investing

Did Volatility ETFs Drive the Market’s Selloff?

These funds have no place among everyday investors

Rising U.S. Treasury yields were widely cited as the spark that ignited early February's sharp selloff in stocks. But the real damage, in my view, was caused by a handful of arcane exchange-traded funds and other products that let traders place giant wagers on the direction of the CBOE Volatility Index, known by its symbol VIX and often called the “fear index.” The good news: The selloff already may be finished. But regardless of whether it’s behind us, you certainly should stay away from these dangerous volatility ETFs.

The stock market’s volatility had been incredibly low the past two years as the market ambled placidly higher. Traders placed bets that the low volatility would continue. These bets were incredibly profitable. The ProShares Short VIX Short-Term Futures ETF (SVXY, $11.34), for instance, gained 80.3% in 2016 and 181.8% last year.

Little more than a week ago, the market suddenly turned volatile — and the funds imploded. ProShares Short VIX Short-Term Futures lost a hard-to-believe 89.7% last week. A similar exchange-traded product, the VelocityShares Daily Inverse VIX Short-Term ETN (XIV, $5.34), plunged 95.3%. The VIX itself rose almost 70%.

Why? As the bets on continued low volatility soured, traders dumped them en masse. Billions of dollars flowed out of the funds and VIX futures. The volatility ETFs’ prices cratered, putting massive buying pressure on futures and funds tied to rising stock-market volatility.

Most of the buying was “short covering.” When a trader or fund wanted to bet that the VIX would decline, it borrowed securities that would go up with rising volatility in the hopes of returning the borrowed shares at a lower price. When the bet on continued low volatility went dramatically wrong, the shorts were forced to buy securities tied to a rising VIX, thus propelling the fear index ever higher.

As that index soared, stocks unsurprisingly tanked. The VIX and the stock market typically move in opposite directions; said differently, the more volatile the stock market is, the more likely stocks will fall.

What’s more, traders who suffered big losses on their short VIX bets had often bought these funds with borrowed money. To repay the money, they sold stocks and other securities, accelerating the market selloff.

Have the sellers already exhausted themselves? Huge rallies Friday and Monday suggest that may be the case. No one knows how much margin (borrowed money) these traders employed in short-volatility VIX funds and other instruments, so some may continue to unwind their trades. But the damage done last week could well be the worst of it. One big caveat: Once a selloff starts, it can continue for a variety of reasons regardless of what initially triggered it.

The Aftermath of the Volatility Spike

At least one volatility ETF — VelocityShares’ XIV, which is issued by Credit Suisse (CS) — plans to liquidate on Feb. 21. Its prospectus allows it to close down after any one-day loss of 80% or more. Fidelity last week halted purchases of three volatility-focused funds.

I’d like to see them all closed. The Securities & Exchange Commission, in my view, should never have allowed these funds to be sold — especially to ordinary individual investors. They’re extremely volatile, serve little if any useful purpose, and as we saw, can cause real harm to the markets.

How many investors read the prospectus language that allowed the Credit Suisse ETN to fold after a one-day loss of 80%? The answer likely is “precious few.”

Even fewer probably understand the problems of daily compounding, which all these instruments employ because they set the same percentage of leverage at the start of each trading day. The prospectuses tell investors that these funds are to be used for one day or less. But, of course, few read the fine print, and many of those who do don’t heed the warning.

Daily compounding means investors are likely to lose money in these funds if they invest for very long, especially if their underlying index is volatile. The problem is simple arithmetic. Say you invest $1,000 in one of these funds and it rises 20% in one day. You then have $1,200. Suppose the fund loses 20% the next day. You don’t have $1,000; instead you have only $960. That process can erode your investment over time. You can make money over time in these funds, but only if their underlying index continues in pretty much one direction.

Plenty of leveraged funds using daily compounding have lost money in years during which the index they tracked (without leverage) finished in the black. For example, the Direxion Daily MSCI Emerging Markets Bull 3x (EDC), designed to deliver three times the daily return of the MSCI Emerging Market Index, has lost an annualized 2.7% over the past five years while the index has gained an annualized 4.6%.

If a couple of Wall Street traders spotted two birds perched on a wire, they’d likely bet on which bird would fly off first. These leveraged and inverse funds, in my view, do about as much good for economy as a bet on which trader wins the bird bet.

But, as we’ve seen, the funds can do enormous damage.

Steven Goldberg is an investment adviser in the Washington, D.C., area.

Most Popular

Refunds for $10,200 Unemployment Tax Break to Begin This Month
Coronavirus and Your Money

Refunds for $10,200 Unemployment Tax Break to Begin This Month

The IRS will start issuing automatic refunds sometime in May to people eligible for the unemployment benefit tax exemption.
May 1, 2021
Child Tax Credit 2021: Who Gets $3,600? Will I Get Monthly Payments? And Other FAQs
Coronavirus and Your Money

Child Tax Credit 2021: Who Gets $3,600? Will I Get Monthly Payments? And Other FAQs

People have lots of questions about the new $3,000 or $3,600 child tax credit and the advance payments that the IRS will send to most families in 2021…
May 4, 2021
10 Dividend Growth Stocks You Can Count On
dividend stocks

10 Dividend Growth Stocks You Can Count On

What should investors prioritize in dividend growth stocks? A history of aggressive payout expansion, and the ability to generate enough cash to keep …
May 3, 2021

Recommended

20 Best Stocks to Buy for the Joe Biden Presidency
stocks to buy

20 Best Stocks to Buy for the Joe Biden Presidency

We examine 20 of the best stocks to buy to take advantage of President Joe Biden's existing and expected policy initiatives.
April 30, 2021
Kip ETF 20: The Best Cheap ETFs
ETFs

Kip ETF 20: The Best Cheap ETFs

You can build a solid core for your portfolio and explore new opportunities with our favorite low-cost exchange-traded funds.
April 29, 2021
Ark Innovation ETF Delivers a Bumpy Ride
ETFs

Ark Innovation ETF Delivers a Bumpy Ride

Some of the fund's growth stocks, including Tesla, suffered recently as investors turned toward value-priced shares.
April 28, 2021
Buffered ETFs Can Limit Your Losses
Becoming an Investor

Buffered ETFs Can Limit Your Losses

The catch: You'll give up some gains in return.
April 28, 2021