With apologies to Shakespeare, to change a line from one of his greatest plays, "to Roth or not to Roth, that is the question/Whether 'tis better to suffer the tax now, and reduce my forture, or hold it tight..."
More than a few of us feel like Hamlet come tax time when we struggle with this question and think long and hard on it. As we get ready for Tax Day in April, it's good to review some of the advantages of suffering "the slings and arrows" of paying taxes now in order to secure future benefits.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Become a smarter, better informed investor. Subscribe from just $107.88 $24.99, plus get up to 4 Special Issues
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
First, there's that tax bite. Ouch. It's hard to let go of those funds when you could simply enter a traditional IRA contribution on Line 32 on the front of your 1040 for an immediate reward of less taxes. But you need to look ahead before doing that. You need to ask yourself when you have retired, do you expect your taxable income to be higher or lower than it is today?
As you are doing your taxes and comparing this year's tax bill and income to last year's, where do you stand? The goal is to pay the tax on the Roth contribution when you expect your tax bracket to be the lowest. If you are having a higher-income year, it may not be the best time to make a Roth contribution. If your bracket is lower in retirement, you may want to wait and work on a Roth conversion strategy at that stage of life. If this is the year your income is lower than you expect it will be in retirement, then by all means contribute to the Roth.
On the other hand, if your current tax bracket will be the same in retirement, it’s a wash and the old adage of putting off paying taxes as long as possible could be the right way to go. Looking ahead here could lead to another wrinkle. If you are married, the day will eventually come when one of you will pass on, leaving a single spouse. Tax brackets change dramatically when your status changes from married filing jointly to filing as a single taxpayer. You may slip into the next higher bracket even if you have lost some Social Security income due to your spouse’s passing.
The next question then becomes: Is it appropriate to convert some of the IRA funds into a Roth while you are in the lower married tax bracket, thus reducing taxable RMD income, in order to potentially reduce the impact of the higher tax bracket when the time comes that the survivor will file without the married benefit?
Also keep timing in mind. There is a five-year rule in play. While you can withdraw your contributions to a Roth without penalty or taxes at any time, the same is not true of the earnings. Think of it like a clock that says that you must have owned the Roth for five years and be older than 59 1/2 before the earnings may be withdrawn tax-free (there are some special exceptions that apply).
The actual wording of the rule states five “tax years,” which start Jan. 1 of the year for which you open and contribute to the Roth. If you open and contribute to the Roth by April 15, 2017, you can claim the contribution for 2016, causing your five years to start on Jan. 1, 2016. You have 16 months of actual time from the five-year wait. Subsequent new contributions and other Roths do not have their own five years (this is not addressing Roth conversions, which have a second five-year rule). It all starts when you open and fund that first Roth account.
Simply put, you could meet the five-year rule in as little as three years and eight months. Once you have opened and funded a Roth and met the time requirement, you have met it forever. Keep in mind this is a hard-and-fast rule. Should you pass away, the account still must meet the five -year rule before earnings, not principal, can be withdrawn tax-free for your beneficiaries.
Remember, due to your growth being tax-free, you should try to put your highest-earning and least tax-efficient investments in this account. Even with Tax Day looming, you might as well give yourself the most Roth reward possible. No point in playing Hamlet on this one.
See Also:Why You Need a Roth IRA
Nancy Fleming, CFP®, is the president of Fleming Financial Services, based in Gilbert, Arizona. She is an Investment Adviser Representative and licensed insurance professional.
-
Why Playing It Safe in Retirement Is a Big RiskFear of losing money could actually cost you in retirement. Find out why being too conservative with your life savings can hurt you and how to stop that from happening.
-
Tax Refund Alert: House GOP Predicts 'Average' $1,000 Payouts in 2026Tax Refunds Here's how the IRS tax refund outlook for 2026 is changing and what steps you can take now to prepare.
-
What Not to Do in an Airport LoungeBefore you settle into that cushy lounge chair, skip the rookie moves that annoy other travelers and can even get you kicked out.
-
Meet the World's Unluckiest — Not to Mention Entitled — Porch PirateThis teen swiped a booby-trapped package that showered him with glitter, and then he hurt his wrist while fleeing. This is why no lawyer will represent him.
-
Smart Business: How Community Engagement Can Help Fuel GrowthAs a financial professional, you can strengthen your brand while making a difference in your community. See how these pros turned community spirit into growth.
-
In 2026, the Human Touch Will Be the Differentiator for Financial AdvisersAdvisers who leverage innovative technology to streamline tasks and combat a talent shortage can then prioritize the irreplaceable human touch and empathy.
-
How Financial Advisers Can Deliver a True Family Office ExperienceThe family office model is no longer just for the ultra-wealthy. Advisory firms will need to ensure they have the talent and the tech to serve their clients.
-
Why Investors Shouldn't Romanticize Bitcoin, From a Financial PlannerInvestors should treat bitcoin as the high-risk asset it is. A look at the data indicates a small portfolio allocation for most investors would be the safest.
-
I'm a Financial Pro Focused on Federal Benefits: These Are the 2 Questions I Answer a LotMany federal employees ask about rolling a TSP into an IRA and parsing options for survivor benefits, both especially critical topics.
-
Private Credit Can Be a Resilient Income Strategy for a Volatile Market: A Guide for Financial AdvisersAdvisers are increasingly turning to private credit such as asset-based and real estate lending for elevated yields and protection backed by tangible assets.
-
5 RMD Mistakes That Could Cost You Big-Time: Even Seasoned Retirees Slip UpThe five biggest RMD mistakes retirees make show that tax-smart retirement planning should start well before you hit the age your first RMD is due.
