Six Steps to Take if Your Insurer Sends You a Non-Renewal Letter
First and foremost, don't procrastinate. Let your insurer know you plan to fix whatever the issue is and then actually follow through on fixing it.
The insurance industry is in a state of flux. This means that you may find yourself having to shop around for a new policy due to being non-renewed, a price increase you feel is unjustified or even because your insurance company is leaving the insurance business altogether. Here is what to do, step by step, if you receive a non-renewal letter.
1. As soon as the non-renewal letter is received
Don’t wait, don’t delay, do not pass Go to collect $200. It is time to take action on your own behalf. You are now on notice that your insurer plans to not renew or keep your policy at its expiration date. The clock is ticking, and state laws differ, but you have a short window of time to take action.
2. Look for the reason for the non-renewal
When you receive a letter of non-renewal from an insurance company, they will tell you why. You may not like or agree with the reason, but you should not see a letter bidding you a fond farewell without some explanation. State regulations differ on the amount of detail provided at this stage, but you should have something to work with. Assuming the issue is something you have control over and are willing to correct, you will need to follow these next steps.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
For the sake of discussion, let’s say your non-renewal is due to some physical condition of your home. Perhaps your roof has missing tiles, you have an empty pool in the backyard, or trees are overhanging your roof. We can dispense with the rationale for why these are hazards to you and, by extension, your insurer for now. Suffice it to say, one of these is the provided reason for the non-renewal notice from your insurer.
Upon reading this, you say to yourself, “Self, I can fix this!”
3. Let the agent or broker and insurer know of your plans
While mindreading is a skillset I do not personally possess, some may claim to. Don’t assume that your insurance company will somehow magically know that today, on this very day, you received the letter of non-renewal and took it upon yourself to address the conditions addressed as concerns. You may know it, your significant other may know it, your neighbors may even see a contractor hard at work putting a new roof on your house. After all, who can miss the repugnant smell of tar and the rumbling of the barrel spinning when the roofers are hard at work?
Email your insurance agent or broker immediately. Don’t wait until the work is done, don’t wait until you decide which contractor to work with — remember the clock is running, and the sooner you make your intentions known, the better. I suggest you email and keep any reply you get from your insurer or its reps. Sometimes things get lost in the shuffle, and being able to pull up an email to show you reached out is priceless.
Let the powers that be know that you are in receipt of the non-renewal notice and confirm you understand what the concern is. Let them know you are going to address the issue and get proof of the fix to them within a specific number of days. Yes, give a date — don’t say you’ll let them know soon, or as soon as you can. Put a date on it and stick with that date.
4. Fix it
You may think this goes without saying, but trust me, it does not. You need to address what was listed in your non-renewal letter. Remember, you’ve made a commitment to remedy the problem, so follow through. There will be no trickery here — if XYZ is listed as the problem, you commit to fixing XYZ, and you are going to need to fix X and Y and Z. Not X and Y and figure that’s enough and that Z is OK. It most certainly will not be enough. Fix. It. All.
5. Get proof to the insurer and agent or broker
Now that you’ve spent your hard-earned cash to fix the problem, take credit for it. You did as you promised, so flaunt it. Do not assume that the insurance company will send someone to inspect and verify the work is done simply because you said you would do it. Sadly, many homeowners claim to do work and then never actually do it. Insurers know this from experience and can’t afford to send an inspector for every alleged physical condition correction.
Take pictures. Lots of them. Take some video — heck, do both. Leave no doubt that what was there and concerning is no longer. Get the proof to both the insurance company and the agent or broker.
Keep the email confirming receipt of your proof. Keep it all. Always.
6. Confirm reinstatement of your policy
At long last, it is time to see the fruits of your labor. You need to contact your insurance company and your agent or broker to get confirmation that your policy is no longer being non-renewed. This can sometimes be called “rescinding a non-renewal notice” or “reinstating a policy previously set for non-renewal.” We’re insurance peeps — we love to put fancy names on simple items. Bottom line: Get proof that you will not be non-renewed.
Congratulations! Never forget that you have more power with your insurance policies than you may believe.
Related Content
Get Kiplinger Today newsletter — free
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
Karl Susman is an insurance agency owner, insurance expert witness in state, federal and criminal courts, and radio talk show host. For more than 30 years, Karl has helped consumers understand the complex world of insurance. He provides actionable advice and distills complex insurance concepts into understandable options. He appears regularly in the media, offering commentary and analysis of insurance industry news, and advises lawmakers on legislation, programs and policies.
-
Lululemon Jumps to the Top of the S&P 500 After Earnings. Here's Why
Lululemon stock is soaring Friday after the athletic apparel retailer's beat-and-raise quarter.
By Joey Solitro Published
-
Should You Buy Pet Insurance?
You can fend off big veterinary bills with a policy that covers your furry companion.
By Donna Fuscaldo Published
-
Lululemon Jumps to the Top of the S&P 500 After Earnings. Here's Why
Lululemon stock is soaring Friday after the athletic apparel retailer's beat-and-raise quarter.
By Joey Solitro Published
-
Which of These Three Types of Soon-to-Be Retirees Are You?
Some folks are concerned. Others are lacking clarity. But what you really want to be is confident. So, how do you stack up?
By Sean P. Lee, MSFS Published
-
Will You Have a Retirement Income Gap? How to Fill It
To ensure your expenses in retirement are covered, you need to know what sources of income you'll have and where to turn to make up for any shortfall.
By Brian Teets, IAR, MBA Published
-
Who Works to Make Your Insurance Work?
Ensuring a smooth insurance process takes more than just your insurance agent or broker — many talented people are busy behind the scenes.
By Karl Susman, CPCU, LUTCF, CIC, CSFP, CFS, CPIA, AAI-M, PLCS Published
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Pause Near Highs Ahead of Jobs Friday
Investors await a key data set with sentiment still broadly positive.
By David Dittman Published
-
Is Coinbase Stock a Buy or Hold as Bitcoin Tops $100,000?
Coinbase stock has rallied in recent months as crypto prices pop. Here's what Wall Street says about COIN amid bitcoin's latest surge.
By Joey Solitro Published
-
Amazon Prime Flight Deals Offers $25 Plane Tickets for Young Adults
Amazon partners with StudentUniverse to offer $25 flights to young adults with certain Amazon Prime accounts.
By Sean Jackson Published
-
Why Analysts Say Five Below Is a Buy After Earnings
Five Below stock is higher Thursday after the value retailer beat earnings expectations and raised its full-year outlook. Here's what Wall Street has to say.
By Joey Solitro Published