If you feel as if your political view is encroaching on more and more of your life and this troubles you, perhaps stop reading now. If instead you’d like to find out how politics plays a significant role in the premium you pay for your insurance policies, then you guessed it, we’re off to the races.
Let’s start out with a little history. Historically, the position of insurance commissioner was one that was appointed. Although that may sound like you have little choice in the matter, the appointee is the governor of the state. All states in this country elect their governor. Therefore, whoever takes the role of the state’s insurance commissioner is directly connected to who resides in the governor’s mansion.
The insurance commissioner will likely share the same values, both social and fiscal, as the governor and be a member of the same political party. So you should expect the state’s insurance commission to tackle its job in much the same way as the governor. The short lesson here: Do your research and vote wisely.
From just $107.88 $24.99 for Kiplinger Personal Finance
Be a smarter, better informed investor.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more - straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice - straight to your e-mail.
There's another way
But what if I told you that 26% of the country has a more direct approach? Let’s find out what that is.
The residents of California, Georgia, North Carolina, Washington, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Mississippi, Kansas, Montana, Delaware and North Dakota — 11 states with 26% of the entire United States population — have a direct hand in who their state’s insurance commissioner is. “How can this be?” you may ask. Simple. They elect the insurance commissioner just as they would elect any other state official.
Yes, sirree, that means people running for that office put out political ads and billboards where they make promises about how they will tackle the state’s most complex insurance matters. They villify the “evil private insurance industry” and profess that only they and they alone have the knowledge and willpower to protect you and lower your rates.
Perhaps I am a tad jaded. However, in my 52 years on this planet, I have come to not entirely trust the promises from people whose names plaster the ballot. This will no doubt come as an entirely mind-bending concept, but sometimes they say one thing to get elected and then do the complete opposite.
In these 11 states, voters must really dig in, take the time to research and find out what their potential insurance commissioner is about. Don’t simply look at their party affiliation, as many will do (the CliffsNotes version of voter research). This may be one of the most significant positions you vote for, next to the president of the United States, and almost certainly the one who will have a financial impact the fastest.
What an insurance commissioner does
The state’s insurance commissioner has a boatload of responsibilities, including regulating the insurance companies it permits to do business in its state, protecting consumers, approving rates and underwriting guidelines, licensing agents and brokers, financial oversight, market conduct examinations, consumer complaints, enforcement actions, education and outreach and more.
If you look at a state like California, for example, the nearly 40 million residents create an economic footprint that is the fifth largest on the planet. Now, imagine how important it is to have someone knowledgeable and experienced handling that laundry list of activities. It is anything but trivial, and unfortunately, it tends to be one of those elected positions that does not generate sufficient public attention, considering its importance. On top of that, the election time can fall outside of the presidential election, when voter turnout is always lower.
Still unimpressed? The insurance industry in this country represents over $1.32 trillion in premiums paid as of 2021, employs just under 3 million and is comprised of almost 6,000 insurance companies. Insurers also hold a combined $9.5 trillion in invested assets. Face it, people: The main portal to the insurance industry is your state’s insurance commissioner, and you need someone who’s up to the task.
This is a coveted position of power
With so many changes happening that can have an impact on the insurance industry, the state insurance commissioner is a coveted position of power. In states where the governor hands out the power, you can bet there are many discussions occurring and promises being made. In the states where the residents choose who will lead, you can be sure there are likely more promises and deals being made.
This is serious business. It is incumbent on you to take your time to find out who you think will best conduct the marching band for the insurance business in your state. Get involved. Ask questions. Demand answers. Take notes. Remember. And finally, vote.
Related Content
- Estate Planning Strategies to Consider as Election Nears
- What Investors Should Keep in Mind This Election Season
- How Will the 2024 Election Impact Your Retirement?
- Five Tips for Choosing Your Insurance Agent or Broker
- When Is the Perfect Time to Buy Life Insurance?
-
Credit Cards That Actually Reward Your LoyaltyIf you have bank or investment accounts with your credit card issuer, you may qualify for extra cash back, waived fees and other benefits.
-
The 10 Most Valuable Vacation Destinations for Retirees in 2026Whether traveling within the U.S. or internationally, retirees can find a perfect blend of relaxation and excitement in these destinations, all while staying within budget.
-
Will Taxes Shred Your 401(k) or IRA During Your Retirement? It's Very LikelyConventional wisdom dictates that you save in a 401(k) now and pay taxes later, but turning that rule on its head could leave you far better off. A financial planner explains why.
-
More Retirees Are Renting: Should You? A Financial Adviser Weighs InIn some ways, renting is cheaper, more flexible and easier, but unless you understand the implications for your taxes and health costs, it might not be for you.
-
I'm a Real Estate Investing Pro: This 1031 Exchange Strategy Can Triple Your Cash FlowSavvy investors can use 1031 exchanges to unlock value by moving capital across markets in a play called geographic arbitrage. These tax implications can make or break the strategy.
-
I'm an Insurance Pro: Everyone Needs to Prepare for Earthquakes, Even if You Don't Live Near a Fault LineHere are my tips for what to do before, during and after an earthquake. The more prepared you are, the more you'll be able to keep your wits about you if it happens.
-
Where There's a Will, There's a Way Your Assets Will Be Distributed as You WishYour will is the backbone of a strong, adaptable estate plan that ensures what you leave behind goes to your selected beneficiaries. Without a will, state laws determine who gets your assets.
-
I'm a Financial Adviser: This Is What You're Really Losing if You Cut Back on Your 401(k) ContributionsMissing out on the benefits of the employer match and compounding growth could force you to work longer and lower your standard of living in retirement. Here are some alternative options.
-
Preferred Bank Stocks: The Investment Retirees (and Others) May Be Missing Out OnMost large banks issue preferred stocks that pay out fixed dividends, often with higher yields than bonds. Should you make room for them in your portfolio?
-
Don't Let Your Equity Compensation Trip You Up: A Financial Expert's GuideStock options, RSUs and other executive perks can come with some serious strings attached. To avoid a nasty tax surprise, you need a plan.
