The Investor’s Dilemma: Active, Passive, or Asset-Class Investing?
It’s a decision that warrants the investor’s time and due diligence, because, ultimately, your wealth is at stake and the wrong move could be costly.

When it comes to your wealth management strategy, deciding what to do gets complicated. There are about 45,000 individual securities and more than 30,000 mutual funds and 1,000 ETFs (exchange-traded funds which track a particular index).
There is a map to help guide you through the tens of thousands of investments to choose form. First, you must decide between Active Management and Passive Management. Active Management is someone or a team making decisions based upon their research, then engaging in the market as a competitor in search of Alpha (excess return above a specific benchmark). Passive Management on the other hand seeks to capture the return of the market without taking excess risk, and most importantly at a lower cost to investors.
Active managers are prone to emotion, external circumstances, and management style drift. They try and outsmart the market based on analysis, timing, predictions and forecasts. Over time it has been shown that a significant majority of actively managed funds will underperform their respective benchmarks. There are multiple reasons for this discrepancy, starting with higher fees and less tax efficiency.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Be a smarter, better informed investor.

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
After costs, the return on the average actively managed dollar will be less than the return on the average passively managed dollar. It’s simple math: After fees and costs, active management becomes a losing game in which the expected outcome is negative. Said differently, some active managers will win some of the time, but the majority usually come up short. It’s a zero-sum game, so with every winner there’s a loser. Trying to pre-identify the small percentage of the winners is extremely difficult.
Passive investing, while less sexy, has become increasingly popular for a large number of investors. A recent study showed that in one year $61 billion flowed into the passive management fund bucket, and in the same year $95 billion flowed out of the active management fund bucket; this trend continues.
Here we come to a fork in the road: Indexing via ETFs or index funds, or Asset-Class Investing.
There are some inherent problems with ETF or index-fund investing:
- There are costs associated with tracking an index. When indexes drop or add a security, the tracking funds are required to do the same. This pushes the price up for purchases and down for sales, making the transaction more costly. The index fund loses the information game here as market participants can anticipate trades ahead of time.
- Indexes are not flexible, and there’s often drift between asset classes. Constituents of any index can move from one asset class to another (small cap to mid cap, for example), but the index only reconstitutes once a year.
- There is zero flexibility in security selection. The Index fund needs to mirror its respective index. There are no exceptions.
Indexes are designed to establish market performance and serve as a benchmark for active managers, not serve as investment vehicles. Some of the advantages of ETFs or index funds are that they have low costs, broad diversification and tax advantages.
Asset-Class Investing is a form of passive investing in the sense that the underlying premise is that markets are efficient, and increasingly so. Both Asset-Class and Passive Management are based on the hypothesis that markets are efficient in that they rapidly price information from 45+ million trades a day, which makes it very difficult to capitalize on any public information.
But there is one major difference: Asset-Class Investing is based on research from some of the academic community’s most innovative and respected thinkers and economists. Rooted in the knowledge that asset allocation has the greatest impact on investment returns, it is designed to control the investments included in each asset class.
This increased flexibility and ability to keep asset classes pure to their objective allows asset-class funds to truly capture the returns in each respective asset class in a dynamic, tax-efficient and low-cost manner.
Some of the advantages of the Asset-Class Investing approach include:
- More flexibility than Passive Management in allowing more pure exposure to the various asset classes. When there is style drift or a significant change in a security’s profile (from small cap to mid cap, for example), changes can be made to the portfolio on a daily basis. Given the annual reconstitution basis of index funds, there can be significant divergence from the asset allocation model. Asset-Based Investing can adjust on a daily basis.
- Securities within asset-class funds can be adjusted with discretion as opposed to the rigid structure of Index funds.
- Advanced trading strategies can be deployed to minimize transaction costs.
Ultimately, the decision on which investment approach to take must come from you (and your financial adviser, if you’re working with one). It’s a decision that warrants the investor’s time and due diligence because, ultimately, your wealth is at stake and the wrong move could be costly.
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.

Woodring is founding partner of San Francisco Bay area Cypress Partners, a fee-only wealth consulting practice that provides personalized, comprehensive services that help retirees and busy professionals to enjoy life free of financial concern.
-
Seven Surprising Reasons Retirees Are Going Back to Work
Sure, money is a big reason to come out of retirement, but it's not the only reason retirees are doing it.
-
Dow Gains 617 Points as Rate Cuts Near: Stock Market Today
Wednesday's economic data didn't shift Wall Street's expectations that the Fed is preparing for a rate cut at next week's meeting.
-
Four Clever and Tax-Efficient Ways to Ditch Concentrated Stock Holdings, From a Financial Planner
Holding too much of one company's stock can put your financial future at risk. Here are four ways you can strategically unwind such positions without triggering a massive tax bill.
-
Beyond Banking: How Credit Unions Serve Their Communities
Credit unions differentiate themselves from traditional banks by operating as member-owned financial cooperatives focused on community support and service rather than shareholder profit.
-
Answers to Every Early Retiree's Questions This Year, From a Wealth Adviser
From how to retire in a crazy market to how much to withdraw and how to spend without feeling guilty, a financial pro shares the advice he's given this year.
-
The Risks of Forced DST-to-UPREIT Conversions, From a Real Estate Expert
Some new Delaware statutory trust offerings are forcing investors into 721 UPREIT conversions at the end of the hold period, raising concerns about loss of control, limited liquidity, opaque valuations and unexpected tax liabilities.
-
I'm a Financial Adviser: You've Built Your Wealth, Now Make Sure Your Family Keeps It
The Great Wealth Transfer is well underway, yet too many families aren't ready. Here's how to bridge the generation gap that could threaten your legacy.
-
Want to Advance on the Job? Showing Some Courtesy and Appreciation Could Help
Two business professors share their insights about the impact of digital communication on the social skills of some in Gen Z and the importance of good manners on the job.
-
From Job Loss to Free Agent: A Financial Professional's Transition Playbook (and Pep Talk)
The American workforce is in transition, and if you're among those affected, take heart. You have the skills, experience and smarts that companies need.
-
A Financial Planner's Top Five Items to Prioritize When Your Spouse Is Ill
During tough times, it's easy to overlook important financial details, but you'll be so much better off if you take care of these things right now.