Cover Your Retirement Income Bases With Scenario Planning
Here are three strategies to help you plan for best- and worst-case scenarios, positioning you for retirement success.
If you’re like most Americans, you’re undersaved, underplanned and underprepared for retirement.
In fact, 55% of employed Americans surveyed by Bankrate.com say they are behind on their retirement savings goals. The stock market, which declined significantly in 2022, was a definite stressor for savers, with the average 401(k) balance down by 23%, according to financial services behemoth Fidelity.
Fortunately, there are steps you can take before retirement to remedy these deficits. Deciding when to retire and when to claim Social Security are two important decisions you’ll need to make. You’ll also need to identify other sources of income in retirement, such as how you’ll draw income from the savings you’ve worked so hard to accumulate during your working years.
One crucial aspect of retirement planning that is frequently neglected is creating a retirement budget. That budget will be similar to — but different from — the spending plan you follow during your working years. That budget is critical because you can’t know how much income you need and for what until you understand what you’ll be spending in retirement. In other words, you can’t make a retirement income plan without putting a spending plan or budget in place first.
In this article, I offer three strategies designed to help you build a retirement budget. The first strategy covers the types of expenses you’re likely to have in retirement. The second strategy offers advice on how to prune that budget down to a worse-case scenario and up to a best-case scenario. Then, the third and final strategy helps you figure out the middle road that will position you to meet your essential needs while enjoying the extras that create retirement memories.
Strategy #1: Determine your expenses in retirement.
When it comes to your expenses in retirement, a decent rule of thumb is to count on 80% of the expenses you had while you were working. While that helps you get to an overall number, you still need to dig into the individual expenses that make up this number to be as accurate as possible. These expenses can change, especially if you’re planning on downsizing, moving and/or making major changes to your lifestyle in retirement.
Your expenses are also dependent upon the activities you will engage in during retirement. If you’ll be eating out more in retirement, that means you’ll need to increase your food and entertainment budget. Same with traveling, which can add up quickly.
I recommend that you divide your expenses into two categories, discretionary and non-discretionary. Discretionary expenses are those that are optional, like eating out and traveling. Non-discretionary expenses are necessary, like utility bills, car insurance, gas, taxes and food. Create a list of non-discretionary expenses and then a list of discretionary expenses. Then add them up and see what you’ve got.
If you’re planning on downsizing or moving, there will be some guesswork involved. For downsizing, you can estimate property taxes, utilities and other household-related expenses based on a percentage of your current expenses. Let’s say you live in a four-bedroom house on an acre of land now and plan to downsize to a two-bedroom condo. Check out the costs for the type of condo you’d like to buy and estimate based on that.
If you’re planning on relocating, analyze real estate listings and websites with cost-of-living information for that area. Then base your budget on some iteration of those numbers.
Strategy #2: Adjust for best- and worst-case scenarios.
Adjusting the spending plan you’ve just created for the best-case scenario is fun. Basically, you add the non-discretionary and discretionary budgets together. Then, you add on some spending that you’d love to do if you had the money. Maybe your original plan included a two-week trip to Europe. Your best-case scenario could include a month-long trip to Europe or a two-week trip at more expensive destinations and higher-priced hotels.
Or maybe you want to offer more financial help to your kids and grandkids, which you can’t really afford in your original spending plan. Add in some financial help in your best-case scenario — maybe paying for summer camp for your grandkids, taking the whole family on a Disney cruise or setting up a college savings plan for your grandkids.
Now, the worst-case scenario plan is not nearly as fun because it involves cutting as much as possible out of your budget. That means axing the travel, financial gifts to your kids and grandkids, the dining-out budget and so forth. Or maybe you preserve a bit of dining out in your budget — say, once a month — but get rid of the rest. The idea here is to ensure that your basic, essential expenses are covered.
Why is this worst-case budget necessary? For two reasons. First of all, your income may fall short of what your original budget requires. Even if that is not the case, unexpected expenses can arise in retirement that require significant cost cutbacks. Perhaps you or your spouse are diagnosed with a chronic illness that requires expensive, ongoing, out-of-pocket treatments or medications. Or maybe your adult child goes through a traumatic divorce or job loss and needs significant financial support that you feel obligated to provide.
Strategy #3: Fine-tune for a realistic spending plan.
With these three alternative spending plans at hand, you can combine them in a way that makes the most sense to you. If you’ve got a spouse or partner, make sure to include that person in your discussions as you finalize your budget. Not all spouses are on the same page about retirement activities or spending, so conversations to bridge any gaps are a crucial part of retirement planning. Maybe you’d like to downsize, but your spouse wants to stay in your current house. That’s something you must work out to ensure that whatever spending plan you come up with is realistic.
