Skip to headerSkip to main contentSkip to footer
Get our Free E-newslettersGet our Free E-newsletters
Kiplinger logoLink to homepage
Get our Free E-newslettersGet our Free E-newsletters
Subscribe to Kiplinger
Subscribe to Kiplinger
Save up to 76%
Subscribe
Subscribe to Kiplinger
  • Store
  • Home
  • Investing
  • Retirement
  • Taxes
  • Personal Finance
  • Your Business
  • Wealth Creation
  • More
    • Podcasts
    • Economic Outlooks
    • Tools
  • My Kiplinger
    • Kiplinger's Personal Finance Magazine
    • The Kiplinger Letter
    • The Kiplinger Tax Letter
    • Kiplinger's Investing for Income
    • Kiplinger's Retirement Report
    • Store
    • Manage My E-Newsletters
    • My Subscriptions
  • Home
  • investing
investing

ONLINE BROKERS AT A GLANCE

Competition among online brokers is tough -– which is good news for investors.

by: Kiplinger Team
January 1, 2012

Competition among online brokers is tough -– which is good news for investors. As a group, they’re providing more services for customers than they did just a few years ago. We examined 11 firms on a variety of criteria, ranging from transaction costs and fees to research and mutual fund offerings. Take a quick glance at some pros and cons of each brokerage, and see which one offers the best of what you’re looking for.

1 of 11

Online Brokers at a Glance

PROS: OptionsXpress is tops in our overall ranking. This relative newcomer has a lot going for it. The brokerage boasts fast service, a wide selection of mutual funds, and low fund prices. Its brokers are quite knowledgeable, too.CONS: Stock-trading commissions aren’t the cheapest (at $14.95), and the brokerage doesn’t offer any funds without transaction fees. (Note: All brokerage commissions listed in this slide show are for trades of up to 1,000 shares.)

2 of 11

Online Brokers at a Glance

PROS: Siebert's customer service is good. The firm also offers a solid selection of stock research from both large and boutique firms.CONS: Siebert’s Web site is hard to navigate and could stand some improvement.

3 of 11

Online Brokers at a Glance

PROS: If you have at least $250,000 in your Wells Fargo brokerage account, you can enjoy 50 free stock or fund trades yearly -– as long as you open a Portfolio Management Account, the company’s high-end checking account. Wells Fargo also scores points with us for paying decent interest on cash balances: Its money-market fund pays 4%.CONS: Commissions outside the PMA program are on the high end, at $19.95. And of the brokerages we surveyed, Wells Fargo has had the most run-ins with clients and regulators

4 of 11

Online Brokers at a Glance

PROS: Firstrade is the Wal-Mart of online brokers -– no frills, but low prices on stocks and funds. Firstrade doesn’t charge anything to buy or sell any of its no-load funds. It also receives the clean hands award for fewest squabbles with regulators and clients.CONS: Firstrade’s Web site is among the most difficult to use, and the brokerage offers little stock research.

5 of 11

Online Brokers at a Glance

PROS: If you crave stock research, Fidelity is by far the best choice. Altogether, you get as much research from Fidelity as you do from most full-service brokers. And you get free access to Fidelity funds. Fidelity’s Web site is also exceptionally easy to navigate.CONS: Fidelity brokers didn’t perform well when we quizzed them with sample customer questions. The firm also receives low marks for execution because it routes a large percentage of trade orders to a firm it owns, instead of shopping trades around for the best possible price.

6 of 11

Online Brokers at a Glance

PROS: If you love Vanguard funds, this online broker is a contender. Its money-market fund pays a generous 4.4% interest on cash balances. And it minimizes nickel-and-dime fees. Vanguard also earns high marks for trade execution because it spreads trades among a variety of market participants.CONS: Commissions are surprisingly high for Vanguard: $25 per trade for a $50,000 account; $22.50 if you have $500,000.

7 of 11

Online Brokers at a Glance

PROS: TradeKing offers the cheapest stock commissions around. This newcomer has been operating only since December 2005, and overall improvement is expected.CONS: Stock research offerings are still slim. So is the firm’s selection of no-load mutual funds. Also be aware that the brokerage provides no cost-basis information, which could cause a headache at tax time.

