Getting the right tax advice and tips is vital in the complex tax world we live in. The Kiplinger Tax Letter helps you stay right on the money with the latest news and forecasts, with insight from our highly experienced team (Get a free issue of The Kiplinger Tax Letter or subscribe). You can only get the full array of advice by subscribing to the Tax Letter, but we will regularly feature snippets from it online, and here is one of those samples…
Roth IRAs are growing in popularity as more people are using them to help save for retirement. Although you can’t deduct contributions to a Roth IRA, the money inside the account grows tax-free. And there are no required minimum distributions for owners of Roth IRAs. Distributions of earnings after age 59½ are generally not taxable. You can also withdraw your contributions at any time on a tax-free basis and without having to pay a penalty. Similar to traditional IRAs, distributions of earnings from a Roth IRA before age 59½ are hit with a 10% additional tax or penalty.
But be sure you know the two five-year rules that apply to Roth IRAs. Failing to comply with the rules can result in a surprise federal tax bill. These rules can be complicated, but we break them both down for you with examples.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Five-Year Rule: Roth IRA contributions
The first rule applies to Roth IRA contributions and whether distributed earnings are tax-free to you.
Distributions of earnings after age 59½ aren’t taxed if at least five tax years have passed since the owner first contributed to a Roth IRA. The five-year clock for this purpose starts the first time money is deposited into any Roth IRA that you own, through either a contribution or a conversion from a traditional IRA (commonly known as a Roth conversion). The clock doesn’t restart for later Roth contributions or for newly opened Roth IRA accounts.
Here are four examples that illustrate the effect of this first five-year rule.
- Scenario 1: You are age 60 and you funded your first Roth IRA three years ago. In 2024, you take a distribution. You will be taxed on the earnings in the account because it’s been less than five years since you first contributed to the Roth IRA.
- Scenario 2: You’ve owned a Roth IRA since 2006. In 2022, you opened and funded a second Roth IRA. Because you funded your first Roth in 2006, you needn’t wait five years to take money from your second Roth for the earnings to be tax-free, provided you are at least age 59½ at the time of the distribution.
- Scenario 3: You did a partial Roth IRA conversion in 2015. You did a second partial Roth IRA conversion in 2021, when you were age 67. In 2024, you take a distribution from your Roth IRA. You will not be taxed on the distributed earnings because it's been more than five years since you first deposited money into any IRA (through the first conversion).
- Scenario 4: You did a Roth IRA conversion in 2012. In 2023, you opened and funded a second Roth IRA. Because you first deposited money into a Roth in 2012, you needn't wait five years to take money from your second Roth for the earnings to be tax-free, provided you are at least age 59½.
Five-Year Rule: Roth IRA conversions and the 10% early withdrawal penalty
The second rule applies specifically to Roth IRA conversions and whether the 10% early distribution penalty hits pre-age-59½ distributions.
This five-year rule doesn’t apply to new contributions to Roth IRAs but to conversions of pre-tax income from traditional IRAs to Roths. Under this rule, if someone under age 59½ does a Roth conversion, and later takes a distribution within five years of the conversion and before turning age 59½, then the amount of conversion principal that is withdrawn is hit with the 10% early distribution penalty. Once you turn 59½, you needn’t worry about this five-year rule, even if you take a payout before your conversion meets the five-year period. For example, there’s no 10% penalty if you do a Roth IRA conversion at age 57 and withdraw funds four years later at age 61. (However, based on the circumstances, the first five-year rule may apply to tax the post-conversion earnings).
This second five-year rule is essentially an anti-abuse rule to prevent people from circumventing the IRA early withdrawal penalty by first doing a Roth conversion and soon thereafter taking the money out of the Roth IRA. That's because the 10% early withdrawal penalty doesn't hit Roth IRA conversions.
Under this rule, each conversion has its own separate five-year period, which differs significantly from the first five-year rule discussed. For instance, if you do multiple Roth IRA conversions, there will be multiple five-year time periods, even if each conversion is done into the same Roth IRA account you owned for years.
Let’s illustrate this second five-year rule with two examples.
- Scenario 1: You are 52 and convert your traditional IRA into a Roth IRA that you have had for ten years. You will be taxed on the converted amount. Four years later, you liquidate the Roth. Your post-conversion earnings will be subject to ordinary income tax rates and the 10% penalty because you are not age 59½ at the time of the distribution. Additionally, your converted principal will also be hit with the 10% penalty.
- Scenario 2: You are 58 and convert a traditional IRA that you own into a Roth IRA that you have had for 16 years. You will be taxed on the converted amount at that time. Three years later, at age 61, you take a large distribution from your Roth. Your post-conversion earnings won't be subject to ordinary income tax because you first made a deposit into a Roth IRA more than five years ago. Your converted principal won't be hit with the 10% early withdrawal penalty because you are at least age 59½ when you take your Roth distribution.
This first appeared in The Kiplinger Tax Letter. It helps you navigate the complex world of tax by keeping you up-to-date on new and pending changes in tax laws, providing tips to lower your business and personal taxes, and forecasting what the White House and Congress might do with taxes. Get a free issue of The Kiplinger Tax Letter or subscribe.
Related stories
-
Farewell Paper I-Bonds: Savings Bonds Are Going Online-OnlyThe last remaining way to buy a paper savings bond in the U.S. (with your income tax refund) won't be available from January 2025. Tax filers will still be able to buy I-bonds online, however.
-
Is Medicare a Good Reason to Wait Until 65 to Retire?The average retirement age is 62, but many people wait until Medicare starts at 65. Should health care be the key driver of your retirement date?
-
Changes to Estate Tax Are Coming... Six Options Congress Could TakeThe Tax Letter An important estate tax change is looming. Here are six ways that Congress might address estate taxes in 2025.
-
Aging in Place Will Be Big Business for Home BuildersThe Kiplinger Letter Many people will be looking to make their homes aging-friendly in the years to come.
-
A Look at Kamala Harris's Tax Plans Ahead of the ElectionThe Tax Letter Under Harris's tax proposals, upper-income individuals would pay more taxes, while the middle class and lower-income people would pay less.
-
A Look at Donald Trump's Tax Plans Ahead of the ElectionThe Tax Letter We take a look at Donald Trump's tax plans and what they could mean for you. Here's what you need to know.
-
Understand These Hobby Loss Rules to Reduce IRS Audit RisksThe Tax Letter The IRS will scrutinize tax returns reporting large losses from any activity that sounds like a hobby. Here is what you need to know.
-
Landlord With Rental Income? See if You Qualify for a 20% Tax BreakThe Tax Letter Many landlords are eligible to take the 20% tax deduction for qualified business income
-
Five Ways to Fund Medicare Part AThe Tax Letter Higher taxes can help stave off the projected 2036 insolvency of Medicare's Hospital Insurance trust fund.
-
QCDs Are a Tax-Smart Way for Retirees To Donate to CharityThe Tax Letter With QCDs, retirees can save on taxes by making donations from their IRAs directly to charity. Here's what you need to know about qualified charitable distributions.
