Is Prepaid Wireless Making a Comeback — and Can It Lower Your Phone Bill?

A man using his smartphone to video chat

Rising wireless bills are pushing more consumers to reconsider traditional phone plans and explore lower-cost alternatives. Prepaid wireless, once viewed primarily as a budget option, is drawing renewed interest as shoppers look for flexible ways to cut recurring expenses without committing to long-term contracts.

Much of the growth is being driven by mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs), which lease network access from major carriers such as Verizon, AT&T and T-Mobile. Because MVNOs don’t maintain their own infrastructure, they can often offer comparable coverage at lower monthly prices.

With inflation continuing to strain household budgets, more consumers are embracing cost-cutting strategies, including switching to prepaid providers.

From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance

Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just ~~$107.88~~ $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues

CLICK FOR FREE ISSUE

https://cdn.mos.cms.futurecdn.net/flexiimages/y99mlvgqmn1763972420.png

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.

Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.

How prepaid plans differ from traditional phone contracts

Prepaid phone plans don’t require the long-term commitments that often come with traditional wireless contracts. While many postpaid plans require two- or three-year agreements, prepaid service allows customers to pay month-to-month, offering greater flexibility and easier plan changes.

Because prepaid service is paid in advance, it typically doesn’t require a credit check, and monthly line costs are often lower than traditional contracts. However, prepaid customers usually need to purchase their phones upfront, rather than financing a device through a carrier installment plan.

There are trade-offs to consider. Prepaid phone promotions are often less generous than postpaid deals, and data allotments may be more limited. Traditional plans also tend to include more bundled perks, such as streaming services or discounts for combining wireless and home internet.

Since many prepaid providers operate as mobile virtual network operators (MVNOs) that rely on major carrier networks, customers may also experience slower data speeds during periods of heavy network congestion.

How much you can save switching to prepaid

Some prepaid phone providers offer rates that are substantially lower than traditional contracts:

Cricket Wireless: Select Unlimited plan with unlimited data is available for $35 per month with Auto Pay
Metro by T Mobile: Unlimited 5G Data plan is available for $40 per month
Straight Talk: Silver Unlimited plan with unlimited data is available for $45 per month

Wireless service can be a major household expense. According to a J.D. Power study, the average monthly cell phone bill is $141, or about $1,692 per year.

By comparison, Straight Talk’s Silver Unlimited plan costs $45 per month, or about $540 annually. That difference could save a user roughly $1,152 per year.

Savings can increase for households that need multiple lines. Several prepaid providers, including Cricket Wireless and Metro by T-Mobile, offer multi-line discounts that lower the per-line cost.

Some plans price four unlimited lines at about $100 per month, which works out to roughly $25 per line. At that price, a household would spend about $1,200 per year for four lines of service, which can be significantly less than the cost of many traditional family plans.

How discounted phones are driving prepaid growth

One drawback of prepaid phone plans is that customers often need to purchase their devices upfront. However, longer smartphone lifespans and shifting upgrade habits are helping make that cost more manageable, allowing consumers to get more years of use from a single device.

Carriers are also helping offset upfront costs by discounting older flagship models. For example, Straight Talk Wireless offers promotional pricing on select iPhones for new customers, including the iPhone 13 for about $199, or as low as $149 when paired with a Silver Unlimited plan or higher.

Newer mid-cycle Apple models, such as the iPhone 15, typically retain their value due to strong durability and ongoing software support. These factors also contribute to strong resale demand, which can keep prices elevated compared with older devices.

Some prepaid providers also offer entry-level phone promotions. Straight Talk, for instance, advertises the Samsung Galaxy A17 5G as a free device when customers enroll in a qualifying unlimited plan.

Who benefits most from prepaid phone plans

Prepaid phone plans can be a strong fit for budget-conscious households, particularly those that need multiple lines, since multi-line discounts can significantly reduce the cost per user.

Seniors and retirees living on fixed incomes may also benefit from prepaid phone plans, which often provide a balance of affordability and essential features without long-term commitments. Teens and secondary phone users are another common fit, as prepaid plans typically offer talk, text and data at a lower overall cost.

Prepaid service can also appeal to travelers or individuals who want a backup or emergency phone. The lower monthly expense and flexible, no-contract structure can make prepaid plans a practical option for occasional or limited use.

When prepaid may not be the best option

Prepaid isn’t always the best option, though, and the plans aren’t a great fit for certain situations:

Heavy data users: Users who rely on data, especially during times of peak use, may find slower data speeds frustrating and limiting. While many prepaid plans include 10 GB of hotspot data, these plans won’t be a fit for individuals who frequently rely on their phones as hotspots or gaming.
Multi-line families: Prepaid multi-line plans offer additional savings, but they won’t always offer a better value than a major carrier’s family plan. Families who need to upgrade all of their devices might get a better deal from a major carrier.
Frequent phone upgrades: Individuals who like to frequently upgrade their phones could find prepaid plans to be limiting and expensive, especially if they’re looking for a top-tier device like a newer iPhone. Consumers who frequently upgrade phones may be better off with a plan from a major carrier that allows for upgrades every two or three years.

Tips for switching to prepaid without losing service quality

A person testing a mobile phone in store

If you’re thinking of switching to a prepaid phone plan, the following tips can help ensure you won’t lose your service quality:

Check network compatibility: If you want to bring your current phone, visit the carrier’s website and enter your device’s IMEI into their IMEI checker to make sure it’s compatible.
Evaluate coverage maps: Check the carrier's coverage map to make sure that coverage is available in the areas you use your phone most frequently.
Prepare to port your number: If you want to port your current number, check with the new carrier to make sure that it’s eligible. Keep your old service active until your number is ported, which can take a few hours up to a few days.
Avoid hidden fees: Many prepaid plans are upfront about fees, but some carriers still hide fees in the fine print. Carefully read all of the documentation available for the plan you’re considering, and look for extra fees like activation fees, taxes and surcharges and international roaming fees.

A prepaid plan can lower your wireless costs — in some cases by $1,000 or more per year — but it isn’t the right fit for every user. Before switching, consider how you use your phone day to day, especially if you rely on fast data speeds or frequent hotspot access.

Prepaid plans can come with trade-offs, including slower speeds during network congestion, fewer perks and less generous device promotions. Weigh those limitations against the savings to decide whether the lower monthly price is worth it for your needs.

Paige Cerulli is a freelance journalist and content writer with more than 15 years of experience. She specializes in personal finance, health, and commerce content. Paige majored in English and music performance at Westfield State University and has received numerous awards for her creative nonfiction. Her work has appeared in The U.S. News & World Report, USA Today, GOBankingRates, Top Ten Reviews, TIME Stamped Shopping and more. In her spare time, Paige enjoys horseback riding, photography and playing the flute. Connect with her on LinkedIn.