Get Real: Benchmarking to the S&P 500 isn’t a Good Strategy
Trying to beat the Standard & Poor’s could lead investors down a path of failed expectations and excessive risk.
Study after study has shown that beating the S&P 500 is over the long-term is nearly impossible. Yet, nearly every time I meet with a new investor, they ask the question, “How have you done against the market (S&P 500)?”
My reply is generally something along the lines of “is that what you’re looking for?” and their answer is either a look of confusion or a resounding “yes.” However, in further conversation, investors come to understand that this is the wrong question. It inevitably will lead them down a path of failed expectations and missed goals (in my previous column I detailed the importance of setting and understanding your goals).
Beating the S&P 500 sounds great, but it does little to help investors gain peace of mind. Moreover it may also be impractical and require taking on risks that are unacceptable to you.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
You don’t have to look back far, 2008-09 is less than a decade behind us. If your portfolio lost 35% in 2008 and gained 3% in 2011, you beat the S&P in both years, so what? Neither seems an attractive return to me.
For the decade ending 2009 the S&P was flat, hardly impressive; and for the period between Dec. 31, 2009, and May 31, 2017, the index returned just over 26% annualized. While the latter is impressive, if you walked into my office and I told you that I have a strategy that has returned over 25% annually you’d rightfully assume that there must be incredible risks associated with this strategy.
My point is simply that benchmarking your goals and expectations to the S&P 500 or any other index is silly and impractical.
Instead of heedlessly chasing the S&P, investors should:
- Take account of their goals.
- Evaluate the costs associated with reaching these goals.
- Task their investment adviser with developing a plan that is likely to achieve these goals with the least amount of risk possible.
This column is the second in a six-part series. In my next column I will detail the importance of focusing on cash-flow generation from your portfolio instead of focusing on your expected investment returns, especially in retirement.
- Column 1: Understanding your goals
- Column 2: Why benchmarking to the S&P 500 is not a good strategy
- Column 3: It’s about cash-flow, not returns
- Column 4: How much are you paying for your portfolio?
- Column 5: 5 critical questions to ask your financial adviser
- Column 6: ‘Senior Inflation’ the not so silent retirement killer
-
S&P 500 Tops 7,000, Fed Pauses Rate Cuts: Stock Market TodayInvestors, traders and speculators will probably have to wait until after Jerome Powell steps down for the next Fed rate cut.
-
The Met Opera May Sell Its Iconic Paintings. Is it a Good Investment?Buying the Marc Chagall murals would come with a big stipulation attached.
-
Do You Really Need All Those Phone Plan Perks?Unlimited data plans now come bundled with streaming, travel perks and device deals — but many people pay for extras they rarely use.
-
S&P 500 Tops 7,000, Fed Pauses Rate Cuts: Stock Market Today
Investors, traders and speculators will probably have to wait until after Jerome Powell steps down for the next Fed rate cut.
-
Today's Senior Living Communities Are Not Your Grandma's 'Old Folks' Home': An Expert Guide to Shopping for the Right FitSenior living facilities have improved and are as diverse as the people who inhabit them. Now, they're more than just a place to go — they're a place to grow.
-
3 Common Misconceptions About Working With a Financial PlannerThink financial planners are only for the wealthy and that AI can replace human advice? Nope. Even people with moderate wealth need professional advice.
-
Should You Consider Investing in the Quantum Computing Sector? This Investment Adviser Has Some SuggestionsInvestors interested in quantum computing could consider ETFs focused on cloud services enabling small businesses to use big technology.
-
S&P 500 Hits New High Before Big Tech Earnings, Fed: Stock Market TodayThe tech-heavy Nasdaq also shone in Tuesday's session, while UnitedHealth dragged on the blue-chip Dow Jones Industrial Average.
-
I'm an Estate Planning Attorney: These Are the Estate Plan Details You Need to Discuss (And What to Keep Private)Gen Xers and Millennials would like to know if they're going to inherit (and how much), but Baby Boomers in general don't like to talk about money. What to do?
-
I'm a Financial Adviser: This Is How You Can Minimize the Damage of Bad Market Timing at RetirementPoor investment returns early in retirement on top of withdrawals can quickly drain your savings. The ideal plan helps prevent having to sell assets at a loss.
-
'You Owe Me a Refund': Readers Report Challenging Their Attorneys' BillsThe article about lawyers billing clients for hours of work that AI did in seconds generated quite a response. One law firm even called a staff meeting.
