How We Rank the Best College Values
Our formula: 55% quality measures, 45% financial measures.
To come up with our best values, we start with data on nearly 1,200 public and private four-year schools provided by Peterson’s, then add our own reporting. We narrow the list based on measures of academic quality. We then rank each school using cost and financial aid measures. Quality criteria account for 55% of total points, and cost criteria account for 45%. For 2015, for the first time, we include a combined list of the 300 best values in private liberal arts colleges, private universities and public colleges to show how the top schools in each of the three categories stack up against each other. We also include our rankings of the top 100 private universities, top 100 liberal arts colleges and top 100 public universities.
In this category, we include admission rate (the percentage of applicants offered admission) and yield (the percentage of students who enroll out of those admitted). The first number demonstrates the selectivity of the school, and the second shows its ability to compete with other schools for accepted applicants. We also consider the percentage of incoming freshmen who are high scorers on the SAT or ACT, because high achievers enhance the academic atmosphere.
On the quality side, our rankings give the most weight to the four-year graduation rate to reward colleges that help students get undergraduate degrees on time and within budget.
Freshman retention rate shows the percentage of students who return for their sophomore year, an indication of how successful the college is in keeping them on track. Students per faculty—the average number of students per faculty member—is another measure of how well each college fulfills its academic mission.
Cost and Financial Aid
To evaluate costs, we give the most points to schools with the lowest total cost (tuition, fees, room and board, and books). In the combined rankings, we use out-of-state costs for the public schools to provide an apples-to-apples comparison with private schools. In the public-school rankings, we rank the schools according to in-state costs and calculate out-of-state costs separately for the out-of-state rank.
We then add points to schools that reduce the price through need-based aid (grants but not loans) and to those that knock down the price through non-need-based aid. Some schools fail to cover the gap between expected family contribution and the aid they provide. We reward schools with the highest percentage of need met, and we give points to schools based on the percentage of students without need who receive non-need-based aid.
Schools that keep down average debt at graduation deserve extra points, and we reward them accordingly. We also factor in the percentage of students who borrow. The lower the number, the better the score.
Additions and Exclusions
Our rankings focus on traditional four-year schools with broad-based curricula, along with student housing. This year we’ve included schools in the City University of New York (CUNY) system, which has introduced on-campus student housing in recent years, in our public-school rankings.
Schools that offer great value but focus on special or narrow academic programs, such as the military service academies, are excluded. For our public-college rankings, Cornell University, best known as a member of the Ivy League, is another exception. It has three land-grant state schools, each of which costs about $31,000 a year for in-state tuition and fees; these schools have been omitted from the public list because the majority of schools at Cornell are part of the privately endowed university.
Schools We Couldn't Rank
In our continuing effort to provide the most accurate and complete data available, we have excluded schools that did not supply us with all the data required to accurately calculate their ranking. Here are the schools, listed in alphabetical order:
Allegheny College, Meadville, Pa.
Bard College, Annandale-on-Hudson, N.Y.
Baylor University, Waco, Tex.
California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo
Catholic University of America, Washington, D.C.
Columbia University, New York, N.Y.
Concordia College, Moorhead, Minn.
Denison University, Granville, Ohio
Ithaca College, Ithaca, N.Y.
Moravian College, Bethlehem, Pa.
Northeastern University, Boston, Mass.
Shimer College, Chicago, Ill.
Simmons College, Boston, Mass.
Wagner College, Staten Island, N.Y.
Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Worcester, Mass.
Marc A. Wojno, Kaitlin Pitsker and David Kuchler helped compile this data.