How the Fed's Moves Affect You
It’s pumping trillions of dollars into the economy and keeping rates near zero. Savers are sunk, but borrowers get a boost.
Not all that long ago, the only major decision the Federal Reserve Board had to make was where to set short-term interest rates. But in the past decade, the Fed has become increasingly aggressive in its efforts to pump up the economy—and there’s no sign it will slow down anytime soon. Whether you’re a borrower, saver or investor, this matters to you.
Some history: As the economy cratered in 2008, the Fed made the unprecedented move of purchasing large sums of Treasury bonds and mortgage-backed securities, which pumped an extra $1 trillion into the economy. Over the course of the next 10 years, it purchased an additional $2.5 trillion. Then, when the coronavirus crisis hit, the Fed purchased another $3 trillion in bonds and securities, bringing its liabilities so far to a record $7.2 trillion. (The total size of the U.S. economy is currently $21.5 trillion.)
And the Fed isn’t done. It now has the authority to support up to $2.6 trillion in new lending, which includes making loans to businesses through its Main Street Lending Facility and lending to city, county and state governments through its Municipal Liquidity Facility. The Fed is also backing loans issued through the Paycheck Protection Program, a federal loan-forgiveness program designed to help small businesses survive the coronavirus pandemic.
As for interest rates, it’s likely they will remain low for a very long time in order to encourage borrowing and keep the money flowing. Fed chairman Jerome Powell announced at the June 10 meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee that the coronavirus could continue to have an impact on the economy for the next two years and that the Fed isn’t likely to raise interest rates until 2023 at the earliest. If inflation remains contained, rates could stay low for even longer. However, although the European Central Bank has experimented with negative interest rates by allowing commercial banks to borrow at negative 1%, the Fed isn’t inclined to go that far.
Good news, bad news. Borrowers will benefit from the low-rate environment. The 30-year fixed mortgage rate is likely to remain below 4% for the foreseeable future (although home prices typically rise faster when rates are low). Auto, home-equity and other consumer loan rates will also likely remain at historic lows.
The news is not good, though, for savers and income investors. Bank deposits, certificates of deposit and short-term U.S. government securities will pay almost nothing. Returns for longer-term government and corporate bonds will also be much lower than historical norms. Annuities and life insurance premiums will cost more, because the insurance companies that back those products are earning less in the fixed-income markets where they invest those proceeds.
The stock market has typically celebrated low interest rates, but low rates are a mixed blessing for investors in general. The stock market is now the only game in town for those looking for decent returns on their retirement savings. But without a bond market that provides a reasonable rate of return, it will be more difficult for investors to protect themselves from market downturns by investing in a mix of stocks and bonds. Investors seeking higher returns may be driven into much riskier investments, such as high-yield junk bonds, commodities and private equity.
Consider investing in high-quality dividend-paying stocks, which may yield more than fixed-income investments while providing some ballast in down markets.
The Fed's money machine
Unlike the rest of us, the Fed doesn’t have a budget constraint. It can buy assets by writing checks on itself. Because the Fed doesn’t ever have to pay off its liabilities, it can never go bankrupt.
So what’s to prevent the Fed from creating as much money as it wants? Again, nothing. The only problem with creating money is that it might cause inflation, as more paper and electronic dollars chase a slowly growing supply of goods and services. This is what has caused hyperinflation in smaller countries in the past.
But so far, that hasn’t been a problem. In the past decade, no matter how many securities the Fed has purchased, inflation has remained stubbornly low, breaching 2% only when oil price run-ups occurred. The mechanisms that drove inflation in past decades don’t seem to be working the same way anymore, and for that reason it appears that inflation is going to remain low for some time to come.