8 of 11

Online Brokers at a Glance

PROS: Schwab is great for clients who want clear direction. It supplies plenty of stock research, with an emphasis on its own computer-generated Schwab Equity Ratings. Its brokers are the most knowledgeable we encountered. Schwab offers more than 5,000 no-load mutual funds, almost 4,000 of them with no transaction fee.CONS: If you want to buy or sell a fund not included on Schwab’s no-transaction-fee list, you’ll pay dearly. Schwab also imposes several incidental fees: $95 to close your account and $2.50 to send you an old statement, for example. The company isn’t generous with interest on cash balances, either: If you total account is worth less than $100,000, your cash earns as little as 1%.

9 of 11

Online Brokers at a Glance

PROS: E*Trade’s Web site is simply terrific.CONS: E*Trade offers fewer than 1,750 no-load funds. And cash balances under $5,000 earn as little as 0.2% annually. Slow phone-response time and high extra fees hurt the brokerage’s ranking as well.

10 of 11

Online Brokers at a Glance

PROS: Scottrade charges low stock commissions, though not the lowest around.CONS: Scottrade offers fewer than 1,800 no-load funds and fewer than 1,000 without a transaction fee. Customer service can be slow.

11 of 11

Online Brokers at a Glance

PROS: TD Ameritrade offers below-average commissions on stock trades and a solid selection of no-load mutual funds.CONS: You’ll pay $49.99 each time you buy or sell a fund not on TD Ameritrade’s no-transaction-fee list. The brokerage pays no interest on cash balances under $2,000. And if you use margin -– that is, borrow money against the value of your account -– be prepared for a high interest rate. Also be aware that the firm doesn’t provide tax-basis information for clients with less than $50,000. Its Web site isn’t all that easy to use, either.

  • investing
  • bonds
Share via EmailShare on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedIn

Recommended

Bonds: 10 Things You Need to Know
Investing for Income

Bonds: 10 Things You Need to Know

Bonds can be more complex than stocks, but it's not hard to become a knowledgeable fixed-income investor.
July 22, 2020
Why I Like Ginnie Mae Funds Now
Investing for Income

Why I Like Ginnie Mae Funds Now

A portfolio of mortgages should retain their value better than ordinary bonds if interest rates rise.
February 28, 2021
2 Top-Tier T. Rowe Price Mutual Funds
mutual funds

2 Top-Tier T. Rowe Price Mutual Funds

T. Rowe Price's mutual funds typically stand out among their peers, but these two selections provide elite equity and bond exposure for this point in …
February 24, 2021
How Green Are Your Bonds?
Becoming an Investor

How Green Are Your Bonds?

Fixed-income investors can make an environmental impact.
February 23, 2021

Most Popular

Will Your Stimulus Check Increase Your Tax on Social Security Benefits?
Coronavirus and Your Money

Will Your Stimulus Check Increase Your Tax on Social Security Benefits?

The answer to this question comes down to whether your stimulus check increases your "provisional income."
March 1, 2021
Where's My Refund? How to Track Your Tax Refund Status
tax refunds

Where's My Refund? How to Track Your Tax Refund Status

If you're waiting for your tax refund, the IRS has an online tool that lets you track the status of your payment.
March 2, 2021
4 Ways You May Be Sabotaging Your Career Success
careers

4 Ways You May Be Sabotaging Your Career Success

To be a success, it’s helpful to know what NOT to do on the job. An interview with the best-selling author of “The Art of Being Indispensable at Work”…
March 1, 2021
  • Customer Service
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us (PDF)
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Kiplinger Careers
  • Accessibility
  • Privacy Preferences

Subscribe to Kiplinger's Personal Finance

Be a smarter, better informed investor.
Save up to 76%Subscribe to Kiplinger's Personal Finance
Dennis Publishing Ltd logoLink to Dennis Publishing Ltd website
Do Not Sell My Information

The Kiplinger Washington Editors, Inc., is part of the Dennis Publishing Ltd. Group.
All Contents © 2021, The Kiplinger Washington Editors

Follow us on InstagramFollow us on FacebookFollow us on TwitterConnect on LinkedInConnect on YouTube