Advertisement
credit & debt

Should Bank Customers Be Allowed to File Class-Action Suits?

Of the $185 million in the Wells Fargo settlement, most will go to government agencies as penalties. Very little will go to customers.

Question: I hear that a federal agency is about to allow bank customers who are victims of fraud and deception, such as Wells Fargo’s opening of 2 million unrequested accounts and credit cards, to use class-action lawsuits for redress, rather than arbitration. What do you think about this?

Answer: I’m appalled by these revelations of fraud, which were the result of bank executives setting unreasonable sales goals for low-level employees, pressuring them and giving them incentives to open the phantom accounts. Some 5,300 sales staff and managers were fired, and two top executives will forfeit at least $60 million in anticipated stock compensation.

Advertisement - Article continues below

But how to deter this behavior and also provide meaningful restitution to victims? The proposed solutions all have limitations. Of the $185 million in the Wells Fargo settlement, most will go to government agencies as penalties. Very little will go to customers—perhaps $5 million to reimburse unwarranted bank fees, or as little as $25 per account. The lion’s share of such settlements should go to victims.

Almost all consumer finance agreements (signed by customers when they open accounts) require that you settle disputes by arbitration rather than legal action. But few bank customers go to the trouble and expense of arbitration to recover small amounts.

Advertisement
Advertisement - Article continues below

That’s why the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau recently proposed a rule allowing bank customers to start or join class-action lawsuits. The rule will go into effect in a few months, unless it is blocked by Republican opponents in Congress. But such suits also have a fairness problem: They typically yield tiny restitution payments to the class members but generate huge fees for their lawyers (sometimes 25% or more of multimillion-dollar settlements).

I would prefer, instead, that the feds reform the arbitration clause in consumer finance agreements—requiring banks, for example, to pay for arbitration; permitting the customer to have legal representation; allowing all the remedies typically available in court, including punitive damages; and allowing customers to band together in a collective arbitration. That would help level the playing field for bank customers.

Have a money-and-ethics question you’d like answered in this column? Write to editor in chief Knight Kiplinger at ethics@kiplinger.com.

Advertisement

Most Popular

12 Tax Deadlines for July 15 (It's Not Just the Due Date for Your Tax Return)
tax deadline

12 Tax Deadlines for July 15 (It's Not Just the Due Date for Your Tax Return)

Between due dates for IRA or HSA contributions, paying estimated taxes and other deadlines, there's more to do by July 15 than just filing your federa…
July 10, 2020
65 Best Dividend Stocks You Can Count On
stocks

65 Best Dividend Stocks You Can Count On

These 65 Dividend Aristocrats are an elite group of dividend stocks that have reliably increased their annual payouts every year for at least a quarte…
July 8, 2020
Know Why Your Credit Score Changes: 9 Money Moves to Consider
credit & debt

Know Why Your Credit Score Changes: 9 Money Moves to Consider

Your credit score is a key indicator of your financial well-being and of the risk you pose to lenders. How good is yours?
July 10, 2020

Recommended

Know Why Your Credit Score Changes: 9 Money Moves to Consider
credit & debt

Know Why Your Credit Score Changes: 9 Money Moves to Consider

Your credit score is a key indicator of your financial well-being and of the risk you pose to lenders. How good is yours?
July 10, 2020
If You're Using Cash Less Often, You're Part of a Trend
Technology

If You're Using Cash Less Often, You're Part of a Trend

The pandemic is speeding up the use of digital payments.
July 2, 2020
The Best Bank Accounts for You
banking

The Best Bank Accounts for You

Kiplinger's contributing editor Lisa Gerstner joins our Your Money's Worth podcast to unveil the best banks for all kinds of savers. Also, our hosts R…
June 30, 2020
The Best Bank for You, 2020
banking

The Best Bank for You, 2020

We've identified the banks and credit unions that offer the best combination of high rates, low fees and a customer-friendly focus.
June 25, 2020