Q. Do you think that secular nonprofit institutions—universities, hospitals, private schools, art museums, even state governments—should pay real estate taxes to the local government?
A. Yes, for this reason: All owners of land and buildings in a community—whether for-profit or nonprofit entities—use the basic services provided by their city or county.
Because most of these services, such as sewers, roads, police and fire protection, are funded by real estate taxes, it’s reasonable that every owner should pay something. (That includes, in my view, a state government that owns land and buildings in one of its constituent local jurisdictions.)
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
But I am sympathetic to the desire of nonprofits, especially small charities struggling to raise money in these challenging times, to avoid bearing any new expense.
If the citizens of a city or county wish, they could vote to give local nonprofits some degree of discount from a normal tax bill. And they could phase in the new property taxes gradually. Many nonprofits, especially wealthy private colleges, already make substantial voluntary payments to local governments in lieu of property taxes.
Sometimes these negotiated amounts come close to the actual bill that would typically be levied on real estate of that value. But I think it would be cleaner if nonprofits were subject to formal assessments and taxation, at either a full or discounted level.
What about churches? I’d leave their present tax exemptions in place, because there is the potential danger of a government using its taxing power against an unpopular religion and violating First Amendment rights. But I would urge churches to make voluntary payments in lieu of property taxes.
As for income taxes, Congress gave all nonprofits a waiver in 1917, and state and local governments followed suit. That is fine with me. Charities are already subject to tax on their “unrelated business income”—profits from enterprises they run that are not directly related to their charitable operations.
-
Stock Market Today: Stocks Rise as Fed Rate Cuts NearThe main indexes closed out the day and week notably higher as excitement swirls ahead of next week's rate cut.
-
Where to Move Your Money Before the Next Fed MeetingTake advantage of high savings rates before the anticipated Fed rate cut next week erodes APYs and lowers returns.
-
Colorado’s New Property Tax Reform Could Save You HundredsProperty Tax The Centennial State just signed a new property tax bill into law. Here’s what you need to know.
-
Five New Tax Credits in Harris Economic Plan: What to KnowElection 2024 Democratic nominee, Vice President Kamala Harris has proposed several tax breaks. Here's what you need to know.
-
New York Sending School Tax Relief (STAR) ChecksTax Relief Are you receiving a NY STAR credit or exemption for your property taxes?
-
How the Election Could Impact the EV Tax CreditTax Credits It’s no secret electric vehicles have become a bit of a political issue. But what does that mean for your EV tax break?
-
How Trump and Harris Might Handle Expiring TCJA Tax CutsElection 2024 Many key provisions of the TCJA will expire soon. Here’s why it matters during the 2024 election cycle.
-
How Much Is the Child Tax Credit for 2024?Tax Credits The refundable amount of this tax break is slightly higher for the 2025 tax filing season. Here’s what you need to know.
-
New York Residents to Receive Child Tax Credit Checks in MailTax Credits The Empire State is sending millions of dollars — find out why and if it applies to your family.
-
$145 Million in ‘Senior Freeze’ Property Tax Checks MailedProperty Tax What you need to know about New Jersey's property tax relief program for older adults.