Remember, whatever spending plan you decide on is a snapshot in time. That plan can’t be engraved in stone because expenses are always changing, and retirement is a fluid process not a one-and-done event. For example, your plan may work for this year, but you’ll need to increase your costs to cope with inflation, which is the tendency of prices to increase over time. While inflation has historically been around 3%, in 2021 and 2022, inflation spiked to heights not seen since the 1980s.
There are other variables to consider in retirement, including the tendency for healthcare costs to increase as you age, especially into your 80s and 90s. In fact, Fidelity predicts that a retired couple turning 65 in 2022 needs $315,000 to pay for out-of-pocket healthcare costs in retirement, excluding long-term care.
The worst-case retirement budget is designed to help you cope with large expenses that you may not anticipate. You can also incorporate some higher costs within your original budget to account for variables such as inflation and retirement healthcare costs.
Your next steps
Creating a realistic budget is an important first step in retirement planning. Once you have a budget that you and your spouse believe is realistic, you can move on to align that budget with your sources of retirement income. Those likely include Social Security and retirement savings. You may also have a pension or other sources of income, such as rental properties.
Retirement has the potential to be one of the most rewarding phases of your life. Make sure to get a good start with realistic budgeting so that you’re headed in the right direction.
Amy Buttell contributed to this article.
This article was written by and presents the views of our contributing adviser, not the Kiplinger editorial staff. You can check adviser records with the SEC or with FINRA.
Get Kiplinger Today newsletter — free
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
With 40-plus years of experience in the industry, Chuck specializes in retirement planning and an outcomes-based approach to wealth accumulation and financial planning. Understanding and thoughtful, he is committed to always put clients’ needs first and providing them unbiased advice. His desire to spread financial literacy and to never stop learning drive him in his everyday responsibilities. He enjoys getting to know his clients and is energized by working with them and helping them find the right retirement strategies for their unique needs.
Licensed Insurance Professional. Respond and learn how financial products, including life insurance and annuities can be used in various planning strategies for retirement.
Securities offered through Geneos Wealth Management, Inc. (Member FINRA/SIPC). Advisory Services offered through Geneos Wealth Management, Inc. a Registered Investment Adviser.
-
CPI Report Points to Gradual Pace for Rate Cuts: What the Experts Are Saying
CPI Inflation surprised to the upside last month but the disinflation trend remains on track.
By Dan Burrows Published
-
Look Out for Scams and Price Gouging Amid Hurricanes
Storm fraud and price gouging are a real threat in the wake of a natural disaster. Victims of hurricanes Helene and Milton are being urged to stay on the lookout for rogue traders.
By Charlotte Gorbold Published
-
Come as You Are: Wealth Management for Gen X
Gen X is stuck in the middle of kids and aging parents, but retirement's not far off. Time to prioritize, with help from Nirvana, The Eagles and David Bowie.
By Alvina Lo Published
-
UTMA: A Flexible Alternative for Education Expenses and More
This custodial account can be used to pay for anything once the beneficiary is considered an adult in their state. There are some considerations, though.
By Denise McClain, JD, CPA Published
-
How to Create a Retirement Plan That Checks All Your Boxes
You might consider starting with a model retirement plan that has already been assembled and is ready to be refined to meet your objectives.
By Jerry Golden, Investment Adviser Representative Published
-
Why Gen X Marks the Spot for Rethinking Retirement
Retirement plans that worked for Baby Boomers may not fit the bill for Gen Xers. If you're nearing 60, it's time to bring your retirement strategy up to date.
By Chris Blunt Published
-
Want to Turn Your Tax Bill Into a Refund? What to Do Now
A few easy steps can help you avoid writing a check to the IRS. And if your most recent refund was a whopper, you might want to consider a few adjustments.
By Isaac Morris Published
-
FTC Cracks Down: Fake Reviews Officially a No-No
Companies can no longer buy and post online reviews that aren't by actual customers — and there's a hefty fine involved. Here's what to watch for.
By H. Dennis Beaver, Esq. Published
-
Election Could Reshape Opportunity Zones and 1031 Exchanges
Trump and Harris have divergent approaches to qualified opportunity zones and 1031 exchanges. See how each could fare under their administrations.
By Daniel Goodwin Published
-
Six Reasons to Have Life Insurance
The peace of mind from knowing your family is financially protected if something happens to you is invaluable, but there are other compelling reasons, too.
By Anthony Martin Published