What You Can Do if Your Insurance Company Cancels You
You might be able to address whatever reason your insurance company cites to non-renew your policy, but you'll need to act fast.

Relax, this isn’t going to be an article about cancel culture. I promise not to go there. Instead, let’s talk about a different type of cancellation — that being from your insurance company. Can an insurance company cancel your insurance policy or non-renew it at any time? What rights do you have if you receive the breakup letter in the mail? What can you do if you still love them and they don’t love you?
An insurance policy is a contract between you and the insurance company. I’m not an attorney, so without going into the details or specifics about contracts, let’s just look at it like it’s a simple deal. This deal says you agree to pay some money, and in exchange, if something occurs, the insurer agrees to pay you some money. At its most fundamental level, that’s what we’re agreeing to when we purchase an insurance product.
So moving along, you have made this purchase, or agreement, with an insurance company. And then one day you check your mailbox. OK, fine, you check your email. And you find this:

Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
Dear You,
RE: Notice of Non-Renewal of Insurance Policy No. 1234
We regret to inform you that your insurance policy, number 1234 with Your Insurance Company, will not be renewed upon its expiration. This decision is in accordance with the terms and conditions of your policy and is based on the following reason(s):
- Reason for Non-Renewal: e.g., change in underwriting criteria, increased risk profile, non-compliance with policy terms, etc.
In compliance with California Insurance Code Section 678.1, we are providing you with this notice at least 60 days prior to the expiration date of your current policy. This will allow you adequate time to secure alternative insurance coverage.
The insurance company is breaking up with you! This is a sample of what your non-renewal letter may look like. It will usually provide your information, the insurer’s information and the state law requiring the notification. So that’s it? Nothing left to do? Well, not entirely.
Renewing your commitment
First, understand that insurance policies renew. This means that every year (for annual policies), both you and the insurance company get the opportunity to renew your vows. Meaning you get to shop around, see if you want to keep your policy or get another, and the insurer gets to decide if it wants to continue working with you. Turns out, state laws do vary, and you will have more flexibility than the insurer will. In this case, the company has decided for some reason not to continue insuring you.
But what if the reason you’re provided is something you can control? Perhaps the company is saying it cannot insure you because you have recently put in a pool and it is unfenced? Or maybe a large tree has had a growth spurt and now hangs traitorously over your roof? If it is something you are ready, willing and able to fix, then by all means, fix it. However, at this point, you are on notice from the insurer. It’s outta here, so if you plan to take actions, then you need to immediately — as in yesterday — let the insurance company know.
The moment you receive a letter like this, reach out to your insurer or agent or broker and tell them your intentions. Tell them you plan to remediate the issues that are causing your policy to be non-renewed. Time is of the essence here. Don’t just do the work and then, the day before your policy cancels, expect to pick up the phone and say, “Hey, y’all, we’re good, we’re cool. I fixed everything,” and have it matter. You need to tell the insurance company what you plan to do and follow up with proof of what you actually did do.
Don’t leave things until the last minute
Also, be sure that you get the work and the proof to the insurer well before the stated non-renewal date. Hey, we all have our computers to contend with, and insurance companies are not immune to the fussiness they can present. Once your policy is marked “to be canceled,” it takes time to change that status, and, gasp, a human being has to — wait for it — look at your proof of the work done and approve it, too. All of this takes time. Do not wait, do not pass Go, do not collect $200.
Try to remember this mantra if you receive a non-renewal notice: SCORE.
S = Speak with your agent/broker or insurance company
C = Confirm work that you are going to get done
O = Offer to do the work
R = Receive proof of the work done
E = Ensure the insurance company has this proof
I like to get things in writing — it tends to keep people honest (not saying by default this isn’t true). If you have it in writing, though, let’s simply say that people are less able to forget things they stated.
Now, remember not all non-renewals will provide a reason you can fix. Sometimes items required are simply not reasonable or possible for you to get done, in which case the countdown clock is ticking, and you should be jumping on the computer and/or leaving no stone unturned to find a new insurer to provide coverage for you.
Related Content
Get Kiplinger Today newsletter — free
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger's advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and much more. Delivered daily. Enter your email in the box and click Sign Me Up.
Karl Susman is an insurance agency owner, insurance expert witness in state, federal and criminal courts, and radio talk show host. For more than 30 years, Karl has helped consumers understand the complex world of insurance. He provides actionable advice and distills complex insurance concepts into understandable options. He appears regularly in the media, offering commentary and analysis of insurance industry news, and advises lawmakers on legislation, programs and policies.
-
How to Delete Your 23andMe Data
23andMe is pursuing a sale after filing for bankruptcy, leading many customers to look into deleting their data from the company.
By Alexandra Svokos Published
-
Why You May Need a Medallion Stamp
Transferring securities from one account to another often requires this extra step.
By Emma Patch Published
-
Would You Benefit From Investing in Cryptocurrency?
Understanding the complexity of adding digital currency to your investments is critical, especially since drastic price changes can happen very quickly.
By Robert Cannon, MBA, CFF®, AIFA® Published
-
Why Company Stock May Be Riskier Than Employees Realize
Stock compensation has its perks, but employees must be realistic (and unemotional) about their investments' prospects. Sometimes strategic sales are smart.
By Michael Aloi, CFP® Published
-
Can You Be Fired for Going to Work When You're Contagious?
What's an employer to do when an employee shows up at the office with a cold or the flu and spreads germs to co-workers?
By H. Dennis Beaver, Esq. Published
-
Social Security Fairness Act: Five Financial Planning Issues to Revisit
More money as a public-sector retiree is great, but there could be unintended consequences with taxes, Medicare and more if you're not careful.
By Daniel Goodman, CFP®, CLU® Published
-
Social Security Warning: Five Missteps Too Many Women Make
Claiming Social Security is complicated, and for women the stakes are high. What you don't know can cost you, so make sure you do know these five things.
By Daniela Dubach Published
-
To Buck the Third-Generation Curse, Focus on the Family Story
The key is to motivate the next generations to contribute to the family business in a productive way. You can look to Lawrence Welk's family as a prime example.
By John M. Goralka Published
-
How Roth Accounts Can Ease Your Tax Burden in Retirement
Strategic Roth IRA conversions can set you up for tax-free income in retirement and a tax-free inheritance for the people you love.
By Jim Hanna Published
-
Are You a High Earner But Still Broke? Five Fixes for That
If you're a HENRY (a higher earner, not rich yet) but feel like you still live paycheck to paycheck, there are steps you can take to get control of your financial future.
By Mallon FitzPatrick, CFP®, AEP®, CLU® Published