Value vs Growth Investing Isn't So Simple
The difference between growth and value stocks isn't black and white.


Warren Buffett likes to say that price is what you pay, value is what you get. But that doesn't mean blindly indexing to value stocks is a path to long-term success.
After all, value stocks have broadly lagged growth stocks for more than a decade and there's no telling when they'll catch back up.
Besides, value is in the eye of the beholder. It's not for nothing that, on average, about 30% of the stocks in the benchmark Russell 1000 Value Index are also found in the Russell 1000 Growth Index.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
"The remaining 70% are assigned to be either all growth or all value," per FTSE Russell.
Passive investors in a broad market index that tracks the S&P 500 needn't worry about the style differences between value and growth. Such distinctions are of more concern to tacticians and traders.
Nevertheless, there is something unusual about value's long-term slump.
First, a quick recap on value stocks vs growth stocks: Value stocks are equities that are perceived to be trading at a discount based on metrics such as price-to-book ratios, price-to-earnings ratios, dividend payout ratios and the like.
Growth stocks tend to trade at premiums to these metrics, as investors are willing to pony up for accelerating future free cash flows.
It's important to know that classifying stocks as growth or value is not a straightforward matter.
Russell assigns a growth and value weight based on its valuation criteria, which is how so many stocks find themselves represented in both benchmark indexes.
As FTSE Russell notes, what started out as a way for active managers to benchmark their performance based on their investment styles became a tool for professionals to make "unbalanced allocations based on their strategic or tactical views."
In other words, the benchmark growth and value indexes are not pure plays, and haven't been for decades.
"Pre-conceived notions of 'growth' and 'value' aren't always reflected in indexes labeled growth and value," writes Liz Ann Sonders, chief investment strategist at Charles Schwab. "That has been both exacerbated and emphasized in the post-pandemic era, especially for a sector like technology, which is traditionally thought of as dominating the growth sphere but now has a hefty weight in some value indexes."
Is value investing dead?
"Value investing is based on the premise that paying less for a set of future cash flows is associated with a higher expected return," writes the equity investing team at Dimensional Fund Advisors. "That's one of the most fundamental tenets of investing."
Over the long haul, value stocks have indeed outperformed growth stocks in the U.S., often by wide margins.
"Data covering nearly a century backs up the notion that value stocks — those with lower relative prices — have higher expected returns," Dimensional adds. "While disappointing periods emerge from time to time, the principle that lower relative prices lead to higher expected returns remains the same."
Given that mean reversion is a thing in both life and investing, value investors may be forgiven for expecting their stylistic preference to come back vs growth.
But it hasn't happened yet.
Have a look at the chart below to see the performance of the iShares Russell 1000 Value ETF (IWD) vs the iShares Russell 1000 Growth ETF (IWF) over the past decade to see how far the gap has widened on a total return basis (price change plus dividends).
Using these benchmark ETFs as proxies, we can see that growth returned more than 360% over the past 10 years vs less than 140% for value. That bucks historical trends in a big way. Since 1927, value stocks outperformed growth stocks by 4.4% annually in the U.S.
This doesn't mean value investing is dead. However, it might suggest that value investing via a broad index like the Russell 1000 Value Index isn't the best way to find value stocks. It isn't necessarily a good proxy for retail investors looking for cheap diversification to true value names.
Finding true value stocks is hard – just ask Warren Buffett. That said, value investors do have history on their side.
As Hartford Funds notes, "the performance of growth stocks and value stocks has been cyclical. This cyclical behavior highlights the benefits of having both types of investments in a portfolio."
Getting the balance and timing of such tactical allocations is generally best left to the pros.
Related Content
- What Will the Fed Do at Its Next Meeting?
- If You'd Put $1,000 Into Berkshire Hathaway Stock 20 Years Ago, Here's What You'd Have Today
- The 10 'Real' Richest Counties in the U.S.
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.

Dan Burrows is Kiplinger's senior investing writer, having joined the publication full time in 2016.
A long-time financial journalist, Dan is a veteran of MarketWatch, CBS MoneyWatch, SmartMoney, InvestorPlace, DailyFinance and other tier 1 national publications. He has written for The Wall Street Journal, Bloomberg and Consumer Reports and his stories have appeared in the New York Daily News, the San Jose Mercury News and Investor's Business Daily, among many other outlets. As a senior writer at AOL's DailyFinance, Dan reported market news from the floor of the New York Stock Exchange.
Once upon a time – before his days as a financial reporter and assistant financial editor at legendary fashion trade paper Women's Wear Daily – Dan worked for Spy magazine, scribbled away at Time Inc. and contributed to Maxim magazine back when lad mags were a thing. He's also written for Esquire magazine's Dubious Achievements Awards.
In his current role at Kiplinger, Dan writes about markets and macroeconomics.
Dan holds a bachelor's degree from Oberlin College and a master's degree from Columbia University.
Disclosure: Dan does not trade individual stocks or securities. He is eternally long the U.S equity market, primarily through tax-advantaged accounts.
-
4 Career Moves to Make Now if You're Worried About a Recession
Worried about a recession? These steps to protect your job prospects will help you professionally whether a downturn develops or not.
-
How StoryCorps Works and How You Can Tell Your Story
StoryCorps has recorded conversations between thousands of people, and anyone can participate. National facilitator Alan Jinich explains how to share your story.
-
I'm a Retirement Psychologist: Here's Why Doing What You 'Ought' in Retirement Beats Doing Whatever You Want
True retirement freedom isn't about simply doing whatever you want, but about finding purpose and direction through commitments that align with your deepest values and allow you to contribute meaningfully.
-
Tactical Roth Conversions: Why 2025-2028 Is a Critical Window for Retirees
The One Big Beautiful Bill (OBBB) extended today's low tax brackets, but they may not last. Here's how smart planning now can prevent costly tax surprises later.
-
Ready to Retire? It's Not Too Late to Convert to a Roth IRA
Millions of Americans are turning 65 this year. If you're retiring soon, don't dismiss the idea of a Roth conversion — it could still be a smart move even now.
-
9 Warren Buffett Quotes for Investors to Live By
Warren Buffett transformed Berkshire Hathaway from a struggling textile firm to a sprawling conglomerate and investment vehicle. Here's how he did it.
-
I'm a Financial Adviser: Three Things You Will Wish You Did Before the Fed Cuts Interest Rates
With potential interest rate cuts on the horizon, you might want to lock in today's higher yields and consider adjusting your asset allocation.
-
Simple Ways to Save on Back-to-School Shopping This Year
Set a budget and stick to it, scour the house for what you already have, decorate backpacks and lunch boxes with your kids and consider buying some items during holiday sales.
-
Stocks End Strong Month on a Down Note: Stock Market Today
There was likely a bit of profit-taking ahead of a historically weak September.
-
If You'd Put $1,000 Into UnitedHealth Group Stock 20 Years Ago, Here's What You'd Have Today
UNH stock was a massive market beater for ages – until it wasn't.