No, AI Can't Plan Your Retirement: This (Human) Investment Adviser Explains Why
AI has infinite uses. But creating an accurate retirement strategy based on your unique goals is one place where its possibilities seem lacking.
Artificial intelligence has become the talk of the town. From boardrooms to classrooms, every corner of our lives seems to be embracing new AI tools, for better or for worse.
In 2025, approximately 66% of Americans reported seeking financial advice from generative AI, according to Credit Karma. That figure rises above 80% for Millennials and Gen Z.
While sources such as ChatGPT and Copilot have proven to be valuable tools, they have also shown to provide misleading, fragmented or even false information when it comes to personal finance recommendations.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
There are many perks to AI's capabilities, but I have three major issues when it comes to using AI for financial advice:
1. Inaccurate information
Despite an explosion in generative AI's capabilities over the past few years, these programs are far from perfect. Asking them to advise you on the most recent tax laws, IRA contribution limits or loan forgiveness programs may lead to receiving outdated or inaccurate information.
A recent UK study by consumer group Which? asked numerous AI tools for investing advice and found some offered tips that would specifically breach tax law. Researchers also found that if they added a flaw to their question or prompt, AI rarely caught it and would offer advice regardless.
A financial adviser can help clarify a question with an error in the premise. AI will regurgitate an answer regardless of the basis.
2. Unrealistic goals
I asked ChatGPT to share steps that would allow me to retire within the next 10 years, earlier than my original plan. A few of its ideas included:
- Saving half of my income between now and retirement
- Selling my home and moving to a new state
- Increasing my yearly income by $50,000
Even after providing extensive information about income, assets and goals, generative AI could not maintain the holistic scope of planning required for retirement planning. Many of its suggestions required drastic life changes and did not consider personal connections or desires post-retirement.
Where these programs truly fall short is in the objective vs the subjective. They can offer objective facts (when they get them right), whereas a financial adviser can offer subjective insights.
The economic factors that impact our finances are moving more rapidly than ever. Advisers are fluid and forward-thinking. AI can only build a puzzle with the pieces you provide at the time of your question, which leaves the picture incomplete.
Which brings us to its greatest flaw:
3. No personal connection
Every retirement plan ever drafted has needed to evolve. Life changes, and so will your wealth, health, family dynamics and personal goals. It's in those moments that a personal connection with a trusted adviser can provide comfort and relief.
Much like a trusted friend or family member you would go to for advice, an adviser knows you and your story.
Artificial intelligence cannot grasp the emotional and interpersonal elements of your dreams and desires. Financial planning may be a numbers game, but every number is built on a relationship between you and your adviser.
At the end of the day, financial planning is about people. AI can do many things, but it cannot replace human connection and judgment.
Of the Americans who have taken financial advice from AI, more than half claimed to have made a poor financial decision as a result, according to Credit Karma.
I predict that financial advisers will need to adapt alongside this technology and integrate it, just as it is being integrated into every other aspect of our lives. The ones who fail to do so will be left behind.
However, in an increasingly digital world, it's the human component that will become more valuable by the day. Humans are social creatures who desire real connection and trusted relationships. That aspect hasn't changed over the course of human history, and it won't change with AI.
This exciting new tool is worth deploying in our lives, but it's no replacement for a relationship with a trusted professional who comes alongside you on your retirement journey.
Related Content
- Can AI Help With Your Finances?
- Have a Retirement Question? AI Can Answer That
- How to Protect Your Privacy While Using AI
- 5 Downsides to DIY Financial Planning
- In Retirement, a Do-It-All Adviser Can Offer Comprehensive Options
-
Tax Season 2026 Is Here: 8 Big Tax Changes to Know Before You FileTax Tips Due to several major tax rule changes, your 2025 return might feel unfamiliar even if your income looks the same.
-
The New Rules of RetirementPopular guidelines about how to save, invest and spend need to be updated and personalized to ensure you'll never run out of money.
-
Humanoid Robots Are About to be Put to the TestThe Kiplinger Letter Robot makers are in a full-on sprint to take over factories, warehouses and homes, but lofty visions of rapid adoption are outpacing the technology’s reality.
-
The New Rules of Retirement
Popular guidelines about how to save, invest and spend need to be updated and personalized to ensure you'll never run out of money.
-
A Value Focus Clips Returns for This Mairs & Power Growth FundRough years for UnitedHealth and Fiserv have weighed on returns for one of our favorite mutual funds.
-
Small-Cap Stocks Gain Momentum. That's Good News for This iShares ETFThe clouds appear to be parting for small-cap stocks, which bodes well for one of our favorite exchange-traded funds.
-
Don't Let a 60/40 Portfolio Derail Your Retirement: Why a Cookie-Cutter Approach Could Cost YouChoosing a personalized retirement investment plan, rather than relying on the 60/40 portfolio, could help protect your savings and ensure long-term growth.
-
Are You Winging Your Retirement Plan? A Wealth Adviser's Tips to Help Build Wealth and Navigate RiskIf you have no strategy tying together your accounts or haven't modeled scenarios to make sure your savings will last, then your plan is probably inefficient.
-
Divide and Conquer: Your Annual Financial Plan Made Easy, Courtesy of a Financial AdviserOverwhelmed by your financial to-do list? Split it into four quarters and assign each one goals that connect to the time of year. It could be life-changing.
-
Nasdaq Leads Ahead of Big Tech Earnings: Stock Market TodayPresident Donald Trump is making markets move based on personal and political as well as financial and economic priorities.
-
11 Stock Picks Beyond the Magnificent 7With my Mag-7-Plus strategy, you can own the mega caps individually or in ETFs and add in some smaller tech stocks to benefit from AI and other innovations.
