and are as stubborn as me, learning how to use a sewing machine is beneficial.

Another option is accessorizing.

My purse problem was laughably easy to solve, no sewing machine necessary. I had a Coach wristlet in my closet from circa 2005 that looked good as new (if you hold onto anything long enough it'll come back in style), but it had a short strap making it less likely for me to wear. Remembering my admiration of the crossbody bags at the alumni event, I simply went to the Coach website and looked for crossbody straps. You can always look for purse straps from less expensive retailers, and Coach Outlet has options at lower price points, too.

All it took was thinking about what the sticking point was to find the obvious solution. With that, I was able to transform my old purse into something new. You can also try this with styling and accessorizing. For example, if you're bored by your purse, why not try a new charm or scarf on it? As an added bonus, you can use those accessories with other outfits.

2. Restore your older bags and clothes

After the Coach miracle, I took a hard look at my other purses and considered why I didn't wear them as often. Some I inherited, and while they're timeless designs, the material has worn in the decades since they were purchased and some elements have started to break.

I realized the solution here was to fix what can be fixed.

Again, for some of these bags, the solution was laughably easy. I took them to a shoe cobbler who re-glued and tied straps and buckles in minutes. It was such a simple fix he refused to charge me for it (I left a tip anyways).

Others required more investment. I found a leather repair store and asked about restoring the exteriors of purses. This is where you'll need to do mental calculations considering the financial balance. The restoration estimates were higher than I expected, so I compared them against the value of the vintage purses.

Value means monetary, of course, as well as emotional and practical. For a more monetarily valuable purse I knew I'd wear a lot more, it made obvious sense to pay for the restoration. For less valuable purses I'd wear once or twice a year, I decided to wait and think about it.

I also found myself considering restorations an honor to the memory of the bags' first owner, or thinking about how delighted my grandmother would be when I showed her I'd taken care of her purse from the '80s — and then I stopped myself. It wouldn't necessarily make practical sense to spend money and materials to repair a purse I wasn't planning on wearing often. I set aside the emotions and decided to not repair those, for now.

3. Let someone else shop your closet

The reality is you're not going to hold onto everything you've ever bought forever. While you can alter and restore some things, others will just take up space. At a certain point, you're going to need to get rid of something.

The environmental impact of mass production and overconsumption was another compelling reason for me to hold back on buying a new purse. One step towards a solution to that problem is buying secondhand rather than new, and you can flip that reasoning to consider how to get rid of items you don't want anymore. Rather than shopping your closet, let someone else shop your closet so the clothes live on.

First, consider if anyone in your life would want what you're KonMari-ing. When my friend took a new job with a less-conservative style while I was returning to office post-COVID, for example, she passed her slacks and blazers on to me.

Second, think about donations. I'm sometimes wary of dropping bags off at larger thrift stores as there have been reports of donations ending up in landfills anyways. One tact is to get to know local shelters and charities and their needs, like coat drives or business-wear giveaways.

Third, think about selling. Maybe there's a consignment store nearby or you can look to places like Thredup, for example, an online consignment store.

If you're disposing of designer goods, I found TheRealReal, which measures its social impact, fairly practical. Instead of trying to take great photos and expertly list my own items, I can simply drop them off at TheRealReal's brick-and-mortar locations and they take care of the rest. What I earn if the items sell won't necessarily be as high as if I'd sold it myself, but I consider it a good exchange for the company doing the selling work for me. It's less a lucrative side hustle, more a bonus for cleaning out my closet.

At the end of the day, though, if you're worried about the environmental impact of shopping, the best thing to do is to shop less and buy items you know will last, both by quality and taste.

What I learned shopping my own closet

The work of shopping my closet achieved several goals: I learned to appreciate the items I have and gave them new life while taking more sustainable measures and saving money.

I also recognize I'm never going to be a perfect consumer. As much as we try to think reasonably, shopping is ripe with emotions. Throughout this process I encountered every feeling from insecurity, pride and boredom to grief, climate anxiety and gnawing guilt that I should really call my grandma more.

Much like Dry January, the idea of exercises like this is to be able to recognize your habits and feelings and where they come from. The more we're able to do that, the more we're able to hold back on the impulse to click "buy now."

And this doesn't mean I'll never buy a new purse again — or that I'll sweat with indecision at the counter. Rather, it means I'll be better informed and able to slow down the racing thoughts to make a decision with more practicality.

Related Content

• Should You Cancel Amazon Prime?
• Products You’ll Waste Money Buying at Warehouse Clubs
• Online Side Hustles Worth Your Time, Including In Retirement